OK let's break this down to why Batman and Robin failed so miserably.
10. Batman: Clooney isn't that bad, but it would have helped if he played the character as more brooding and darker.
9. Robin: Chris Odonnel is too old and too tall for this part. Dick Grayson was never this immature in the comics.
8. Batgirl: The character had no reason for being in this movie, it was as if they finished writing it (writing?) and someone said let's put batgirl in this, just...add her in tagging along after the heroes. And she's not Alfred's neice, she's Commisioner Gordon's daughter. (Hey Joel, try reading a comic before you make a movie based on that comic)
7. Mr. Freeze: Arnold wasn't that bad, but let's face it, hundreds of one-liner-cold-puns will kill anyone's career.
6. Poison Ivy: Uma I thought could act, but this role was so ridiculous, and so were her outfits, they looked like they came right out of the 60's. And when she rose (or grew) from the ground and immediatley knew what forign chemicals were running thru her system was laughable.
5. Bane: Let's see, in the comic he is a veritable Dr. Moriarty to Batman's Sherlock Holmes, in the movie he was some dumb shmuck, (like the people who paid to see this) Jeep Swenson (R.I.P.) looks too bulky for the part, Arnold would have been much better in this role.
4. The soundtrack: what soundtrack, they spent all their money on stars and special effects so they just used Goldenthal's soundtrack from Batman Forever.
3. Alfred: Was he dying from sickness, or just trying to die. Since when would he know how to program his brain algorithms into the batcomputer, how would he know her exact measurements, and if he knew Batgirl was going to discover the secret, why not just tell her.
2. The production: THERE WAS TOO MUCH OF IT. All the stunts looked fake, especially at the start when robin burst thru the window on his motorcycle and it just...floats to the ground. By the way how many times are we going to see a superhero drop in thru a skylight.
1. Joel Shumacher: he said Batman should be over his grief of the death of his parents and therefore a little more light hearted ... of course if BATMAN ever was over that, he would stop being BATMAN, that's the only reason he does what he does is because of his grief.
Gotham City has become such a colorful and happy place to live now. I swear I was expecting Aunt Harriett Cooper to pop out someplace in the mansion and offer them milk and cookies. Every few minutes, I found myself looking away and saying "I...I can't belive it's this bad." When BATMAN came out, it was great, when RETURNS came out,I had mixed feelings about it, when FOREVER came out I thought it made RETURNS look so good by comparison, now AND ROBIN comes out and it actually makes FOREVER look good. Let's just hope that WB learns their lesson...But I doubt it.
2 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends