What happens when you take a few original L Word cast members who are now much older and throw them in with a gang of 20-somethings who are humorless and one-dimensionally-written? Apparently a mish-mash of uneven writing, a cast that doesn't blend well, and a show that doesn't make sense on its own OR as a nod to the original show.
First of all, the Gen Q script takes itself way too seriously and lacks levity. The characters are mostly one-dimensional and checking boxes for inclusivity rather than being fully fleshed out, complex people who can still be likeable. Most of the young characters are just annoying thanks to bad writing that tries way too hard. I appreciate the intention to be more inclusive-but it almost feels like that was so much of the focus for the show-correcting the original L Word's "wrongs" for its time-that the actual writing in Gen Q is an afterthought here. In addition, we are missing chemistry between...well, anyone really other than the buddy-buddiness of old pals Alice and Shane. The older generation doesn't really mix at all with the younger cast, so any interactions between generations seem forced and out of place. Gone are the funny lunch table conversations with the ensemble of women we saw in the L Word, and instead we get piecemeal interactions and awkwardly-written relationships with "Gen Q."
The original L Word got flack for their treatment of transmen, but I'm not sure Gen Q's transman is any better-he's mopey, rigid, humorless, and as mentioned about many characters on this show, pretty one-dimensional. Not sure you improved things there, Gen Q writers!
At the end of the day, the L Word did have a few issues with its portrayal of bisexuality and trans characters, and it lacked diversity in some ways. But it had heart, laughter, the actors had amazing chemistry, and it was compelling. Gen Q is a bit of a dumpster fire in comparison. The writing is terrible, the ensemble is gone, the cast has no chemistry with each other, and this show won't please either generation watching-the older lesbians who remember the original, or the Gen Z kids wanting a show about fleshed out same sex relationships between women and compelling characters they actually like watching. This new version is a snoozefest and embarrassing compared to the original.
First of all, the Gen Q script takes itself way too seriously and lacks levity. The characters are mostly one-dimensional and checking boxes for inclusivity rather than being fully fleshed out, complex people who can still be likeable. Most of the young characters are just annoying thanks to bad writing that tries way too hard. I appreciate the intention to be more inclusive-but it almost feels like that was so much of the focus for the show-correcting the original L Word's "wrongs" for its time-that the actual writing in Gen Q is an afterthought here. In addition, we are missing chemistry between...well, anyone really other than the buddy-buddiness of old pals Alice and Shane. The older generation doesn't really mix at all with the younger cast, so any interactions between generations seem forced and out of place. Gone are the funny lunch table conversations with the ensemble of women we saw in the L Word, and instead we get piecemeal interactions and awkwardly-written relationships with "Gen Q."
The original L Word got flack for their treatment of transmen, but I'm not sure Gen Q's transman is any better-he's mopey, rigid, humorless, and as mentioned about many characters on this show, pretty one-dimensional. Not sure you improved things there, Gen Q writers!
At the end of the day, the L Word did have a few issues with its portrayal of bisexuality and trans characters, and it lacked diversity in some ways. But it had heart, laughter, the actors had amazing chemistry, and it was compelling. Gen Q is a bit of a dumpster fire in comparison. The writing is terrible, the ensemble is gone, the cast has no chemistry with each other, and this show won't please either generation watching-the older lesbians who remember the original, or the Gen Z kids wanting a show about fleshed out same sex relationships between women and compelling characters they actually like watching. This new version is a snoozefest and embarrassing compared to the original.
Tell Your Friends