IMDb > Evening (2007)
Top Links
trailers and videosfull cast and crewtriviaofficial sitesmemorable quotes
main detailscombined detailsfull cast and crewcompany credits
Awards & Reviews
user reviewsexternal reviewsawardsuser ratingsparents guidemessage board
Plot & Quotes
plot summarysynopsisplot keywordsmemorable quotes
Did You Know?
triviagoofssoundtrack listingcrazy creditsalternate versionsmovie connectionsFAQ
Other Info
box office/businessrelease datesfilming locationstechnical specsliterature listingsNewsDesk
taglines trailers and videos posters photo gallery
External Links
showtimesofficial sitesmiscellaneousphotographssound clipsvideo clips

Evening (2007) More at IMDbPro »

Photos (See all 24 | slideshow) Videos (see all 11)
Evening -- Trailer for this drama
Evening -- Clip: Ann's past
Evening -- Interview: Patrick Wilson "On the script"
Evening -- A drama exploring the romantic past and emotional present of Ann Grant and her daughters, Constance and Nina. As Ann lays dying, she remembers, and is moved to convey to her daughters, the defining moments in her life 50 years prior, when she was a young
Evening -- A drama exploring the romantic past and emotional present of Ann Grant and her daughters, Constance and Nina. As Ann lays dying, she remembers, and is moved to convey to her daughters, the defining moments in her life 50 years prior, when she was a young


User Rating:
6.6/10   10,989 votes »
Your Rating:
Saving vote...
Deleting vote...
/10   (delete | history)
Sorry, there was a problem
MOVIEmeter: ?
Up 6% in popularity this week. See why on IMDbPro.
Writers (WGA):
Susan Minot (screenplay) and
Michael Cunningham (screenplay) ...
View company contact information for Evening on IMDbPro.
Release Date:
29 June 2007 (USA) See more »
Her greatest secret was her greatest gift. See more »
A drama exploring the romantic past and emotional present of Ann Grant and her daughters, Constance and Nina. As Ann lays dying, she remembers, and is moved to convey to her daughters, the defining moments in her life 50 years prior, when she was a young woman. Harris is the man Ann loves in the 1950s and never forgets. Full summary » | Full synopsis »
Plot Keywords:
1 nomination See more »
User Reviews:
Don't expect the book See more (100 total) »


  (in credits order) (complete, awaiting verification)

Claire Danes ... Ann Grant

Toni Collette ... Nina Mars

Vanessa Redgrave ... Ann Lord

Patrick Wilson ... Harris Arden

Hugh Dancy ... Buddy Wittenborn

Natasha Richardson ... Constance Haverford

Mamie Gummer ... Lila Wittenborn

Eileen Atkins ... The Night Nurse

Meryl Streep ... Lila Ross

Glenn Close ... Mrs. Wittenborn

Ebon Moss-Bachrach ... Luc

Barry Bostwick ... Mr. Wittenborn

David Furr ... Ralph Haverford

Sarah Clements ... Lizzie Tull (as Sarah Viccellio)

Cheryl Lynn Bowers ... Peach Howze

Chuck Cooper ... Ray
Timothy Kiefer ... Karl Ross
Jon DeVries ... Deaver Ross (as Jon Devries)

David Call ... Pip

Robert Walsh ... Matt
David Robson ... Ethan

Kara F. Doherty ... Chloe / Constance Age 6 (as Kara Doherty)

Chris Stack ... Phil Mars

Maxine Prescott ... Great Aunt Roo
Margaret Coen ... Constance Age 4
Annie Wardwell ... Nina Age 4
rest of cast listed alphabetically:
Jason Anthony ... The Plunge Group (uncredited)

Whitney Avalon ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Ellen Becker-Gray ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Brian Bradshaw ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Allyssa Brooke ... The Plunge Group (uncredited)

Susan Buttrick ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Michael Anthony Coppola ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Blaise Corrigan ... Driver (uncredited)

