Picturesque Udaipur (1939) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Does James A. Fitzpatrick Disapprove?
boblipton26 October 2019
Fitzpatrick sends the Technicolor cameras under the supervision of Hone Glendinning to Udaipur in India, to give us some interesting pictures of the Indian city and its suburbs. Some nice pictures show up, along with some odd local customs, like feeding wild boars.

Usually, Mr. Fitzpatrick had only nice things to say about his cinematic subjects. This time, though, I thought I detected a sense of unease. It's not simply that he uses the word "picturesque" a lot; I have concluded that when people talk about buildings that way, it means they look nice, considering they're old and broke. He talks about all the cattle wandering around the city, as wasted beef on the hoof, seems to call attention to the segregation of the castes in a manner that indicates that he doesn't disapprove, and tells us that people in India look down on farmers. That's something that hard-working Americans would think nonsense.

Perhaps, though, I am stretching. He so often simply rhapsodizes over the beauty of things that any comment that isn't fawning seems disapproving.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
1930s India
nickenchuggets13 July 2022
If you've seen TravelTalks playing on TCM at the end of many a film, you should know the drill by this point. James Fitzpatrick travels to a random area on the Earth, records important historical landmarks of a particular place, and gives details about what makes the place special. This time we're in India; the city of Udaipur to be exact. He starts off by saying there's a prevailing myth about this place that involves a girl acquaintance of one of its rulers. She was told she could live in a palace with him so long as she was able to cross a large lake on a tightrope. She actually almost managed to do it apparently, but the rope was cut by someone who wasn't a fan of the leader's proposal to her, and she drowned. We then see cows on the streets of the city and are told that because they're considered sacred, they can do as they please. One is shown stealing a cabbage from a produce salesman, but she doesn't get away with it. We also learn some things about Hinduism, one of which seems grossly unjust to me. Fitzpatrick says how in the indian caste system, the dregs of society, the people with nothing going for them, do all the hard work. This might not be surprising, but he then goes on to explain how you aren't meant to pity them because of the concept of reincarnation. Hindus believe that these people have such miserable existences now because they are being punished for some bad thing they committed in a previous life. Therefore, the people on the bottom of society's totem pole deserve to be in the position they're in. We're also shown some of the city's architecture, a lot of it being many centuries old. Like most TravelTalks, there isn't a whole lot to comment on with this. I liked the visuals, but the narration seems to have a droning effect on me (and most people) after a while it seems. I think this mindset of liking what's being displayed on the screen the most and placing that alone above all the other things shown applies to most of these shorts.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
color and the past
SnoopyStyle26 October 2019
This is a James A. FitzPatrick Traveltalks episode showing the beautiful Indian location. It's in color which is very helpful in the brightly colored turbans. It has loads of street life which is a great insight into colonial India. The narration does get into a lot of Hindu religion and practices. It's a little awkward to hear it from an old white British voice which sometimes seem condescending. It's a snapshot of the past with a voice from the past.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
TravelTalks
Michael_Elliott29 November 2011
Picturesque Udaipur (1939)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Nice entry in MGM's TravelTalks series has James A. FitzPatrick telling us the story of Udaipur, a city in India that's the home to a million and a half people. We start off learning about an old legend involving a tightrope walking female who was offered a place inside the mansion if she could walk across a rope stretched across a lake. Just as she was about to finish the job one of the man's "friends" cut the rope, which caused the woman to drown and we're told that her ghost could still be seen. From here we learn about the Hindu religion and the cows that freely roam the busy streets. We learn that in all cases the cow has the right of way no matter where it is. Also we learn about turbans and how the red ones are the most popular. Other subjects include the street musicians, how women do most of the hard labor and why bathing and washing in lakes is so important. Overall this is another pleasant entry in the series and if you're already familiar with it then you know the Technicolor is one of the best things as it perfectly brings the city to life. As usual we get some pretty good stories and even though I've seen dozens of TravelTalks shorts I do believe this was the first one to tell a ghost story.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Brought to viewers from the same studio behind that revisionist "Worst Picture Ever" . . .
oscaralbert26 October 2019
Warning: Spoilers
. . . (GASHED WITH THE WHIP--aka, GWTW, of course!), PICTURESQUE UDAIPUR features the Prime Suspect bloviating bozo bigot who desperately attempted to bring his sulfurous version of the Planet to unsuspecting yokels as the self-proclaimed "Voice of the Nether World" during the benighted 1900s. This bloated buffoon, who is not named for the same reason that local American sheriffs are refusing nowadays to give "recognition"--and encourage copycats--each time there's yet another mass slaughter perpetrated by a maggot with a military-style assault rifle (most of who are wearing red hats with the same four-letter acronym beginning with "M" and ending with "A"), sports a surname indicating that he's an adherent of the same narrow-minded, tunnel-vision, Medieval (and just plain Evil) Roman Death Cult which now controls a majority of the out-of-date, archaic, worthless SCOTUS. As you listen to Red Commie Cathy's Clown blather such inanities as "the meanest and poorest receive no pity under Hinduism" and "Who is thy neighbor (in India)? The man from thy own caste" throughout PICTURESQUE UDAIPUR, you will realize exactly WHY it will take a seven-generation "cooling off" period AFTER the narrator's bigoted Pachyderm Party (for whose official propaganda arm he labored) is permanently outlawed, and the Authorities carry out the daunting task of rounding up and destroying every product of this "snuff film" studio, as well as declaring the 100 million demented "core supporters" comprising the Pachyderm "base" as the traitors they obviously are under the RICO Act, and deporting them all to Siberia once their undeserved U.S. citizenship is stripped through the Benedict Arnold precedent, and their ill-gotten Wealth and Weapons are seized under America's Civil Forfeiture Laws!
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed