Wow, this show is way overhyped with the ratings on here and on IMDb. It took a bit to get used to the black and white-bordering-on-sepia filter but it does work once you're immersed in the story conflict of the ongoing deception and murderings by Tom Ripley. Andrew Scott is average as Ridley but not awards-worthy, but I prefer Matt Damon's version, he fits the character more and isn't the character supposed to be a little younger and less traveled in a sense? Again, I have the same sentiment with the other main/supporting characters, Dickie Greenleaf and Marge. I prefer the performances of Jude Law and Gwyneth Paltrow in the 1999 film version by Anthony Minghella. It makes more sense for Dickie to be a selfish, vapid playboy (in the show, he is not a playboy, much less wild, and more genuine) and for Marge to be naïve and kind in the beginning to Tom versus in the show, she already is suspicious of his motives from the get-go and standoffish. I also didn't like Dakota Fanning's performance of Marge. It was too cold, void of general emotion, just a really empty performance (a prime example that child actor stardom doesn't translate to the same caliber of adult acting performances).
Overall, the film carried more natural, emotionally nuanced performances vs in this TV series. Just like the film, the show had good usage of authentic '50s costumes, quality cinematography, filming locations were spot-on, and I do like that spoken Italian language was interweaved in the dialogue (where there was less of this in the film version).
After watching this TV adaptation of Ripley, it makes me appreciate the quality of filmmaking, directing, and performances in the 1999 version. I really believe the distinctive failure of the show is making Dickie such a two-dimensional and too nice of a character so that when Ripley murders him for less of a believable motive other than he wants his money and to steal his identity and secure the life he covets, viewers are left with hating Ripley. Whereas the film is the opposite, viewers are glad in a way that Ripley killed Dickie and this leads to viewers questioning and thought-provoking commentary on rooting for a morally ambiguous character that we sometimes can't help feel sorry for despite all the bad things he's done. But the show does get right, just as the film did, that ultimately Ripley is trying to survive no matter what it takes to get there. Goes to show that you can't recreate crime drama greatness in the same way all these years later in a Netflix show on the same story and characters lol. So obviously, I recommend watching the 1999 film version over this show.
Overall, the film carried more natural, emotionally nuanced performances vs in this TV series. Just like the film, the show had good usage of authentic '50s costumes, quality cinematography, filming locations were spot-on, and I do like that spoken Italian language was interweaved in the dialogue (where there was less of this in the film version).
After watching this TV adaptation of Ripley, it makes me appreciate the quality of filmmaking, directing, and performances in the 1999 version. I really believe the distinctive failure of the show is making Dickie such a two-dimensional and too nice of a character so that when Ripley murders him for less of a believable motive other than he wants his money and to steal his identity and secure the life he covets, viewers are left with hating Ripley. Whereas the film is the opposite, viewers are glad in a way that Ripley killed Dickie and this leads to viewers questioning and thought-provoking commentary on rooting for a morally ambiguous character that we sometimes can't help feel sorry for despite all the bad things he's done. But the show does get right, just as the film did, that ultimately Ripley is trying to survive no matter what it takes to get there. Goes to show that you can't recreate crime drama greatness in the same way all these years later in a Netflix show on the same story and characters lol. So obviously, I recommend watching the 1999 film version over this show.
Tell Your Friends