John Currie ... Ring Bearer (uncredited)
Bonnie-Kathleen Discepolo ... Upper East Side Lady (uncredited)
Christopher Ferrara ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Keith Fluker ... Cameraman (uncredited)
Domenic Fuggetta ... The Plunge Group (uncredited)
Gabe Goodman ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Rob W. Gray ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Diane Halling ... Irish Maid (uncredited)

Americo Presciutti ... Jazz Club Musican (uncredited)

Jerry Quinn ... Pianist (uncredited)
Laurence Richardson ... Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Heath Stewart ... The Plunge Group (uncredited)

Kal Thompson ... Bar Patron (uncredited)

Donald Warnock ... Next-Door Neighbor (uncredited)

Directed by
Lajos Koltai 
Writing credits
Susan Minot (screenplay) and
Michael Cunningham (screenplay)

Susan Minot (novel)

Produced by
Michael Cunningham .... executive producer
Jill Footlick .... executive producer
Michael Hogan .... executive producer
Robert Kessel .... executive producer
Susan Minot .... executive producer
Luke Parker Bowles .... co-producer
Thomas A. Reilly .... associate producer (as Tom Reilly)
Jeff Sharp .... producer (as Jeffrey Sharp)
Claire Taylor .... co-producer
Nina Wolarsky .... co-producer
Original Music by
Jan A.P. Kaczmarek 
Cinematography by
Gyula Pados (director of photography)
Film Editing by
Allyson C. Johnson 
Casting by
Kerry Barden 
Suzanne Crowley 
Billy Hopkins 
Production Design by
Caroline Hanania 
Art Direction by
Jordan Jacobs 
Set Decoration by
Catherine Davis 
Costume Design by
Michelle Matland (co-costume designer)
Ann Roth 
Makeup Department
Cheryl Daniels .... hair stylist
Tricia Heine .... key makeup artist
J. Roy Helland .... hair designer
J. Roy Helland .... makeup designer
Jeri La Shay .... makeup artist
Jerry Popolis .... hair department head
Karen Specht .... key hair stylist
Bradley Stenson .... department head makeup
Louie Zakarian .... special makeup effects artist
Frank Barbosa .... hair stylist (uncredited)
Paula Dion .... hair stylist (uncredited)
Diane Dixon .... hair stylist (uncredited)
Christine Fennell .... additional hair stylist (uncredited)
Production Management
Stephanie Accetta .... unit production manager (as Steph Accetta)
Jennifer Lane .... post-production supervisor
Nellie Nugiel .... unit production manager
Judy Richter .... production supervisor: New York
Second Unit Director or Assistant Director
John Greenway .... second second assistant director
Deanna Leslie .... second assistant director (as Deanna Leslie Kelly)
Thomas A. Reilly .... first assistant director (as Tom Reilly)
Art Department
Brian Buckley .... set dresser (as Brian W. Buckley)
Jason Case .... set dresser (as Jason Pontes)
Jessica Case .... set dresser
Doug Cluff .... charge scenic artist (as Douglas Cluff)
Melissa Cooperman .... second assistant property master
Peter K. Dunbar .... leadman: New York
Elizabeth Fisher .... art department production assistant (as Elizabeth Anne Fisher)
Eric Jerman .... set dresser
Lance Littlefield .... scenic artist
Robin Everett McGuirl .... art department production assistant
Brian McKenzie .... set dresser
Ann Miller .... property master
Janine Moore .... art department coordinator
Paul Peabody .... construction foreman
Scott T. Pina .... construction coordinator
Michael Ramsey .... art department production assistant
Helen Rasmussen .... assistant set decorator
John Ryder .... picture car coordinator
Will Scheck .... on-set greensperson: New York
Robert Schleinig .... lead man
Elizabeth Schlitten .... first assistant property master
Karl Shefelman .... storyboard artist
Andrew Spagnoli .... set dresser
Steven Sparfven .... set dresser
Meaghan E. Stone .... lead greensperson
John H. Storey .... scenic foreman (as J.H. Storey)
Debra Sugarman .... on-set dresser
Katie Tower .... graphic designer (as Katherine Tower)
Bill Wieters .... on-set scenic artist
Peter Wilcox .... gang boss (as Peter A. Wilcox)
Peter Wilcox .... propmaker (as Peter A. Wilcox)
Erik Malkovich .... set dresser (uncredited)
Randy L. Parisian .... scenic artist: New York (uncredited)
Giovanni Rodriguez .... scenic artist (uncredited)
Debra Sugarman .... character artwork (uncredited)
Cleo Wang .... set dresser (uncredited)
Sound Department
Gina Alfano .... adr editor (as Gina R. Alfano)
David Boulton .... adr recordist
Timothy R. Boyce Jr. .... cableperson: New York (as T.R. Boyce Jr.)
Rachel Chancey .... foley editor
Krissopher Chevannes .... adr recordist
Harry Higgins .... sound re-recordist
Bobby Johanson .... adr recordist
Thomas Kodros .... sound consultant: Dolby
Lenny Manzo .... utility sound
Dave Paterson .... sound re-recording mixer (as Dave Patterson)
Dave Paterson .... supervising sound editor
Mary Ellen Porto .... dialogue editor
Joel Reidy .... boom operator
Steve Schwartz .... first assistant sound editor
Reilly Steele .... sound re-recording mixer
Shane Stoneback .... sound re-recordist
Robert Troeller .... sound mix technician (as Bob Troeller)
Tom Williams .... sound mixer
Ryan Collison .... foley engineer (uncredited)
Jay Peck .... foley artist (uncredited)
Special Effects by
J.C. Brotherhood .... special effects supervisor (as JC Brotherhood)
Chris Jordan .... special effects foreman: New York
John Ruggieri .... special effects coordinator
John Ruggieri .... special effects foreman
Visual Effects by
Sarah Barber .... visual effects production assistant: Mr. X Inc
Michael Becki .... digital compositor: Mr. X Inc
Shawn Broes .... digital intermediate editor: Modern VideoFilm
Rene Clark .... digital imaging: Modern VideoFilm
Adrian Colbert .... digital intermediate scanner: Modern VideoFilm
Anand Dorairaj .... digital compositor: Mr. X Inc
David Fix .... senior systems administrator: Mr. X Inc
Zachary J. Gans .... visual effects production assistant: Mr. X Inc
Robert Greb .... digital compositor: Mr. X Inc
Kris Gregg .... digital imaging: Modern VideoFilm
Annu Gulati .... digital compositor: Mr. X Inc
Nicholas Hasson .... iq artist: Modern VideoFilm (as Nick Hasson)
Victoria Holt .... visual effects coordinator: Mr. X Inc
Mark Intravartolo .... visual effects artist: inferno, Modern VideoFilm
Ethan Lee .... visual effects rigging: Mr. X Inc
Mai-Ling Lee .... modeler and texture artist: Mr. X Inc
Shun Sing Edward Lee .... digital compositor: Mr. X Inc. (as Edward Lee)
Jim Maxwell .... matte painter: Mr. X Inc.
Sarah McMurdo .... digital producer: Mr. X Inc
Sean Mills .... modeler and texture artist: Mr. X Inc
Mateo Novacovici .... systems administrator: Mr. X Inc
Ben Perez .... video colorist
Matt Ralph .... 3D animator: Mr. X Inc
Dominic Remane .... visual effects lighting: Mr. X Inc
Darcy Reno .... systems administrator: Mr. X Inc (as Darcy Bangsund)
Carolyn Shelby .... visual effects tape operator: Mr. X Inc (as Caroline Shelby)
Brendan Taylor .... on-set lead: Mr. X Inc
Ed Thompson .... digital imaging: Modern VideoFilom
Aaron Weintraub .... visual effects supervisor: Mr. X Inc
Fiona Campbell Westgate .... visual effects producer: Mr. X Inc
Colin Withers .... senior technical supervisor: Mr. X Inc
Wojciech Zielinski .... modelling supervisor: Mr. X Inc
G.A. Aguilar .... stunt coordinator (as George Aguilar)
Blaise Corrigan .... stunt coordinator
Geoffrey Dowell .... stunts (as Geoff Dowell)
Samantha MacIvor .... stunts
Stephen Mann .... stunts
Thomas T. O'Brien .... safety dive master
Christopher Place .... stunts (as Chris Place)
Keith Siglinger .... stunts
Jason Matthew Barclay .... safety diver (uncredited)
Thomas T. O'Brien .... safety diver (uncredited)
Christopher Place .... stunt double: Patrick Wilson (uncredited)
Camera and Electrical Department
Leonard Applefeld .... electrician (as Leonard Applefield)
Rick Beausoleil .... company grip
Jason Bowen .... generator operator
Eric Boyle .... grip
Robert Bullard .... first assistant camera: "b" camera
Robert Clark .... electrician
Brian Corbett .... grip
Jerry DeBlau .... chief lighting technician
Kenneth Dodd .... best boy electric (as Ken Dodd)
Dru Dunnaway .... grip
Eric Engler .... electric
Brant S. Fagan .... Steadicam operator
Cynthia Fand .... grip
James V. Gartland .... dolly grip
Peter Girolami .... rigging gaffer
Michael Hadley .... electrician (as Michael A. Hadley)
Sean Hadley .... electrician (as Sean Kevin Hadley)
John Halligan .... best boy grip: Paris
John Hamilton .... second assistant camera: "a" camera (as John R. Hamilton)
Matt Harrington .... best boy rigging grip (as Matthew Harrington)
Elizabeth Heslep .... camera loader (as Liz Heslep)
Christian J. Hollyer .... second assistant camera: "b" camera (as Christian Hollyer)
Sal Lanza .... key grip
John Levy .... video assist operator
John R. Loyd .... grip
Robin MacLeod .... grip
Phil Nason .... electrician
Gene Page .... still photographer
Michael Peterson .... electrician (as Michael J. Peterson)
Mark Price .... grip
David Puopolo .... grip
Blackford 'Boots' Shelton .... first assistant camera: "a" camera (as Boots Shelton)
Gregory W. Smith .... Steadicam operator: New York (as Greg Smith)
Elliott Snell .... electrician
Bill Trautvetter .... camera operator
Aaron Tyburski .... rigging electric
Thomas Yostpille .... key rigging grip
Andrew Zuch .... video playback operator (as Andy Zuch)
Joshua Barnatt .... set electrician (uncredited)
Robert Beinhocker .... additional electrician (uncredited)
Rick Cardillo .... electrician (uncredited)
Brant S. Fagan .... camera operator: Super Technocrane (uncredited)
Josh Friz .... second assistant camera (uncredited)
Ryan Gibeau .... electrician (uncredited)
Zack Gorman .... rigging grip (uncredited)
Ed Lalli .... additional electrician (uncredited)
Ed Lalli .... additional grip (uncredited)
JD Leedham .... additional rigging grip (uncredited)
Rob Massey .... epk director of photography (uncredited)
Dave Provenzano .... grip (uncredited)
Peter Rippe .... electrician (uncredited)
David C. Romano .... grip (uncredited)
Travis Trudell .... grip (uncredited)
Casting Department
Sondra James .... adr voice casting
Jessica Kelly .... casting assistant
Anne Mulhall .... casting: Rhode Island
Anne Mulhall .... extras casting: Rhode Island
Paul Schnee .... casting assistant
Grant Wilfley .... extras casting: New York
