This review is aimed at those who have seen the film . Moore ostensibly begins this doc with the question 'why us?' As in 'why are Americans so prone to gun violence?' This is an important and valid question and For about half the film, Moore respects this question but then things go downhill.
Moore can't help himself, answering his own question and vilifiying the NRA. The scene with Heston is cringeworthy, with Moore asking Heston to apologize to a picture of a little girl that was gunned down. Shallow, manipulative and opportunistic. Besides, if the question of 'why we are violent?' is admittedly not answered in the doc, then why is Heston responsible? And if Moore is killing Heston for visiting Colorado after Columbine, why does Manson get a pass for doing the same thing ? Probably Because Moore is seduced by how articulate and intelligent Manson is. I love Marilyn Manson and I don't hold him accountable for Columbine but the truth is that his lyrics at the time were violent and angry and the boys were big fans of his. It is insincere to imply that 2 16 year old boys would have been more inspired by what the president is doing than a rock star. I think if we are going to ask why are we more violent, then we must consider that Manson's Lyrics and pop culture may actually be part of the problem. Not convenient and does not fit Moore's agenda but an honest, unbiased exploration of the problem would not have dismissed that point of view IMO.
6/10. Worth a watch but make up your own mind.
Moore can't help himself, answering his own question and vilifiying the NRA. The scene with Heston is cringeworthy, with Moore asking Heston to apologize to a picture of a little girl that was gunned down. Shallow, manipulative and opportunistic. Besides, if the question of 'why we are violent?' is admittedly not answered in the doc, then why is Heston responsible? And if Moore is killing Heston for visiting Colorado after Columbine, why does Manson get a pass for doing the same thing ? Probably Because Moore is seduced by how articulate and intelligent Manson is. I love Marilyn Manson and I don't hold him accountable for Columbine but the truth is that his lyrics at the time were violent and angry and the boys were big fans of his. It is insincere to imply that 2 16 year old boys would have been more inspired by what the president is doing than a rock star. I think if we are going to ask why are we more violent, then we must consider that Manson's Lyrics and pop culture may actually be part of the problem. Not convenient and does not fit Moore's agenda but an honest, unbiased exploration of the problem would not have dismissed that point of view IMO.
6/10. Worth a watch but make up your own mind.
Tell Your Friends