Review of Mute Evidence

Man with a Camera: Mute Evidence (1959)
Season 1, Episode 14
Throwback to the Silent Era
16 October 2023
Instead of the series' regular director, Paul Landres piloted this episode and got plenty of overwrought melodramatic performances. He wasn't helped by a terrible script that reminds me of Silent era melodramas made 30 or 40 years ago (now a full century back).

Simon Scott is the mad killer/thief carrying a pitchfork no less, though Chuck has two, count 'em fights with him in which that pitchfork is no match for our hero's fists. Oddball story features exaggerated pantomime by deaf-mute damsel (with a pixie haircut) in distress Sue George, who is being treated with experimental "photography therapy" to help her communicate, by a doctor who's murdered at the outset of the episode.

She ends up bonding with Chuck her savior in a quite old-fashioned plot line that has Bronson matched with a completely non-sexual heroine -she's young and there's no hint of sex whatsoever. I was struck that a decade later he co-starred with the great British actress/producer Susan George (what a coincidence!) in Richard Donner's "Twinky" (a/k/a "Lola"), an obscure romance I saw in the '70s at a Cleveland drive-in. It was a quite impressive example of an older man/young girl movie, which was a favorite of mine alongside the similar "Breezy" by Clint Eastwood (which memorably paired Wiliam Holden with Kay Lenz) a couple of years later.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed