"Stargate SG-1" Ethon (TV Episode 2006) Poster

(TV Series)

(2006)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Rough day
owlaurence12 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
At the beginning, it's nothing much: another plea for help against the Ori, this time from the world where Daniel was stranded in "Icon" last year. You'd think people who were almost destroyed by a zealot would resist a bit more, but no --even though the president, of all people, seems the only real convert in the lot. (All along we'll never know what really motivates the Rand nation as a whole: belief in the Ori, fear of them, a grudge against their traditional enemy, or merely meek obedience to their leader.) Daniel's best attempts at negotiating a truce are then cut short when, well, he's thrown to jail without having said a single word. (Nice use of transitions here, by the way: it's a trick the series rarely uses but it constitutes one of the few funny moments in the episode.)

As the episode progresses, things get worse and worse. I was left gaping when Prometheus simply blew up halfway through (with really impressive SFX by the way). The way it is destroyed is particularly dramatic as we see it come apart with every blast, while everybody is scrambling to save it; to the last second, we expect Carter to have one of her genius ideas and save the day.Nope. Bye Prometheus. Honestly, that ship has been in dire straits almost every time they used it; but it was Earth's most reliable defense, and its loss is bound to have consequences. (Of course, the title was a huge hint, but even if you know the story of Prometheus, I doubt you'd recognise the name Ethon. I had to look around for a while before I found the info and added it to the Trivia section).

Anyway, after that debacle, SG1 does manage to get some of its own back: first Carter comes up with a brilliant idea to save the day; then Daniel comes up with an even better idea to save the world. Things get a bit tense there, but we get our happy ending as expected. For 5mn, everything is perfect --until Daniel reveals that it has all been for nothing. This, coming from the guy who never gives up, puts the lid on a very, very gloomy episode. Clearly, the good old days when SG1 routinely triumphed against all odds at the last possible second, are definitely gone. So the episode is good, very dramatic and sadly believable in some parts, but --gosh, I *miss* the good old days.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The End of a Titan
claudio_carvalho4 June 2021
Jared Kane, from Tegalus, comes to the Stargate Command and discloses that the Rand Protectorate have negotiated with the Ori and received a satellite weapon to destroy the Caledonian Federation. The SGC agrees to send Prometheus to Tagalus to destroy the weapon. However, Kane and Jackson are lured by a peace offer from Col. Pendergast and are imprisoned by the deranged Rand commander. Further, the satellite weapon attacks Prometheus. What will happen next?

"Ethon" is a brainless full of action episode. There are many inconsistencies, such as: (a) the war between the Rand Protectorate and the Caledonian Federation is eternal. Why should Jared be worried with the destruction of his enemy?

(b) why Jared Kane and Daniel Jackson are so easily by lured Col. Pendergast?

The destruction of Prometheus would be enough to destroy both Federations. My vote is seven.

Title (Brazil): "Ethon"
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
If the priors are ghosts of men, who you gonna call?
fig-752753 October 2020
Ethon is an action packed and tense episode.

When the SGC is visited by an old friend from an earlier episode, SG-1 go off on a mission on board Prometheus. Of course, not everything goes according to plan.

The episode has a few plot holes. Some of the decisions that are made are a bit dumb, and they only really serve to make things worse for the team. The dumbest for me was when SG-1 were worried about Daniel Jackson. Have they not realised by now that Daniel Jackson can look after himself!?

I think I know enough about where season 9 and season 10 of Stargate are going to understand the events in this episode. Consequently, I think the Ori plot is moving along nicely. It was good to see Ernie Hudson in action one more time too!
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Tired
Calicodreamin11 April 2022
Tired storyline that has been done with the Rand and Caladonians three times and it always ends the same way. Loved seeing Ernie Hudson though, he's awesome.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I Coulda Been a Contender
fcabanski5 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
The episode could have been a 9 or 10 if not for the writers'/producers' insistence on showing global conflicts as silly arguments between equivalent nations.

On Earth, there really is good and evil. That is, to people who understand the difference between the U.S. and Hitler's Nazi Germany or the USSR.

It's yet another defeat for Earth at the hands of the Ori. This time, SGC underestimates the power of a satellite given to a less advanced planet by the Ori. Sam says it should be easy to destroy the satellite.

Nope.

The satellite takes everything Prometheus can throw at it, then it slices through Prometheus' advanced shields like they aren't there.

The other problem with the episode is Captain Pendergast. He's a weak commander who is good at surrender and abandoning ship. If he had fired on the satellite as soon as P exited hyperspace, the P would have won the day without damage or casualties.

Is he a hero? Nope. He's an incompetent, weak boob.
3 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Stupidity over creativity
n-middleton-11727 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This was a clear example of the writers losing their ability to write creatively or with any kind of logic. Instead, they resort to creating drama through stupidity.

The story seems quite legitimate to begin with, they have a sound plan and suitable safeguards. However, upon Prometheus' arrival the story goes downhill with a series of absurd plot twist and even more ridiculous command decisions. The fact they're surprised Jackson was searched and his transmitter removed is naive. Delaying their assault on the satellite, despite clearly agreeing before leaving for the mission that they'd follow through regardless is a weak attempt to build suspense, at the cost of allowing the shields to power up, and then the utterly absurd "what now" response once their weapons have no effect is nothing short of idiotic! They clearly stated in the mission briefing, "if anything goes wrong, we'll jump back into hyperspace"...but apparently 2 seasoned Lt Colonels are able to forget everything in the moment.

Everything that follows on from here is a weak attempt to salvage a situation that never should have occurred in the first place. Sci-fi shows like Stargate, are expected to have more intellectual and logical plot lines, yet this episode spits in the face of that and builds a story out of gross incompetence, unbefitting to the characters.

The only thing saving this episode is the wider impact it has on the rest of the season, with the loss of Prometheus and the realisation of the power of the Ori weapons. However, both of these outcomes could have been achieved through more rational storylines! Even the simplest of changes, such as Rand making the first aggressive move by contacting Earth/Prometheus and holding Jackson's life to ransom, before their arrival, would present a far more logical chain of events rather than gross negligence and incompetence of major characters.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Utter Nonsense
maa-230145 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Like a few other folks here, I found this episode to be so...dumb. The show consistently presents Lt. Colonel Carter as the smartest person in the world and then writes her character as the exact opposite. Every episode this season has shown that the Ori and their Priors are entirely capable of destroying human life, yet Carter (and SG-1) always under estimates them. She makes the assumption that the weapon the Ori has given the Rand Federation would lack any kind of shield or defenses because... the Rand Federation wouldn't think of it. BUT THEY DIDN'T BUILD THE WEAPON.

This episode breaks down from the very beginning but continues to wallow in it's dumbness. Why do all of the military officers on the Prometheus hesitate to make decisions? Decisions I might add that were already made before they even left the base. It's particularly frustrating when the entire last episode focused on Mitchell making rash decisions and how that positively impacted his military career.

This season (and the soft reboot) aren't awful but this episode sure was.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Totally no brainer episode
szabokris17 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I believe this is one of the point when the new guy, Mitchel ruined the whole story. Wrong decesion from the very beginning... again. In the previous seasons everybody was quesioning the SG-1 decesions. Now since we have this new guy as a replacement for Jack we are moving from one wrong decision to another... Honestly after this decision of, Mitchel should have been fired and sentenced to prison. But nothing happened. Half of the star fleet destroyed for an idiot decision to save two idiot nations from destroying each others. Pointless and dumb.
5 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed