Where the film succeeds is in this ability to make us feel on a dramatic ridge flirting with the precipice. Continuously: the resourcefulness, the negotiation, the daily quest for the right plan, for the money to find for the moment or the one after. Each individual linked to the other, By necessity or tradition. On one side, the comfort of the community, on the other its permanent violence, like two sides of the same coin. Drama can arise from every shot. Everything is survival and misery, but everything is also beauty and kindness. Anything could happen, But in the end we are left with motherly love.
15 Reviews
War Pony
CinemaSerf14 June 2023
This starts off as quite an interesting observation of two young men growing up on the Pine Ridge reservation for the Oglala Lakota tribe in rural Dakota. It principally centres on the young "Bill" (JoJo Bapteise Whiting) who is juggling two girlfriends, two young children, and aspirations to buy and breed a rather mangy looking poodle! When he happens by a successful farmer whose car has broken down by the side of the road, he sees a way to make some extra cash. The two men click and pretty soon "Bill" is packaging turkey jerky by the bucketload! Meantime, the younger "Matho" (LaDainian Crazy Thunder) has been thrown out of his father's home after he and his pals compromised his cocaine business by adding a little epsom salts to their distribution network! Both stories see the men and their friends and families trying to get by in a community that seems to exist for the sake of it. Poodles notwithstanding, there seems little structure to their lives nor much point to anything. Opportunities are sparse and family loyalties only appear to endure when convenient. It's actually quite a depressing story that I couldn't help wonder might not have been worthy of watching at all, had it not been for the native American aspects to the production and plot. Despite that increasingly prevailing downbeat theme, there is something likeable about Whiting's characterisation of the wayward "Bill" - a man who does seem to at least want to escape the relentlessness of their existence. The ending is weak, though, and frankly really quite daft and as an whole, the film does drag a bit across the two hours of rather soporifically scored, slowly paced, drama. It's worth a watch, but it's not great.
Fascinating and Absorbing
liverpoolarchive7 October 2023
Watched this film with no idea what it was about, other than being set on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. Completely blown away by the style and performances. Uncompromising, raw and compelling. If you like the series 'Reservation Dogs' then you'll enjoy this offering. The focus of the story shifts between two young male characters who are trying to get by with their daily lives. There's some alcohol consumption, smoking and dabbling with drugs, drawn from real life experience. The performances are top class and the film marks the very impressive directorial debuts of Keough and Gammell....
An important reminder.
PK_7111 August 2023
I tend to think of the United States as a rich country. One of the world's richest, in fact. And so do all Americans I've ever met. And I know perfectly well that large numbers of Americans are poor. But every now and then I need to be brutally reminded of just *how* poor the poorest Americans are, and how disproportionately these poorest Americans tend to be Native Americans or Black.
War Pony is exactly that kind of reminder, and it does that job beautifully. As far as I understand, the cast is entirely made up of amateur actors, who have grown up on the reservation. If that is true, their performance is very impressive indeed. Having said that, there are brief moments, where the acting comes up a bit short.
I'm very glad that I saw this film, and I happily recommend it. All privileged people will benefit from watching this movie, and all privileged Americans really ought to see it.
War Pony is exactly that kind of reminder, and it does that job beautifully. As far as I understand, the cast is entirely made up of amateur actors, who have grown up on the reservation. If that is true, their performance is very impressive indeed. Having said that, there are brief moments, where the acting comes up a bit short.
I'm very glad that I saw this film, and I happily recommend it. All privileged people will benefit from watching this movie, and all privileged Americans really ought to see it.
Sad Story - Biased toward the Corruption
sharonlscotty9 March 2024
My mother was 1/2 Oglala Sioux and 1/2 Menominee. She married my father who was German and French. She was raised in Standing Rock Rez until she was 8. I was raised as WASP as they come but always relish my American Indian heritage.
While I understand that this is only a movie but seeing as how it's kind of in a documentary format I wish it would have included some good realities that are there as well. The repsentation of the realities seem a little sku'd.
The movie was so disappointing because it didn't show the hope that's available to them on the reservations. It lacks the folks who are Ogalala that are the good ones with integrity. Yeah it showed us the way of life by the majority... or so we think... because frankly we don't know the truth because we're not there. But there were some very good people on the Rez - my great grandpa being one of them - He was the last Chief of the Sioux Oglala - Old Thunder. He was a great man and wrote a book talking about his life and how he shared hope with all he worked with on the Rez.
While I understand that this is only a movie but seeing as how it's kind of in a documentary format I wish it would have included some good realities that are there as well. The repsentation of the realities seem a little sku'd.
