Picture Day (2012) User Reviews

Terrific lead performance in a smart coming-of-age story

[space_base · 7/10 · 8 January 2014]

Now here's an insightful little teen film that gets the angst of coming- of-age without having to resort to the same old clichés. "Picture Day" from promising first-time filmmaker Kate Melville is a sensitive portrayal concerning a couple of teens going about the daily grind.

The reckless, wannabe rebel Claire (Tatiana Maslany), forced to attend an extra year of high school, befriends the socially awkward Henry; a boy she used to babysit years earlier. Claire is unaware of their history at first, but Henry isn't, and in fact has never abandoned his long standing, secretly obsessive crush.

"Picture Day" is well written and unpredictable, but it is the terrific work of Maslany (a revelation on TV's "Orphan Black") that makes the film succeed. She's a quirky, natural performer and at 28 somehow plays a high schooler with utter conviction. Her character is flawed, brash, but realistically drawn and we root and sympathize with her. Melville rests a lot on Maslany's performance to great results.

The plot goes some places that don't really work, and some scenes are in need of a good trimming, but this is never the less a rarity in the teen genre; one that favors character development, leisurely pacing, and no easy answers.

This is smart, good-natured indie fare with a terrific performance at it's center. It's imperfect sure, but memorable and well worth seeking out.

Tatiana Maslany, a True Star.

[SnoopyStyle · 7/10 · 27 August 2013]

Tatiana Maslany of 'Orphan Black' stars as Claire Paxton, a rebellious teen forced to repeat her senior year of high school. She is look down upon as a school outsider with a questionable reputation. She becomes a friend, mentor, and an object of desire to Henry who is also a quiet outsider she used to babysit as a child. On the other hand, she is sexually involved with Jim, the 30-something front man for the funk band, the ElastoCitizens.

This is a coming of age story not just for Henry but also for Claire. They're both amazing in this great little indie movie, but Tatiana is the one that breaks out as a true movie star. She is both magnetic and vulnerable in this role.

Tatiana must mean "gold" in some language

[gdump · 7/10 · 18 August 2019]

I was going to skip this movie because it sounded like yet another in a long stream of lame teen movies, but then I saw that Tatiana Maslany was the lead. Based on her stunning performances in Orphan Black, I decided to give it a chance and I'm glad I did.

Both Maslany and Spencer Van Wyck play roles much younger than their actual ages, but they are both completely believable. Their performances raise this otherwise common story into something much better.

Tatiana's strong performance

[rjp-40901 · 7/10 · 25 August 2020]

Tatiana wants to hang out with a much older musician, no wait, she is suddenly interested in the younger guy she used to babysit, making him her pet project. What's interesting is seeing her character's layers and defences peel away, little by little. No question we're watching a Canadian film here. And yes, that's a good thing.

Picture Day 2012 is a Canadian Movie about a girl growing up

[annuskavdpol · 3/10 · 17 February 2015]

Picture Day is a movie about a late teenager/ young adult who has failed grade twelve and is repeating it again. This movie is about conflict and resolution. In a way it is about an individual who is born without many chances. Her mother does not really seem to know that she exists and she does not have any real friends to support her. She does not have any hobbies to keep her going, nor any commitments. She is floating through life in a kind of a danger zone. Is this part of growing up? Or is it something deeper? Does she have traits of mental illness, or is this all a part of the trials and tribulations of growing up? Without loving parents to question these traits in their daughter - no one is to really know. Towards the end of the movie things kind of do seem to pan out a little bit - but there are clearly personal boundaries that have been crossed. This movie is somewhat like the Canadian movie Exotica by Atom Egoyan. Perhaps this movie, Picture Day is like a typical Canadian movie - whereby the Canadian identity is not rooted in a personal history but rather by external situations in life which seem to form the otherwise formless Canadian identity.

Great little movie.

[ebonytower · 8/10 · 20 June 2013]

This movie's great. The ending is a little abrupt, but there are so many good moments which are reminiscent of Freaks & Geeks, even better if only in the ability to capture teenage life/adolescence in all its awkwardness, relationship dynamics, etc. especially for those of us who didn't really "belong" or fit in re high school life. It's not something you often find in films these days. It's funny, touching even; there are some great moments in this. Music fits in perfectly with some scenes.

The actress, Tatiana Maslany is incredible in this and really does make the movie. Truly a freaking impressive performance.

Stuck between adolescence, adolescence and stereotypical immaturity

[napierslogs · 3/10 · 9 October 2013]

"Picture Day" stars Tatiana Maslany as Claire, a girl who's described as being caught in between adolescence and adulthood. But that's only accurate if adulthood is actually an immature state of being where teenagers are snarky and rude because they think they're cool and smarter than everybody else. She's smack dab in the middle of adolescence no matter how mature she might think she is.

During Claire's last year of high school – again, she meets two guys. Jim is legally an adult, thereby making him older and wiser. He also represents the sex, drugs and rock & roll stage of "adulthood". Henry is younger than Claire, but also mature, studious and observant. He's also more sheltered and needs someone to show him the harsh realities of coming of age.

The coming of age parallels within in this film are apparent and abundant. Claire's stuck between adolescence and adulthood and is repeating her last year of high school – as if she's unable to know when she needs to grow up. She's also torn between two guys, representing the high school and adult worlds she's torn between. And then within the guys themselves, the older one is more immature and less adapted to the adult-world and has no need for Claire himself. While the younger one can provide Claire with the stability she needs and has the maturity to approach adolescence like an adult.

The problem is all those parallels are represented within the premise, once you actually start watching the movie, there's nothing left to discover. "Think these ideas are smart? Good, because that's all we've got."

Worse is that the characters themselves don't provide any reasons to keep watching. Claire is rude, insolent and immature, and doesn't deserve our sympathy or even our attention. Jim is a walking, talking stereotype that is even more annoying than that sounds. Henry is a decent character, and since that should solve her boy-related dilemma, the only dilemma that's left is why we're still watching.

I so much wanted to like this but....

[jordondave-28085 · 5/10 · 30 April 2023]

(2012) Picture Day DRAMA

Written and directed by Kate Miles Melville directing a coming-of-age story, centering onto yet another misunderstood teenage girl in this case it's Claire (Tatiana Maslany) who does nothing except sleep around, drink booze with people who don't really care about her, particularly the struggling rock musician. But ironically, the only person who does care about her is the young teenage guy she used to babysit with. I mean, like whoopee... Now, while I appreciate the 'raw' looking environment background, it's unable to make it's characters engaging, since each one of them are just as self-absorbed and one-note as the next, as we continue to see them doing things we ourselves can't see ourselves doing. Obviously, inspired by one of Mike Leigh's improvised movies perhaps "Naked" as well as "semi-documentaries such as "Kids" and "Bully". This movie is boring and doesn't add up to nothing.

really nice movie!

[vandwedge · 7 January 2022]

So much of this movie's charm comes from its cast, who are all super likable, especially the lead. But it's also got really great storytelling, with a lot of understated moments and implications you have to piece together yourself. Breezy and moody and recommended to anyone who likes these chill sorts of movies.