I'm going to critique the first 2 episodes as one pilot, even though I think the anime should've just been 44min per episode. Having each "episode" actually be 2 22min episodes messes with the structure but whatever.
A pilot is usually supposed to set up a show. We get introduced to the characters, their motives and the world they live in. Obviously the pilot shouldn't immediately reveal all but it should set it up and yet the only character that gets any sort of setup is Eren. Mikasa is just kinda there as his overly-serious sidekick and Armin just stands there and does nothing for the whole pilot.
Even Eren is set up so poorly. Instead of there being an extended scene between him, his mother and his father and us getting to actually know them, the mom is in 2 short scenes where we only learn the absolute basics about her but nothing to actually hook us into her character and feel sorry for Eren when she dies. What's worse, the show clearly realises this but instead of adding more interactions between her and Eren, we get stupid flashbacks in the form of static images right when she dies. I'm sorry dude but that does not make me sad for her, it just makes me wonder why you didn't introduce her better.
Other than that, there are so many plotholes:
- How did nobody hear an army of titans marching toward the villages?
- Why are there no posts at the top of the wall where soldiers keep watch for titans?
- Why are there soldiers keeping watch on the INSIDE of the walls and not one soldier on the OUTSIDE?
- Why was only one ferry built to carry people in case of an emergency? Materials clearly aren't an issue or the 3 massive stone walls surrouding the villages wouldn't exist
Oh and what should've been a big reveal of the titans is spoiled through the intro, the episode shouldn't have aired the intro at all
I could go on and on but I do not have the braincells to do so anymore. I'm sorry but I do not see how this is any more unique than any other stupid dark fantasy anime out there.
3 out of 19 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink