Sort by Popularity - Most Popular Movies and TV Shows With Shay Guthrie

1. Law & Order (1990– )

TV-14 | 45 min | Crime, Drama, Mystery

New York's finest police detectives and prosecutors fight to make the city a safer place. With integrity as the guiding force from investigation to verdict, the teams weigh every perspective in their commitment to finding justice.

Stars: Jerry Orbach, Jesse L. Martin, Dennis Farina, Sam Waterston

Votes: 44,703

2. American Rust (2021–2024)

TV-MA | 60 min | Crime, Drama

A compelling family drama that explores the tattered American dream through the eyes of complicated and compromised Chief of Police Del Harris in a Rust Belt town in southwest Pennsylvania.

Stars: Jeff Daniels, Maura Tierney, David Alvarez, Julia Mayorga

Votes: 11,192

3. Archive 81 (2022)

TV-MA | 60 min | Drama, Horror, Mystery

An archivist hired to restore a collection of tapes finds himself reconstructing the work of a filmmaker and her investigation into a dangerous cult.

Stars: Mamoudou Athie, Dina Shihabi, Evan Jonigkeit, Julia Chan

Votes: 59,589

4. I Am Not Okay with This (2020)

TV-MA | 30 min | Comedy, Drama, Fantasy

Sydney is a teenage girl navigating the trials and tribulations of high school while dealing with the complexities of her family, her budding sexuality, and mysterious superpowers just beginning to awaken deep within her.

Stars: Sophia Lillis, Wyatt Oleff, Sofia Bryant, Kathleen Rose Perkins

Votes: 74,794

5. Sprung (2022– )

35 min | Comedy

Having been previously incarcerated, Jack moves in with his former cellmate, Rooster, and is determined to turn his life around, just at the start of a global pandemic.

Stars: Garret Dillahunt, Shakira Barrera, Phillip Garcia, Clare Gillies

Votes: 6,074

6. The Virtuoso (2021)

R | 110 min | Action, Thriller

Danger, deception and murder descend upon a sleepy town when a professional assassin accepts a new assignment from his enigmatic boss.

Director: Nick Stagliano | Stars: Anson Mount, Abbie Cornish, Anthony Hopkins, David Morse

Votes: 9,320

7. The Chair (2021)

TV-MA | 30 min | Comedy, Drama

At a major university, the first woman of color to become chair tries to meet the dizzying demands and high expectations of a failing English department.

Stars: Sandra Oh, Jay Duplass, Bob Balaban, Nana Mensah

Votes: 18,968

8. Gone (I) (2017–2018)

60 min | Crime, Drama

The survivor of a famous child-abduction case joins a special task force dedicated to solving abductions and missing person cases.

Stars: Leven Rambin, Chris Noth, Danny Pino, Andy Mientus

Votes: 1,891

9. A Party to Die For (2022)

TV-MA | 83 min | Horror, Thriller

Escaping an unsavory past, Sadie arrives in Los Angeles, reinventing herself as the successful socialite that she's always dreamed of being. She starts dating wealthy, handsome nightclub ... See full summary »

Director: Nanea Miyata | Stars: Jonetta Kaiser, Kara Royster, Jermaine Rivers, Madia Hill Scott

Votes: 245

10. Supah Ninjas (2011–2023)

TV-G | 30 min | Action, Adventure, Comedy

Three high school students - Mike Fukanaga, Owen Reynolds, and Amanda McKay - become ninjas with the help of Mike's grandpa.

Stars: Ryan Potter, Carlos Knight, Gracie Dzienny, George Takei

Votes: 1,760

11. Faith Under Fire (2018 TV Movie)

TV-14 | 85 min | Drama

On the day that Antoinette Tuff considered suicide, she realized that all of her challenges had prepared her for a purpose; to save an Atlanta school under siege from a deranged killer bent on murdering the students.

Director: Vondie Curtis-Hall | Stars: Toni Braxton, Trevor Morgan, Yaya DaCosta, David Manzanares

Votes: 320

12. The Pennsylvania Miners' Story (2002 TV Movie)

100 min | Drama

Based on the real-life chronicle of the "nine for nine" Pennsylvania coal miners who were rescued in the summer of 2002. Told from their own perspective, the movie reveals their ... See full summary »

Director: David Frankel | Stars: Graham Beckel, Dylan Bruno, Marisa Ryan, JD Souther

Votes: 182

13. Redcoats (2018)

19 min | Short, Drama, History

Three British soldiers pillage the home of a woman, her daughter and two grandchildren during the Revolutionary War and get more than they bargained for in this dramatic short with a twist.

