In 2013, two remarkably similar films released in theaters at around the same time. Both were about a takeover of the white house, Olympus Has Fallen and White House Down. Both were phenomenal critical flops, and deserved to be so. However, back in 1964, two films that dealt with identical subject matter were released in theaters, one after the other. Both of these films are tremendous and memorable, but they take distinctly different approaches to the subject.
These films are Dr. Strangelove (or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb) and Fail Safe. They both deal with the topic of mutually assured destruction during the cold war. In both films, a false alarm is sent out to bomber planes, which are flying two hours away from their targets. In both films, all attempts are made to stop the planes from attacking once it is discovered there is no need for attack. However, Dr. Strangelove tackles the topic from a dark comedy angle, while Fail Safe takes a serious, sorrowful, and devastating angle. Both do so as well as is possible, and both are stunning.
Fail Safe stars Henry Fonda as the unnamed President of the United States, who takes control of the situation in a tremendous performance. His character has several discussions with the Russian president, in another scene which shows the definite difference between this and Strangelove. In Strangelove, the president's conversation is quite amusing ("You know how we've always talked about the possibility of something going wrong with the bomb?") whereas here it's deadly serious and quite realistic.
Neither of these perspectives is the right or wrong perspective, and both are directed by masters of the craft of filmmaking. Sidney Lumet, the director of Fail Safe, is known most for films like 12 Angry Men, Dog Day Afternoon, Serpico, and more recently Before the Devil Knows You're Dead. Here, reminding us of 12 Angry Men is not only the director but the star, Fonda. Also, there is the atmosphere, the tension in the air of an impossible decision which needs to be made, and the most certainly deadly outcome will undoubtedly weigh heavily on the shoulders of those who make it.
Fail Safe doesn't make it to the ten star mark for me, personally, because of a decidedly slow start. The opening ten minutes or so are unpleasant and dull in my memory, and keep it from being a great film from start to finish. But once the plot gets on the road, this film is absorbing, tense, and everything a cold war thriller should be. Highly recommended.
These films are Dr. Strangelove (or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb) and Fail Safe. They both deal with the topic of mutually assured destruction during the cold war. In both films, a false alarm is sent out to bomber planes, which are flying two hours away from their targets. In both films, all attempts are made to stop the planes from attacking once it is discovered there is no need for attack. However, Dr. Strangelove tackles the topic from a dark comedy angle, while Fail Safe takes a serious, sorrowful, and devastating angle. Both do so as well as is possible, and both are stunning.
Fail Safe stars Henry Fonda as the unnamed President of the United States, who takes control of the situation in a tremendous performance. His character has several discussions with the Russian president, in another scene which shows the definite difference between this and Strangelove. In Strangelove, the president's conversation is quite amusing ("You know how we've always talked about the possibility of something going wrong with the bomb?") whereas here it's deadly serious and quite realistic.
Neither of these perspectives is the right or wrong perspective, and both are directed by masters of the craft of filmmaking. Sidney Lumet, the director of Fail Safe, is known most for films like 12 Angry Men, Dog Day Afternoon, Serpico, and more recently Before the Devil Knows You're Dead. Here, reminding us of 12 Angry Men is not only the director but the star, Fonda. Also, there is the atmosphere, the tension in the air of an impossible decision which needs to be made, and the most certainly deadly outcome will undoubtedly weigh heavily on the shoulders of those who make it.
Fail Safe doesn't make it to the ten star mark for me, personally, because of a decidedly slow start. The opening ten minutes or so are unpleasant and dull in my memory, and keep it from being a great film from start to finish. But once the plot gets on the road, this film is absorbing, tense, and everything a cold war thriller should be. Highly recommended.
Tell Your Friends