◄ IMDb Polls

Poll: The Critics and Audiences Agree...

A poll by rubyfruit76
The following movies have IMDb ratings and Metacritic scores that correspond exactly. Which movie did they get most right? You be the final judge: Which movie did the audiences and critics rate most accurately?

After voting, feel free to discuss here.

(Movies are listed in order of score/rating, from highest to lowest. There are several ties. Ties are listed in alphabetical order.) (Scores and ratings accurate as of July 1, 2021.)

Results of 406 votes:

  1. 1.

    The Godfather Part II (1974)

     
    Metacritic Score: 90 / 9.0 IMDb User Rating
  2. 2.

    The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002)

     
    Metacritic Score: 87 / 8.7 IMDb User Rating
  3. 3.

    The Departed (2006)

     
    Metacritic Score: 85 / 8.5 IMDb User Rating
See all results

Related Polls

IMDb Poll Board: Happy Valentine's Day!
A poll by BonaFideBOSS
IMDb poll board members wish you a happy Valentine's day, and have recommended these romantic movies to watch on Valentine's Day. Which one of these movies do you prefer the most? ? Discuss or Submit …
What is the Best Song From a Non-Musical Movie? (Part 2)
A poll by NarniaIsAwesome
A follow up to my previous poll of the same type. Pretty much all movies feature songs, but that doesn't mean they're musicals. A popular song (sometimes written specifically for the movie, sometime…
Movies that won both Song and Score
A poll by Paok-Kilkis
Which of these movies that won the Oscar for both best original song and best original score deserved it more? Discuss the list here!
Top 25 four-word movie quotes ...
A poll by ElMaruecan82
1,2,3-word quote, 4-word quote rock! Which of these classic four-word movie quotes, would you say, is the most iconic? Discuss here
Mickey Rooney Oscar Films
A poll by penchofifteenpolls
During his long career of more than 300 film, actor Mickey Rooney was involved in several Oscar nominated films. In which of his Academy Award recognized film do you think he had the most memorable ro…
AFI Top 100 Songs That Won an Academy Award
A poll by ethangentle
Which one of these songs in the AFI Top 100 Songs that won an Oscar for Best Original Song is your favorite? Discuss Here
American Film Institute's Top 35 Songs of All Time
A poll by ethangentle
Which one of these top 35 songs of all time according to the AFI is your favorite? Discuss Here in the IMDb Community Forums
Best Audrey Hepburn Movie
A poll by Paok-Kilkis
Which of these movies starring Audrey Hepburn is your favorite? Discuss the list here!
2014 Oscars - In Memoriam: The Films
A poll by ur44797245
These are the films that were mentioned in the montage shown at the Academy Awards ceremony. They are listed in the order in which they appeared in the montage, with the names of the person remembered…
Early to Screen and Early to Laugh
A poll by Chihir0
This is a list of Earliest Comedy Feature Films With At Least 25000 Votes which includes the period of 1921-1961. Which of the following movies do you like the most? After voting, discuss here.
Henry Mancini — Composer
A poll by mariojacobs
Henry Mancini (1924 – 1994) was a prolific American composer, conductor and arranger. Often cited as one of the greatest composers in the history of film, he won 4 Academy Awards, a Golden Globe, and…
Stuffy Gent and Daffy Dame
A poll by ur44797245
One of the mainstays of comedy is the pairing of a rather boring, conservative and traditional gentleman with an unconventional, crazy female. Which of the actors in these productions make the most en…
Run-Off: The Best Film Titles Part I
A poll by rubyfruit76
Excellent prose sometimes seems to be a dying art. The film industry, at times, does its part to revive it with great screen plays and, every so often, with exquisite titles from various sources, incl…
Epix's "Whole Lotta Love Valentine's Day Marathon"
A poll by yrnej
This February 14th, Epix is presenting a marathon of movie romances. If you could only watch one this Valentine's Day, which would it be? Discuss the list here
Run-Off: The Best Film Title Ever
A poll by rubyfruit76
Excellent prose sometimes seems to be a dying art. The film industry, at times, does its part to revive it with great screen plays and, every so often, with exquisite titles from various sources, incl…
IMDb Poll Board Favorite Original Song Oscar Win
A poll by Paok-Kilkis
The members of the IMDb Poll Board have chosen their favorite Original Song Oscar win. Which of their favorite Oscar win selections is your favorite too? Discuss the list here!
It's All Good in the Neighborhood
A poll by Hoekkie
To celebrate Tom Hanks' new film A Beautiful Day In The Neighborhood (2019), which movie about 'the neighborhood' or 'neighbors' is your favorite? You may discuss the poll here
IMDb Poll Board Favorite 1960s Movie
A poll by Paok-Kilkis
The members of the IMDb Poll Board have chosen their favorite movie from the 1960s. Which one do you choose? Discuss the list here!
Food For Thought
A poll by mpaxtonpolls
What is your favorite movie with a memorable scene where a food is present? Please discuss here after voting.
Best Soundtrack of the 60s
A poll by otter68
Which of these soundtracks from 1960s movies is the best? Discuss here 70s 80s 90s 00s

Clear your history

Recently Viewed