Marny Smith .... casting assistant (uncredited)
Costume and Wardrobe Department
Gina Castellano .... costume coordinator
Nina Cinelli .... set costumer
David Davenport .... costume supervisor
Nicole Greenbaum .... set costumer
Donna Maloney .... costume supervisor
Janna Pederson .... stitcher
Janna Pederson .... tailor
Ann Powderly .... stitcher
Ann Powderly .... tailor
Jonathan Schwartz .... costume department assistant
Benjamin Wilson .... set costumer
Megan Asbee .... costume production assistant (uncredited)
Margaret Palmer .... set costumer (uncredited)
Editorial Department
Joe Finley .... digital intermediate colorist: Modern VideoFilm
Terry Haggar .... color timer
Patrick McGuinn .... project manager: video dailies, Technicolor New York
Zara Park .... digital intermediate post supervisor: Modern VideoFilm (as Zara Roberts)
Ben Perez .... video colorist: Technicolor New York
Carrie Puchkoff .... first assistant editor: dailies
Pat Repola .... vice president feature post-production: Modern VideoFilm
Gina Sansom .... post-production assistant
David A. Smith .... first assistant editor
Joe Violante .... dailies advisor: Technicolor New York
Alexis Wiscomb .... post-production coordinator: delivery
Brian Boyd .... digital preview colorist (uncredited)
Charles Herzfeld .... hd dailies advisor (uncredited)
Jason Spencer .... editor intern (uncredited)
Music Department
Christine Bergren .... music legal and clearance
Adam Bytof .... musician: cello
Linda Cohen .... music supervisor
Jan A.P. Kaczmarek .... orchestrator
Jan A.P. Kaczmarek .... score producer
Christopher Kennedy .... music editor
Krzysztof Kit .... musician: oboe
Agnieszka Kopacka .... musician: piano
Bogna Kowalska .... orchestra contractor
Deb Lapidus .... vocal coach
Sylwia Mierzejewska .... musician: violin
Leszek Mozdzer .... musician: piano
Rafal Paczkowski .... music score mixer
Enis Rotthoff .... assistant to composer
Justyna Steczkowska .... musician: singer (as Justyna Streczkowska)
Marek Szpakiewicz .... orchestrator
Piotr Tatarski .... assistant to composer
Janusz Wawrowski .... musician: violin
Tadeusz Wicherek .... conductor
Transportation Department
Roland A. Allard .... driver
Stephan Atamian Jr. .... driver
Oscar Beguiristain .... driver
Charles Bessette .... driver
John 'Bubba' Branch .... transportation co-captain
Richard R. Busardo .... driver (as Richard Busardo)
Sam Cardarelli Jr. .... driver (as Samuel W. Cardarelli Jr.)
Mike Easter .... transportation captain (as Michael C. Easter)
George Forte .... driver
George M. Gagnon .... driver
Kenny Gaskins .... transportation co-captain: New York
Ernie Hallquist .... driver
Ronald R. Harrison .... driver
James Healey .... driver (as James P. Healey)
Keith Kalohelani .... driver
Gino Lucci .... representative: picture car company, New York
John McLaughlin .... driver: honeywagon
Daniel Nason .... driver
Harry R. Ogden .... driver
Wade Pytka .... driver
Nicholas Ricamo .... driver
Dexter Roberts .... transportation
John Ryder .... car wrangler
Antonio G. Silva .... driver
Ronald J. Vincent .... driver
Other crew
John Alfred .... finance executive
Sheila Allen .... production accountant
Natalie Angel .... production coordinator
Anthony Bonello .... set production assistant
Patrick D. Boyd .... second assistant chef
Barbara Branch .... first assistant accountant
Wilson Braun .... assistant: Lajos Koltai
