With Robert Rodriguez's name attached to this movie I was completely game and looking forward to this new Predator movie. Reading production notes and the like, it seemed that there was hope for this one to be a great rehash. In the end Predators was a stretched out movie borrowing most of its ideas from the first and ONLY predator film.
I'm a huge fan of the original Predator. What John Mctiernan did with Predator was nothing short of genius which is why I think all of the Predator movies since have fallen short in its wake. In that light here is my opinion of why Predators has ultimately tried and failed.
With science fiction often times less is more. When one has to start asking too many questions the genre losses its appeal. Predators was introducing to many questions into the Predator lore that in my opinion was like re-writing the whole legend itself. Apparently the time and energy to find elite fighters on earth, kidnap them and do it all so that they do not know what is going on is worth the trouble of placing them on a foreign planet in order to hunt them. The mystery of how the predators work in the first movie is what really made it great. We did not know where they came from, how intelligent and so on. Predators offered us a little too much. Keep Predators mysterious! That's why we love them.
Another aspect making Predator a great movie was the outstanding score by Alan Silvestri. A movies score is meant to compliment and help progress the story. In lieu of Alan Silvestri John Debney would be scoring Predators. He said he would incorporate parts of the original score for this film. Well not only did he incorporate but he flat out stole most of the score which to me is fine because I love the original but each movie has its own tone and story which should be accompanied by the right score. John Debney seemed confused about where to take the score with this movie, which I don't blame him because the story was a backyard version of the original movie. Borrowing too much from the original score is not going to make the movie work. Writing an original score perhaps inspired by Alan's could have helped.
I think there also is something to be said about Robert Rodriguez not directing this and only standing by as producer. The use of the right lenses and close up shots was perfectly mixed in Predator however in Predators shots were impersonal and not thought out too well. I felt the director tried to cram too much in many of the shots. Help the actors with the lens, don't leave them bare, fighting for the scene.
Lastly I will say that there were too many characters with too little development for each of them. You can only press a good actor to do so much with a faulty script. It also helps to let the audience figure out the story and not be told directly by the main characters what's going on, we are not idiots Hollywood! I can tell that Robert Rodriguez had the first predator fresh in his mind when he wrote this script because there were many similarities: jungles, falling off waterfalls, hand held mini gun, military folk, come on Robert, shame on you dude.
The movie had some fun moments but in no way was it the kick-butt Predator movie I and so many others were hoping for. 6-6.5 out of 10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends