Dan's Favorite Reality TV Shows of the Past 25 Years - 1990 to 2015

by dgarling | created - 25 Sep 2015 | updated - 25 Sep 2015 | Public
 Refine See titles to watch instantly, titles you haven't rated, etc
  • Instant Watch Options
  • Genres
  • Movies or TV
  • IMDb Rating
  • In Theaters
  • Release Year
  • Keywords




IMDb user rating (average) to
Number of votes to »




Reset
Release year or range to »




































































































1. The Real World (1992– )

TV-14 | 30 min | Drama, Reality-TV

A new version of the long-running MTV reality show, which looks to unite people from different backgrounds and find a common ground.

Stars: Janelle Casanave, Alton Williams II, Arissa Hill, Brynn Smith

Votes: 4,284

The one that started it all, MTV's groundbreaking series where they put a bunch of people from different backgrounds together in a NYC loft, and watched what happened. Arguably one of the least contrived reality shows of all time in it's first season.

2. Road Rules (1995–2007)

TV-14 | 30 min | Adventure, Game-Show, Reality-TV

A diverse group of five to six people in their late teens to mid-20s are chosen to travel together in an RV, completing missions in order to receive a handsome reward. Each season's trip takes place in a different region.

Stars: Adam Larson, Shane Landrum, Susie Meister, Veronica Portillo

Votes: 584

Doubling down on the success of The Real World, MTV gave us Road Rules - introducing challenges, intentional conflict, and rampant hookups.

3. House Hunters (1999– )

TV-G | 30 min | Reality-TV

Hosted by Suzanne Whang, the show takes viewers behind the scenes as individuals, couples and families learn what to look for and decide whether or not a home is meant for them.

Stars: Andromeda Dunker, Suzanne Whang, David Bromstad, Andrea Carollo

Votes: 1,862

A mesmerizing series that sucks you in and makes you scream at the TV to "Pick the Second One you idiot!" as new home buyers navigate the confusing world of real estate and select the home of their dreams - from three choices. The early episodes with Suzanne Whang are among my favorites.

4. Survivor (2000– )

TV-PG | 60 min | Adventure, Game-Show, Reality-TV

A reality show where a group of contestants are stranded in a remote location with little more than the clothes on their back. The lone survivor of this contest takes home a million dollars.

Stars: Jeff Probst, Lillian Morris, Jon Dalton, Rob Mariano

Votes: 27,445

I used to get together with my friends EVERY WEEK to watch Survivor together, eat junk food, and enjoy as the clean cut and well fed contestants transformed through the season to leaner, dirtier, and arguably sexier versions of themselves... and eat bugs and balut and other horrible things.

5. Temptation Island (2001–2003)

TV-14 | 60 min | Reality-TV

A real-life dramatic series where boyfriends/girlfriends travel to a romantic place to quiz and fascinate the strengths of their relationships. Once the location has been selected, the ... See full summary »

Stars: Mark L. Walberg, Catherine Chiarelli, Nikkole Palmatier, Genevieve Deittrick

Votes: 493

The oft forgotten show where couples were taken to a tropical island, split apart, and thrown into a shark tank of bloodthirsty, sexy singles set on breaking them up permanently.

6. The Anna Nicole Show (2002–2004)

TV-MA | 30 min | Comedy, Reality-TV

Reality show starring everyone's favorite plus sized model Anna Nicole Smith!

Stars: Anna Nicole Smith, Daniel Smith, Howard K. Stern, Kim Walther

Votes: 834

The show that introduced us to the tragic beauty of Anna Nicole.

7. America's Next Top Model (2003–2018)

TV-PG | 42 min | Game-Show, Reality-TV

A cyclical competition in which women from all over the U.S. compete for the honor of being America's next "it girl" in the modeling world.

Stars: Adrianne Curry, Yoanna House, Tyra Banks, J. Alexander

Votes: 18,464

ANTM has taught an entire generation to smile with their eyes. Nuff said.

8. The Simple Life (2003–2007)

TV-14 | 22 min | Comedy, Reality-TV

Paris and Nicole accept various internships along the East Coast. Hilarity ensues as the girls leave their limos behind and travel by Greyhound bus.

Stars: Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie, James DuMont, David Richards

Votes: 5,909

Even though we couldn't figure out why they were famous, watching socialites Paris Hilton and Nicole Ritchie "slumming it" with regular people was a wonderful guilty pleasure.

9. Queer Eye (2003–2007)

TV-14 | 60 min | Comedy, Reality-TV

Five gay men try to improve the lives and confidence of straight men by giving them makeovers and advice.

Stars: Ted Allen, Carson Kressley, Kyan Douglas, Thom Filicia

Votes: 2,537

Perhaps reinforcing some stereotypes, but still entertaining to watch as five gay men - each specializing in one area - coach a straight guy on grooming and culture.

10. Extreme Makeover: Home Edition (2003–2020)

TV-PG | 60 min | Comedy, Drama, Family

A family that has faced hardship has their dilapidated house completely rebuilt while they are away on vacation for a week.

Stars: Ty Pennington, Paul DiMeo, Michael Moloney, Tracy Hutson

Votes: 4,866

In those early years, I ended every episode in tears, watching families who had endured heartbreaking situations were given houses built to fit their unique needs by Ty Pennington and his band of hyperactive builders and designers.

11. What Not to Wear (I) (2003–2013)

TV-PG | 60 min | Family, Reality-TV

Two fashion stylists and a team of hair and makeup advisors help revamp the look of individuals who have been nominated by their friends for makeovers due to their lamentable appearance, using a $5,000 budget.

Stars: Adam J. Harrington, Clinton Kelly, Stacy London, Carmindy

Votes: 1,890

Clinton and Stacey work miracles on this show as they find people with shockingly bad style and teach them ways to dress that complement their bodies and elevate their confidence.

12. Project Runway (2004– )

TV-PG | 60 min | Reality-TV

Aspiring fashion designers compete for a chance to break into the industry in this reality competition. Each week, a designer is eliminated from the competition after exhibiting their work in front of a judges' panel.

Stars: Nina Garcia, Tim Gunn, Heidi Klum, Michael Kors

Votes: 11,666

The reason I got cable TV and a DVR, so I'd never miss an episode. I learned to sew thanks to the inspiration, and watched it religiously (until it went to Lifetime).

13. The Swan (2004–2005)

TV-14 | 60 min | Reality-TV

A reality show about an ugly duckling turned beautiful swan, only it's a woman giving herself a physical makeover with plastic surgery, to compete in a beauty pageant.

Stars: Terry J. Dubrow, Amanda Byram, Nely Galan, Greg Comeaux

Votes: 529

A train wreck of low self esteem, as women compete to transform into beauty pageant contestants via plastic surgery and fitness regimens. Hard to watch but impossible to stop watching.

14. The Girls Next Door (2005–2010)

TV-PG | 22 min | Comedy, Reality-TV, Romance

An inside peek at what really goes on inside the Playboy Mansion, starring Hugh Hefner's then three main girlfriends Holly Madison, Bridget Marquardt and Kendra Wilkinson.

Stars: Hugh Hefner, Holly Madison, Bridget Marquardt, Kendra Wilkinson

Votes: 4,062

Hugh Hefner's three girlfriends, Bridget, Holly & Kendra navigating polyamory, pool parties, and photo shoots. I thought I'd hate it, but absolutely fell in love with two of the three girls, watching their spin-offs after they left the mansion.

15. Kept (2005– )

Reality-TV

Former model Jerry Hall tries to turn all American boys into refined British gentlemen in this VH1 reality series.

Stars: Glenn Kinsey, Devonric Johnson, Jerry Hall, Austen Earl

Votes: 60

Jerry Hall - Mick Jagger's ex-wife - coaching and testing a group of American men to decide which would become her kept man. Wonderfully different in a sea of shows about pretty women.

16. Top Chef (2006– )

TV-14 | 44 min | Game-Show, Reality-TV

A reality competition show in which chefs compete against one another in culinary challenges and are a judged by a panel of food and wine experts, with one or more contestants eliminated each episode.

Stars: Tom Colicchio, Padma Lakshmi, Gail Simmons, Richard Blais

Votes: 6,848

The show that inspired me to cook and blog, taught me to talk about food, and introduced me to celebrity chefs and up and comers and fine dining. After a slow first season, the switch to Padma Lakshmi as the host elevate the show immensely, and her banter with Tom and Gail is wonderful.

17. Man vs. Wild (2006–2020)

TV-PG | 60 min | Adventure, Reality-TV

Bear Grylls travels the world in search of challenges to his survival skills.

Stars: Bear Grylls, Chris Kratt, Will Ferrell, Sean Lacoste

Votes: 23,273

Sexy, sexy Bear Gryllis drinking his own pee, eating frogs, holding his breath and falling down hillsides.

18. Sunset Tan (2007– )

Reality-TV

A look at the lives and loves of employees and clients of a Los Angeles tanning salon.

Stars: Erin Tietsort, Nick D'Anna, Janelle Perry, Devin Haman

Votes: 385

A perfect summer diversion in 2007, watching "The Ollys" and the rest of the vapid staff at a tanning salon fight and argue and bicker and occasionally spray a customer with tanning solution.

19. DogTown (2008–2010)

46 min | Documentary

DogTown documents the work of Best Friends Animal Sanctuary, where trainers and vets rescue and rehabilitate dogs no one else wants. Follow the stories of dogs and the people who love them enough to give them a second chance at life.

Stars: Chuck Thompson, Sherry Woodard, John Garcia, Pat Whitacre

Votes: 83

A tear-jerking show following the dogs and trainers at a massive no-kill shelter that tries to rehabilitate some of the most damaged dogs.

20. RuPaul's Drag Race (2009– )

TV-14 | 63 min | Game-Show, Reality-TV

RuPaul searches for America's next drag superstar.

Stars: RuPaul, Michelle Visage, Ross Mathews, Jason Carter

Votes: 23,425

The show that introduced drag to the masses, and has caused an explosion in the number of drag queens and the variety of drag queens in the world... and inspired me to learn a trick or two about beating my face.

21. The Colony (2009– )

TV-14 | Reality-TV

A group of strangers gathered for three months to test out the concept of rebuilding civilization.

Stars: Michael Raines, Joey Sciacca, John Valencia, Sian Proctor

Votes: 1,997

Like Survivor, but in the city - watching as a bunch of specialists from various fields apply their knowledge and test their people skills as they try to survive a post disaster, off grid world.

22. Oddities (2010– )

22 min | Reality-TV

New York City's Obscura Antiques & Oddities ain't your grandmother's antique shop unless your grandmother is an eccentric. Oddities follows this unique store as it deals in the strange and the bizarre, item-wise and client-wise.

Stars: Evan Michelson, Mike Zohn, Ryan Matthew, Ersan Bajramoski

Votes: 736

Taxidermy, antique medical equipment, human remains and everything in between are bought and sold at this NYC shop, with the customers arguably more interesting than the things they come to the shop to buy and sell.

23. Face Off (2011–2018)

TV-PG | 44 min | Game-Show, Reality-TV

Special effects make up artists compete in challenges.

Stars: McKenzie Westmore, Glenn Hetrick, Ve Neill, Michael Westmore

Votes: 7,253

A dream job of mine, watching season after season of make-up artists transform models into aliens, animals and accidents keeps me up late every week and inspires my own costumes and makeup.

24. Ink Master (2012– )

TV-14 | 60 min | Game-Show, Reality-TV

Ten of the country's most creative and skilled tattoo artists are judged by icons of the tattoo world. They compete for a hundred thousand dollars and the title of "INK MASTER".

Stars: Dave Navarro, Oliver Peck, Chris Nunez, Rick Robles

Votes: 4,738

One of the most antagonistic, arrogant groups of contestants on TV, I can't stop watching every week as tattoo artists apply amazing and awful ink to "human canvasses" who inexplicably agree to be permanently altered.

25. The Quest (2014– )

42 min | Adventure, Fantasy, Game-Show

Fantasy meets reality as 12 contestants engage in epic challenges in the world of "Everealm", and compete to avoid "banishment" in order to become the one true hero that will save the kingdom.

Stars: Stephanie Nur, Florence Kasumba, Douglas Tait, Mai Duong Kieu

Votes: 1,369

One of the highest production value and least appreciated reality shows I know of, a bunch of fantasy buffs live on what amounts to a Lord of the Rings set for weeks as they compete to save the kingdom from dark forces, and to be the last champion standing.



Recently Viewed