To begin with I must stress how much of a fan of the original 1996 Independence Day movie I am. For me, its my all time favourite film. Like most movie lovers there are certain films that you go back to now and again, purposely leaving 6 months or more until the next viewing just to make sure that you forget a scene here and there.
I've searched for years about the possibility of a sequel for Independence Day and when it was announced that there would be one, even so far as to have 2 sequels, I was very excited.
I went to view it last night trying to ignore the 5.6 IMDb rating, not reading reviews in case of any spoilers that were left in there and basically approaching it knowing it wasn't going to be a story driven movie like Shawshank or The Godfather. Unfortunately I left feeling very disappointed. I've given it 4/10 only because of the graphics which I thought were very impressive albeit relied upon too much, and the other reason was seeing the characters from the first movie.
My latter reason - the characters - brings me to my first point. Whilst as mentioned it was great to see them on the big screen again and involved in a new story I left feeling as if there had been no character development or at least no explanation as to how they got to where they were.
Take Jeff Goldblum's character David. One of his driving forces to get to the White House in the first movie was not only to inform the Presidency that the clock was ticking, but also to save his estranged wife - Constance (Margaret Colin). She was a massive subplot character yet she was no where to be seen nor was any explanation for her lack of appearance given. It took a quick search when I got home to find out like others have tried to, that she died in a car accident in the official prequel novel to this movie - Independence Day: Crucible. I didn't even know this existed, apparently it was released a month before Resurgence came out. I'm hoping that this will explain in more detail what happened. The character of David seems unaffected by her loss and the story hints at some romance between him and some English women that "he met at a conference".
Moving on to the next character - and in my opinion the most important one - President Whitmore. His leadership and amazing speeches gave humans hope and determination to fight back when the time came. In this movie he's just a bumbling old crazy man, all it would of taken was a quick 2 minute scene where they explain that after the original movie, Bill Pullman's character suffered from a PTSD due to the attack or that he worried so much about another attack that he lost his mind. Instead it came down to the telepathic connection he had from the original movie that made him into this weak character. Which brings me to his demise. I couldn't believe how poor his death scene was, and to be perfectly honest with you, it was all for nothing. Yeah he destroyed the Queen's (more about her later) mini ship, but she survived the explosion due to her having a personal shield, so it was all in vain...and as for his "Happy 4th July" line before pressing the button to set off the bomb, there was no build up whatsoever, as soon as it happened I had to double take and thought to myself - "is that it?". Just remember back when Randy Quaid's character gave his final line "Hello boyyyys, I'mmmm backkkkkk!" after taking the jet into a vertical flight and then boom, huge explosion, the destroyer is defeated and lots of "USA! USA!". Although cheesy, it gives me goosebumps every time.
My last point on original characters and this will be quick is of Jasmine - Will Smith's wife to be. Again like Contance for David Levinstein - Jasmine was a driving force for Captain Steven Hiller. In this movie she's now moved on from being a stripper to apparently being pretty high up in a Hospital. Again, zero explanation, another chance to have a quick 2 minute scene perhaps with her son Dilan. This would of been perfect timing to discuss Will Smith's character - Cpt Steven Hiller - having died. Her death was also very weak, her character was wasted and never mentioned again.
Now moving on to the new characters - this is going to be very brief. Poor acting, unlikable and it felt more like Hunger Games: In Space. This of course helped with the inclusion of Liam Hemsworth - the cheaper brother. Not at all interesting and forgettable.
All in all it was a very bad film, I feel I could write all day about what I thought went wrong with this movie but if you've gotten this far down my babbling then I thank you and will save you from the rest. I just sit here shaking my head at a missed opportunity.
To finalise, in my mind, this movie for me will not be connected to the original Independence Day. I'll still watch the 1996 movie as if the final scene was the end of the story to be told.
I just wish to say this to Roland Emmerich for producing this poor sequel to a cinematic classic:
- "In the words of my generation...Up Yours!"
0 out of 1 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends