Although I have several friends who are Cuban exiles, some pro- and some anti-Castro, and despite having SOME knowledge of Cuban life today (having visited Cuba in the late '90s), I will not comment on the historical accuracy or political tone of this film.
I'll stick to the acting, casting, and direction, and briefly say that I thought that the cinematography and music were delicious.
I feel badly that such an obvious labor of love for Andy Garcia ended up having such poor finish. The dialog was stilted, the performances lacked credibility, and although I truly enjoy Bill Murray, his role and performance in the film were nothing but a distraction.
Dustin Hoffman's portrayal of Meyer Lansky was understated, credible, and just about the only bit of acting that didn't make me feel like I was watching outtakes.
Smiles were forced, dialog didn't match expressions, continuity wasn't, reactions were inappropriate, and in general, it appeared that the director was spread too thin. I can't say whether the editing was poor or if Mr. Cibelli didn't get enough to work with, but the finished product was quite flawed.
I've seen Garcia act at a higher level, and more believably. Maybe he just needed a better director, or at least one who'd stay behind the camera.
I'll stick to the acting, casting, and direction, and briefly say that I thought that the cinematography and music were delicious.
I feel badly that such an obvious labor of love for Andy Garcia ended up having such poor finish. The dialog was stilted, the performances lacked credibility, and although I truly enjoy Bill Murray, his role and performance in the film were nothing but a distraction.
Dustin Hoffman's portrayal of Meyer Lansky was understated, credible, and just about the only bit of acting that didn't make me feel like I was watching outtakes.
Smiles were forced, dialog didn't match expressions, continuity wasn't, reactions were inappropriate, and in general, it appeared that the director was spread too thin. I can't say whether the editing was poor or if Mr. Cibelli didn't get enough to work with, but the finished product was quite flawed.
I've seen Garcia act at a higher level, and more believably. Maybe he just needed a better director, or at least one who'd stay behind the camera.
Tell Your Friends