I didn't see this in the theaters, because I was not expecting much. However, I did watch some of it when it came on the premium pay cable channel the other day. I was wrong about it. It was even worse than I expected.
Oscar Wilde, and this play in particular, is meant to be done `over the top'. `The Importance of Being Earnest' is supposed to be poking fun at Victorian mores. This film manages to get absolutely nowhere near that. Oliver Parker, the director of this film, seems to have no absolutely no concept of how to be humorous. The lines are delivered flat and much too fast, with absolutely no hint of irony or humor. Some of the funniest exchanges in the play go over absolutely like a dead fish in this film. In fact, many of them go by so quickly that the uninitiated probably don't even recognize them as jokes. I admire Judy Dench as a very accomplished actress, but she was a miserable choice for the role of Aunt Augusta. She comes across as a mean spirited, always cross spinster. The exchange between she and Earnest Worthing about his lack of parents and being found in a handbag in Victoria Station was so amazingly without humor, I was astounded. And to have Gwendolen visit a tattoo parlor was very out of character. It didn't fit in at all. I suppose that was thrown in to somehow make this film somehow `relevant' to the 20-something's of today's movie going audience, as was the attempt to make several other aspects of this film on the `racy' side. It all seemed very unnecessary and gratuitous, and the attempt really diminished the good points of a wonderful play.
If you want to see this play done well, go catch it at one of your local theater groups. They would do a much better job that this vast disappointment. Or better yet, get a hold of the video of the 1952 version, starring Michael Redgrave and Dorothy Tutin. That is the definitive version of this play. It is a wonderful treatment of Oscar Wilde's snide humor and witty wordplay. This one, don't waste your time.
Oscar Wilde, and this play in particular, is meant to be done `over the top'. `The Importance of Being Earnest' is supposed to be poking fun at Victorian mores. This film manages to get absolutely nowhere near that. Oliver Parker, the director of this film, seems to have no absolutely no concept of how to be humorous. The lines are delivered flat and much too fast, with absolutely no hint of irony or humor. Some of the funniest exchanges in the play go over absolutely like a dead fish in this film. In fact, many of them go by so quickly that the uninitiated probably don't even recognize them as jokes. I admire Judy Dench as a very accomplished actress, but she was a miserable choice for the role of Aunt Augusta. She comes across as a mean spirited, always cross spinster. The exchange between she and Earnest Worthing about his lack of parents and being found in a handbag in Victoria Station was so amazingly without humor, I was astounded. And to have Gwendolen visit a tattoo parlor was very out of character. It didn't fit in at all. I suppose that was thrown in to somehow make this film somehow `relevant' to the 20-something's of today's movie going audience, as was the attempt to make several other aspects of this film on the `racy' side. It all seemed very unnecessary and gratuitous, and the attempt really diminished the good points of a wonderful play.
If you want to see this play done well, go catch it at one of your local theater groups. They would do a much better job that this vast disappointment. Or better yet, get a hold of the video of the 1952 version, starring Michael Redgrave and Dorothy Tutin. That is the definitive version of this play. It is a wonderful treatment of Oscar Wilde's snide humor and witty wordplay. This one, don't waste your time.
Tell Your Friends