OK. There will be spoilers.
I just want to mention that when I sympathize with a man who's committed two really gruesome murders and tried to frame a somewhat innocent woman for that more than I sympathize with his victims or the people who try to catch him, there is some problem with the story I'm reading or watching. And this is precisely what happened here. Let me try to explain.
A troupe of anarchist actors travel from town to town to perform and speak out against the tyranny of things like Science and Society. For some reason their amateurish and, frankly, horrible shows manage to rile people up to the point where, when they go to Glasgow, they're warned by the police not to perform, because that may cause a riot. Being anarchists, they still do their show and cause a riot during which Angus Boyde's wife is trampled to death. He decides to take his revenge, infiltrates the troupe and when they eventually reach Kembleford. he kills two of them and successfully pins that on one of his victims' daughter - who is the only one from the troupe that remains alive. Of course, Father Brown soon solves the mystery.
Can you see where my problem is? I hope you do, but if you don't - these "actors" were just a band of dangerous criminals who got God knows how many people killed. They knew what they were doing. And not only that, but the supposedly innocent daughter said in plain text that a true anarchist owes nothing to anyone. And this woman was not innocent at all. True, she was framed for the murders, but before that she assaulted the first suspect in front of witnesses and then, after he was released, she tried to kill him right in front of a few police officers. Isn't attempted murder a crime? How about trying to claw someone's eyes out? (The way the actress performed uncontrollable rage was award worthy, though.)
This is what eventually tanked the episode for me. At the end of the day, while this woman lost her father (who was shown to be a really horrible human being and possibly an abusive parent, by the way), she was not held accountable for the crimes she committed within the episode, nor was she held accountable for the lives she and her troupe ruined.
Well...
1 out of 7 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink