"Once Upon a Time" The Final Battle: Part 1 (TV Episode 2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Battle of the souls
TheLittleSongbird19 May 2019
'Once Upon a Time' was very addictive when it first began. What really intrigued me into seeing it in the first place was its fascinating and creative premise of turning fairy tales and characters on their head and putting own interpretations on them. Good premises always do intrigue me and that or talented casts, or both, are usually my main reasons in my interest in watching something. Liked to loved a vast majority of Seasons 1-4 and found a lot to like about Season 5, despite reservations with the second half of it.

Season 6 was for me more hit and miss, leaning generally towards the disappointing. Personally thought that the first three episodes of the season were very good to great, especially "The Other Shoe". It was from "Strange Case" onward when the problems began and things got somewhat pear-shaped, when there was an increasing lack of new ideas and magic, increasing too were the campiness and soap opera, the over-stuffing and less interesting characterisation. It did get significantly better though towards the end of the season, but between "The Other Shoe" and "Page 23" the season was very uneven, though never unwatchable.

"The Final Battle", both parts, is a great episode and one of the season's best. Also one of the best episodes of the latter (meaning Seasons 5, or at least the second half of it, -7) seasons, and we are not talking marginally. It worked incredibly well as a season finale, one of the show's season finales, and actually would have worked equally brilliantly as an ending to the show.

Do feel that the cursed Storybrooke parts had more tension and emotion than the Enchanted Forest ones. The latter parts were charming and enjoyable, as well as interesting, if not quite going the extra mile like the Storybrooke parts did.

So much to love though however. What was striking about "The Final Battle" was how it returned to its roots and came back to what we already knew, but instead going round in circles it played around with it without contradicting. It was very affectionately nostalgic, though one is reminded somewhat of how 'Once Upon a Time' progressed so much since it first started on the whole, and packed a big emotional punch (i.e. Hook and Emma). A lot happens here, yet unlike most of the other episodes of Season 6 it didn't feel over-stuffed or rushed with it being spaced out over two parts. It to me didn't feel muddled and comprehension was not a problem.

What is also great is the character interaction and how the characters were written. Even with deliberately different takes on some of them, the characters are still very interesting and engaging, some being the most interesting they've been all season (i.e. Mary Margaret, showing some steel), and they don't come over as distorted. Actually really cared about all of them. Loved the character interactions, like with Emma and Henry, Regina and Evil Queen, Snow White and Regina, Hook and Emma etc. and the more subtle things, like how Rebecca Mader says Zelena's line regarding the destruction of Oz and with Snow White and Regina. The Black Fairy is a more than convincing antagonist and Gold's story here is very moving and really cared for Gold more so than any of the previous Season 6 episodes.

Even with the playing around and returning to the roots, the story grips and intrigues, while the dialogue is amusing, thought-provoking, heartfelt and intense, balanced very well. Less soap, corn and camp here. The production values have a lot of beauty and atmosphere, nothing drab or gaudy here, while being attractively photographed. The music doesn't ever sound cheap or out-of-kilter, fitting well with the mood and never found myself questioning its placement. The main theme is still memorable. Lana Parrilla, Jennifer Morrison, Robert Carlyle and Rebecca Mader are on particular top form of the uniformly strong cast.

Overall, a great episode and season finale. 9/10
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Hope vs Insanity
Jackbv12315 May 2017
I just watched an hour long special where the recurring theme was the importance of hope.

The problems I have with the episode The Final Battle Part 1 is that it juxtaposes hope with delusional insanity. I totally hated the Buffy The Vampire Slayer episode that did the same thing.

Insanity is not something to toy with. No rational person would ever suggest to a delusional person that perhaps it IS a good idea to have hope that his delusions are real and that all he needs to have hope in her delusions. The whole concept is ridiculous.

In this episode we are supposed to root for the protagonist to just have enough hope ... that her delusions are real. And not just that, but that people are depending on her to conquer fear with hope based on her delusions.

In my opinion, this episode glorifies the antithesis of real heroic hope. The hope is not heroic, it is delusional.
3 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed