I watched this movie probably for the first time ever in 2023. I thought I had seen it before, but after watching it I realize I didn't really remember any of it. With that said, I think what makes this movie such a cult classic is the famous director and the famous lines and stills, from "red rum", to the identical twins and bleeding elevators, to "here's Johnny" and the hedge maze scene. The story is truly all over the place and leaves the watcher guessing a lot on what is actually going on and who's going mad. Honestly, I don't think it was as good as the hype I've heard about it, though I did enjoy the classic scenes.
But honestly as a movie is has a ton of plot holes. The hotel is apparently haunted, and it's mentioned that it's built on an ancient Indian ground which is probably the reason. But the gift the boy and Halleran share called the Shining really doesn't make any sense with the movie. The boy has the ability to see things in the past and in the present in short glimpses, and also can communicate with other people with the gift. Ok, but what does that have to do with a haunted hotel? He hardly uses it for anything in the movie. Plus the imaginary friend Tony is never explained, and really has no point in the movie at all. The whole thing is just meant to confuse you. The scenes from the naked woman in room 237 who turns ugly, to the man wearing a pig mask near the end, and the skeletons in one of the rooms, it's as if Kubrick just took a mash of a million movies and threw them into one just to confuse the hell out of the viewer with none of it making any sense. I thought Halloran being called to the hotel would've resulted in something a little more than him being immediately killed...in the end the Shining gift Danny possesses was pointless and made no sense in the movie at all.
All in all I didn't find this movie to be very classic or even great with the exception of the classic scenes that have grown iconic for some reason over the years. The movie itself wasn't scary at all and made no sense. In the end we find that a man who looks just like Jack ran the hotel back in 1921. Umm...ok?? More unanswered questions. Not as great as people say it is. I'm not sure why this was ever a classic.
5 out of 8 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends