FILM: 7.5
When Rogue One: A Star Wars Story was announced, I was sceptical. After all, telling a story about a small moment in Star Wars history with the outcome already known didn't entirely sound exciting. Fortunately, it's about that, but it's about a lot of other things too.
The film delves into themes of ambition, destiny, resistance, and morality, examining these concepts quite well. It's better at exploring these themes than the prequels were. The action is excellent and quite visceral for a Star Wars film, making everything feel more tangible compared to the prequels. The ending is unique too, and stands out in the franchise.
The performances are all solid, with Felicity Jones being a fine lead. However, Diego Luna's performance doesn't wow me. Donnie Yen and Alan Tudyk, on the other hand, steal the show with their captivating performances. Mads Mikkelsen's brief appearances elevate the film, as he always does.
Despite these strengths, there are several issues. Even with extensive reshoots, there are some story moments that don't hold up to scrutiny. Would the film have been better in its original cut? Who knows. Still, the ending is extremely well done and offers some fan service, but it's delivered in a way that doesn't feel like pandering.
The film manages to balance its introspective themes with the excitement of the Star Wars universe. The exploration of these deeper themes, combined with the tangible action sequences, creates a compelling narrative that stands out within the franchise. In that respect, it does earn its right to exist.
In the end, Rogue One is a solid entry in the Star Wars saga. It's a film that offers more than just a small moment in history, exploring larger themes that resonate with the broader narrative of the series. Despite some flaws, it's a rewatch that I find both enjoyable and thought-provoking.
FORMAT: 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray
VIDEO: 9.5 Native 2160/24p presentation Detail level: Excellent Colour reproduction: Good Level accuracy: Excellent Encode: Good Master condition: Excellent
AUDIO: 9.0 Dolby Atmos audio Dialogue reproduction: Excellent Soundtrack & effects clarity: Excellent Dynamics: Good Surround sound presentation: Excellent LFE content: Good
MOOFIEMETER: 8.0.
The film delves into themes of ambition, destiny, resistance, and morality, examining these concepts quite well. It's better at exploring these themes than the prequels were. The action is excellent and quite visceral for a Star Wars film, making everything feel more tangible compared to the prequels. The ending is unique too, and stands out in the franchise.
The performances are all solid, with Felicity Jones being a fine lead. However, Diego Luna's performance doesn't wow me. Donnie Yen and Alan Tudyk, on the other hand, steal the show with their captivating performances. Mads Mikkelsen's brief appearances elevate the film, as he always does.
Despite these strengths, there are several issues. Even with extensive reshoots, there are some story moments that don't hold up to scrutiny. Would the film have been better in its original cut? Who knows. Still, the ending is extremely well done and offers some fan service, but it's delivered in a way that doesn't feel like pandering.
The film manages to balance its introspective themes with the excitement of the Star Wars universe. The exploration of these deeper themes, combined with the tangible action sequences, creates a compelling narrative that stands out within the franchise. In that respect, it does earn its right to exist.
In the end, Rogue One is a solid entry in the Star Wars saga. It's a film that offers more than just a small moment in history, exploring larger themes that resonate with the broader narrative of the series. Despite some flaws, it's a rewatch that I find both enjoyable and thought-provoking.
FORMAT: 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray
VIDEO: 9.5 Native 2160/24p presentation Detail level: Excellent Colour reproduction: Good Level accuracy: Excellent Encode: Good Master condition: Excellent
AUDIO: 9.0 Dolby Atmos audio Dialogue reproduction: Excellent Soundtrack & effects clarity: Excellent Dynamics: Good Surround sound presentation: Excellent LFE content: Good
MOOFIEMETER: 8.0.
Tell Your Friends