Eamonn Burke .... assistant: Vanessa Redgrave and Natasha Richardson
Troy Caldwell .... first assistant chef
Celeste Autumn Clark .... office production assistant: New York (as Autumn Clark)
Clementine Crawford .... assistant: Jeff Sharp (as Clementine Teniqua Crawford)
Robert Darwell .... legal services: Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton
Joe Deingenis .... craft service
Patrick Donovan .... production secretary
Anthony Dorre .... caterer: New York
Gleanna Doyle .... animal wrangler
Henry Fernaine .... production executive
Jane Finn-Foley .... assistant: Jill Footlick
Mike Fitzgerald .... production assistant
Natsu Furuichi .... production associate
Philippe Gallichet .... chef
Dave Ginsberg .... assistant location manager: New York (as David Ginsberg)
Jonathan Golfman .... legal services: Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton
Franky Guttman .... assistant: Jeff Sharp
Tina Hamilton .... asset manager
Charles Harrington .... location consultant (as Charlie Harrington)
Corri Hopkins .... location assistant: New York
Crystal Jenney .... office production assistant
Kristin Johansen .... adr actor
Jon M. Johnson .... parking coordinator: New York (as Jon Johnson Sr.)
Matthew J. Kotowski .... set production assistant
Ashley Kravitz .... clearance services
Amy Leigh Johnson .... unit publicist
Patrick Mahoney .... craft service (as Patrick J. Mahoney)
Adam McCarthy .... location manager
Ryan McPeake .... set medic
Carlos Medeiros .... set production assistant
Rob Meisenholder .... payroll accountant
Ashley Morris .... assistant: Claire Danes
Daniel Murray .... set production assistant (as Daniel C. Murray)
Thomas T. O'Brien .... dive master
Chris Michael Peterson .... choreographer
Christina Pitassi .... second assistant accountant
Luke Poling .... assistant production coordinator
Heather Quam .... medic
Joe Robinson .... production secretary
Phil Rodowsky .... combined dialogue continuity and spotting: Oncore Productions
Todd Rodowsky .... combined dialogue continuity and spotting: Oncore Productions
Whitney Rothe .... set production assistant
Howard Samuelsohn .... dialect coach (as Howard Samuelson)
Andrew Saxe .... location manager: New York
Ken Schiff .... craft service
Dee Schuka .... post-production accountant: Trevanna Post Inc.
George Sheanshang .... legal council: Hart Sharp
Robin Squibb .... script supervisor
Chris Walsh .... location assistant (as Christopher Walsh)
Colin Walsh .... assistant location manager
David H. Angell .... production assistant (uncredited)
Jason Matthew Barclay .... diver (uncredited)
Mimi Coleman .... location coordinator (uncredited)
Terry Conforti .... stand-in (uncredited)
Shannon Dennard .... location scout: New York (uncredited)
Alan Francis .... photo double: Patrick Wilson (uncredited)
Scott Franklin .... location assistant (uncredited)
Jennifer Zolten Freed .... post-production accountant (uncredited)
Mark Killian .... production assistant (uncredited)
Michael Kowalczyk .... craft service assistant (uncredited)
Thomas T. O'Brien .... lead diver (uncredited)
Jeff Pinette .... production assistant (uncredited)
Jillian Roache .... production assistant (uncredited)
Jesse Rosenblatt .... legal services: rights (uncredited)
Joe Russo .... epk producer (uncredited)
Heli Soell .... assistant post-production accountant (uncredited)
Bill Timoney .... adr voice group (uncredited)
Steven Feinberg .... grateful acknowledgment