Director: Amy Tiehel | Stars: Chris James Boylan, Chase Jennings Gray, Shay Guthrie, Shay Guthrie-Belajac

14. Evelyn (II) (2018)

Short, Drama

In a polygamist cult isolated from modern society, a young widow named Evelyn begins to question her faith when she's forced to remarry on the day of her husband's death.

Director: Joel Black | Stars: Michael Douglass, Hollis Evey, Shay Guthrie, Stacy Kessler

15. Birthday Bash (2018)

16 min | Short, Comedy, Horror

Inspired by teen comedies and slasher films of the 80's, "Birthday Bash" is a horror-comedy short film set in 1987.

Director: Colin James | Stars: Mallory Roach, Carla Duval, Shay Guthrie, Maya Tripathy

16. I Am Not Okay with This (2020)
Episode: The Master of One F**k (2020)

TV-MA | 20 min | Comedy, Drama, Fantasy

After Dina ditches her for Brad, Syd spends the afternoon with Stan - and learns there's more to him than she thought.

Director: Jonathan Entwistle | Stars: Sophia Lillis, Wyatt Oleff, Sofia Bryant, Kathleen Rose Perkins

Votes: 1,970

17. American Rust (2021–2024)
Episode: Happy Returns (2021)

TV-MA | 57 min | Crime, Drama

Harris' investigation continues. Isaac leaves town. Billy and Lee reunite as Buell celebrates a shotgun wedding.

Director: John Dahl | Stars: Jeff Daniels, Maura Tierney, David Alvarez, Bill Camp

Votes: 354

18. The Chair (2021)
Episode: The Town Hall (2021)

TV-MA | 30 min | Comedy, Drama

Bill hosts a town hall with the students that quickly takes a turn. Joan starts a fire. A dinner with the dean puts Ji-Yoon in an awkward position.

Director: Daniel Gray Longino | Stars: Sandra Oh, Jay Duplass, Bob Balaban, Nana Mensah

Votes: 478

19. The Chair (2021)
Episode: Don't Kill Bill (2021)

TV-MA | 30 min | Comedy, Drama

Pressure mounts for Ji-Yoon to turn the department around after Bill's suspension. The hiring of a new professor undermines Yaz's chance at tenure.

Director: Daniel Gray Longino | Stars: Sandra Oh, Jay Duplass, Bob Balaban, Nana Mensah

Votes: 438

20. Archive 81 (2022)
Episode: Mystery Signals (2022)

TV-MA | 59 min | Drama, Horror, Mystery

Haunted by a family tragedy, Dan begins to restore videotapes for a cryptic firm. Then he's startled to learn his connection to their missing creator.

Director: Rebecca Thomas | Stars: Mamoudou Athie, Dina Shihabi, Evan Jonigkeit, Julia Chan

Votes: 1,942

21. Archive 81 (2022)
Episode: The Ferryman (2022)

TV-MA | 47 min | Drama, Horror, Mystery

The veil drops from a cursed film's origins. At the Vos Mansion in 1924, Iris recruits Rose for a blood ritual. Dan knows he must find Anabelle.

Director: Rebecca Thomas | Stars: Mamoudou Athie, Dina Shihabi, Evan Jonigkeit, Julia Chan

Votes: 1,303

22. Sprung (2022– )
Episode: Chapter One (2022)

37 min | Comedy

After having been previously incarcerated, Jack moves in with his former cellmate, Rooster, and is determined to turn his life around, just at the start of a global pandemic.

Director: Gregory Thomas Garcia | Stars: Garret Dillahunt, Shakira Barrera, Phillip Garcia, Clare Gillies

Votes: 342

23. Supah Ninjas (2011–2023)
Episode: Finding Forster (2013)

TV-G | 23 min | Action, Adventure, Comedy

Flint Forster learns Amanda's real identity; Mike must rescue Flint and Amanda when they are taken hostage.

Director: Lev L. Spiro | Stars: Ryan Potter, Carlos Knight, Gracie Dzienny, George Takei

Votes: 17

24. Law & Order (1990– )
Episode: Last Dance (2024)

TV-14 | Crime, Drama, Mystery

When a woman is found murdered in Central Park, evidence points to two frequent park-goers - a street vendor and tech billionaire. In the face of extreme political pressure, McCoy takes drastic action to make the case.

Director: Alex Hall | Stars: Reid Scott, Mehcad Brooks, Camryn Manheim, Hugh Dancy

Votes: 208

25. Gone (2017–2018)
Episode: Ride (2017)

43 min | Crime, Drama

The team are faced with multiple missing persons' cases. This time, three female college students - Zoey Price, Amy Holt and Jenna Tucker - request rides through a popular app, but they never make it home.

Director: John Terlesky | Stars: Leven Rambin, Danny Pino, Andy Mientus, Chris Noth

Votes: 97