Production CompaniesDistributorsSpecial Effects
  • Mr. X (digital visual effects)
Other Companies

Additional Details

Also Known As:
Rated PG-13 for some thematic elements, sexual material, a brief accident scene and language
117 min
Aspect Ratio:
2.35 : 1 See more »
Sound Mix:

Did You Know?

Spouses-to-be Claire Danes and Hugh Dancy met for the first time during this shoot.See more »
Anachronisms: In a scene in which characters get ready to drive away from the mansion, they are shown fastening seat belts with a shoulder strap. Shoulder straps were not introduced until much later than the mid '50's.See more »
Buddy Wittenborn:You know what you've got? You have got a talent for love. You're like a love genius. And there are too many statues of generals and politicians, and there are not enough statues of someone like you. In this world, there is so much of what looks like love...See more »
Movie Connections:
Referenced in "Jeopardy!: Episode #26.31" (2009)See more »
One for ErnieSee more »


This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.
49 out of 69 people found the following review useful.
Don't expect the book, 10 July 2007
Author: Tom White from United States

Since starting to read the book this movie is based on, I'm having mixed feelings about the filmed result. I learned some time ago to see the movie adaptation of a book before I read the book, because I found that if I read the book first I was inevitably disappointed in the film. This would undoubtedly have been true here, whereas in the case of Atonement, which is probably the best filmed adaptation of a book I've ever seen, it would probably not have mattered.

I'm trying to figure out what the cause is, and I suspect that I have to point my finger squarely at Michael Cunningham. Much as I respect him for The Hours (which I have not read but which I saw and was awed by) I cannot escape the feeling that he not so much adapted Susan Minton's book as he did take a few of the characters and the basic premise and write his own movie out of it.

It's not that I dislike the movie. I actually love the movie, which is why, since I started reading the novel, I'm feeling disturbed about the whole thing. I feel disloyal to Ms. Minton for enjoying the movie which was so thooughly a departure from her work. Reading it, I can understand why she had such a struggle adapting it. Unlike what one reviewer of the movie said, it's not so much that some novels don't deserve to be a movie; it's more like some books just can't make the transition. Ms. Minton's novel operates on a level so personal and intimate to her central character, so internally, that it seems impossible to me to place it in a physical realm. Even though a lot of the book is memory of real events, it is memory, and so fragmented and ethereal as to be, I feel, not filmable. I think that Ms. Minton's work is a real work of literature, but cannot make the transition to film, which in no way detracts from its value.

I cannot yet report that Evening, the film, does not represent Evening, the novel, in any more than the most superficial way, since I'm only halfway through, but the original would have to make a tremendous leap to resemble the film that follows at this point. I guess I'm writing this because I feel that if you're going to adapt a novel, adapt it, but don't make it something else that it's not. I'm not sure if Michael Cunningham has done anything wholly original, but from what I can see so far the things he has done are all based on someone else's work. We would not have The Hours if Virginia Woolf had not written Mrs. Dalloway, and we would not have Evening, in its distressed form, if Susan Minton had not had so much trouble doing what probably should not have been attempted in the first place. But it's too much to say that it would be better if Ms. Minton had left well enough alone, because Evening, the film, is a satisfactory and beautiful work of its own.

Thus my confusion, mixed feelings, sense of disloyalty, and ultimate conclusion that, in this case, the novel cannot be the film and vice versa, and my eventual gratitude to both writers for doing what they did, so that we have both works as they are.

Was the above review useful to you?
See more (100 total) »

Message Boards

Discuss this movie with other users on IMDb message board for Evening (2007)
Recent Posts (updated daily)User
Why couldn't Ann and Harris have got married? bruce-k-morrison
Anybody who thinks Ann was disloyal to Buddy? kayleewheat
Does anyone else think Ann was disloyal to Lila? missmynx
Boring Waste of Time jadeelee88
Is there a point? Mind_Dweller
Why was this film panned by audience and critic alike? pat102853
See more »


If you enjoyed this title, our database also recommends:
- - - - -
Gone with the Wind Atonement Random Harvest The Kite Runner Giant
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
IMDb User Rating:
Show more recommendations

Related Links

Full cast and crew Company credits External reviews
News articles IMDb Drama section IMDb USA section

You may report errors and omissions on this page to the IMDb database managers. They will be examined and if approved will be included in a future update. Clicking the 'Edit page' button will take you through a step-by-step process.