The movie was so disappointing because it didn't show the hope that's available to them on the reservations. It lacks the folks who are Ogalala that are the good ones with integrity. Yeah it showed us the way of life by the majority... or so we think... because frankly we don't know the truth because we're not there. But there were some very good people on the Rez - my great grandpa being one of them - He was the last Chief of the Sioux Oglala - Old Thunder. He was a great man and wrote a book talking about his life and how he shared hope with all he worked with on the Rez.
Becoming a man
maximefo30 May 2023
A very good first movie, which reminded me of Songs my brothers taught me. Many topics are addressed, but maybe the most important ones are a realistic representation of life on a Native American reservation, the trajectory of a teenager and a young adult, both hustling and navigating the duties, stereotypes and expectations of what it means to be(come) a man. Physically speaking, Bill reminded me of Eros Ramazzotti when he was in his early 20s.
The actors are amazing and the plot quite surprising. I also enjoyed a few magical/poetic moments in this dramatic film. There is so much empathy towards the main characters and their struggles, it is in many ways a moving and eye opening movie.
The actors are amazing and the plot quite surprising. I also enjoyed a few magical/poetic moments in this dramatic film. There is so much empathy towards the main characters and their struggles, it is in many ways a moving and eye opening movie.
Bags of potential, but...
scaryjase-061619 April 2024
The film follows Bill (Jojo Bapteise Whiting) in his early 20s and Matho (LaDainian Crazy Thunder) in his early teens as they try to hustle their way to success/maturity/whatever their latest goal is. And so, like hustling often involves, various different strands are followed throughout the film - some of which progress the "story" along more than others. A sense of foreboding builds at the end, partly because the score starts sounding more like Jaws and partly because a review has told me that the boys lives are somehow interlinked so I was expecting a coming together to give the whole thing some meaning. And they do meet, but I don't think anyone could particularly describe it as revelatory - however, the film does give us some moments of tenderness and emotion that are really well conveyed, particularly around Matho, who could REALLY do with a bit more adult guidance from those around him.
The film is full of very natural performances - most of the actors in the film are first time actors and they all give a good account of themselves. Jojo and LaDainian do a lot of work throughout the film and they've both very expressive and easy to hang out with, although most of their behaviour would probably be described as sketchy at best.
It's an overly quirky film style at times - the buffalos and turkeys randomly appearing do get a little unsettling, but I'm sure they mean something to someone. It's generally nicely filmed - nice use of the scenery and light and shade (although possibly a little too much shade at times). I think it manages to stay the right side of "documenting a lifestyle away from the mainstream" without straying into the "overly worthy/patronising" but I'm really not the best placed person to comment on such matters. I also think that for two white women (Riley and Gina Gammell) to create this, no matter how many Native Americans they consulted with, they are opening themselves up to comments along the "poverty tourism" lines (particularly since Riley cannot be lacking a dollar or two) - critical comment has generally been positive though.
And there's no doubt that poverty is very much on display - these people do not lead glamorous lives and the struggle to exist day-to-day feels very real. Grindingly so, which I'm sure it is, but I do feel the film could have benefited from a little more light to contrast the shade. There's also not enough plot for the length of the film and some of the stories involved go on waaaay longer than they need to - however, I never felt like giving up on it (although it did take me several attempts to get through it).
One other quibble that may be entirely down to me - I found a lot of the dialogue tricky to understand. I think it was a combination of the accents, the language and the sound levels (there's often a large amount of "background" noise, which must be a deliberate choice but not one I appreciated) but at times I really had to pay attention to get some idea what was going on.
Overall, I think there's plenty of promise and some great filmmaking on display here from Riley and Gina - for me it has not, however, resulted in a great film but it's certainly interesting and beautiful in places. If you fancy checking it out, then it's available to rent in all the usual places (and a bargain £1.99 on Apple+) - it's worth a look, but won't be for everyone.
The film is full of very natural performances - most of the actors in the film are first time actors and they all give a good account of themselves. Jojo and LaDainian do a lot of work throughout the film and they've both very expressive and easy to hang out with, although most of their behaviour would probably be described as sketchy at best.
It's an overly quirky film style at times - the buffalos and turkeys randomly appearing do get a little unsettling, but I'm sure they mean something to someone. It's generally nicely filmed - nice use of the scenery and light and shade (although possibly a little too much shade at times). I think it manages to stay the right side of "documenting a lifestyle away from the mainstream" without straying into the "overly worthy/patronising" but I'm really not the best placed person to comment on such matters. I also think that for two white women (Riley and Gina Gammell) to create this, no matter how many Native Americans they consulted with, they are opening themselves up to comments along the "poverty tourism" lines (particularly since Riley cannot be lacking a dollar or two) - critical comment has generally been positive though.
And there's no doubt that poverty is very much on display - these people do not lead glamorous lives and the struggle to exist day-to-day feels very real. Grindingly so, which I'm sure it is, but I do feel the film could have benefited from a little more light to contrast the shade. There's also not enough plot for the length of the film and some of the stories involved go on waaaay longer than they need to - however, I never felt like giving up on it (although it did take me several attempts to get through it).
One other quibble that may be entirely down to me - I found a lot of the dialogue tricky to understand. I think it was a combination of the accents, the language and the sound levels (there's often a large amount of "background" noise, which must be a deliberate choice but not one I appreciated) but at times I really had to pay attention to get some idea what was going on.
Overall, I think there's plenty of promise and some great filmmaking on display here from Riley and Gina - for me it has not, however, resulted in a great film but it's certainly interesting and beautiful in places. If you fancy checking it out, then it's available to rent in all the usual places (and a bargain £1.99 on Apple+) - it's worth a look, but won't be for everyone.
Important, eye opening and unique
martinpersson9723 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This indie drama is definitely recommended for any lover of film, as it is a very unique and thourough presentation - and very much one of my favourite films of the year.
It must be said, though, that it doesn't spare any punches to say the least. It is a very dark and tragic film, depicting the realities of the criminal circles and how even children can be dragged into it.
The actors all do an incredible job, most of them amatours or just normal residents - and I would very much like to see more of them.
The cinematography feels very unique, very small scale and low key, yet very effective and unique. The same can be said for the cutting and editing.
Overall, an amazing film for sure. I would highly recommend this for any lover of film!
It must be said, though, that it doesn't spare any punches to say the least. It is a very dark and tragic film, depicting the realities of the criminal circles and how even children can be dragged into it.
The actors all do an incredible job, most of them amatours or just normal residents - and I would very much like to see more of them.
The cinematography feels very unique, very small scale and low key, yet very effective and unique. The same can be said for the cutting and editing.
Overall, an amazing film for sure. I would highly recommend this for any lover of film!
War Pony: A Gritty Masterpiece of Visual Splendor
billsquires21211 August 2023
"War Pony" is a cinematic masterpiece that captivates audiences with its breathtaking visuals and gritty realism. The film's beautifully filmed sequences transport viewers to a world of raw emotion and visceral action. The portrayal of characters and their struggles is nothing short of spectacular, evoking deep empathy and connection. The filmmakers' commitment to realism is evident in every frame, creating an immersive experience that lingers long after the credits roll. "War Pony" is a must-watch for anyone seeking an unforgettable journey into the heart of human resilience and the art of filmmaking.
It could have been MUCH better
jnbonicar5 September 2022
Slow, long, and boring film ! I was expecting a lot as I'm passionate about the realities of contemporary life on Native American reservations, and I love when a film is shot in a reservation with Native actors, so that's great. The biggest issue in this film is the script, as there is almost no script, this is more a documentary than a film, and that's a shame. The characters could have been more engaging, and they're not involved in a clear story with goals and conflicts, the film lacks conflicts and built, deep relationships between the different characters. The result is that it's not easy to follow what's going on, for we don't and can't know where it's going on. The film is so slow, and long, I watched it at the DEAUVILLE FILM FESTIVAL and several people went out of the theater, the filmmaker herself didn't stay to watch it and left at the beginning to come back at the end, maybe she had something more interesting to do in town. Again, I'm passionate about Native Americans but this film is a missed opportunity.
Bill won me over
h7942322 August 2023
The movie centers around two different characters: Bill, a man in his early 20s, who is hustling in order to maintain his family and his relationship with his two sons from different mothers, and Matho, a much young boy, who's life is spiraling due to drugs and unstable home life.
I was hesitant to like this movie at first, but Bill won me over. At first he just seemed too obtuse, but over time you learn that he just takes that role when he needs to maintain a relationship. In reality, he is a smart and affectionate young man, who might be somewhat too impulsive, when he sees opportunities, but on the other hand, he needs to make money somehow. He is no father of the year, but maybe if he could just find some calm in his life, he would be.
Matho is a simpler character. He is rebellious and while early on he isn't the leader of his little friend group, he raises to that position later. On the other hand, life keeps dealing him a bad hand over and over again even at his very young age.
For most of the film, their paths are separate and despite the relatively small community, they don't even know each other.
We see a lot of examples of the native American culture they come from. I can't really claim to understand all the metaphorical aspects of certain motifs in the movie, but at the same time the characters have also lost their connection to them, so they don't understand them either.
In many ways this feels more like coming from European tradition of film making than American, as the focus is on the characters, not the story, which is just a vehicle for us to get to know the people.
On the other hand, it's also about the wealth disparity these people experience and the repercussions of that. Crime is casual. Many of these people just do it. It's all around them. The few interactions they have with people outside of their culture are quite racist and there's a strong feeling of their people being used.
Overall, definitely worth a watch, if you are into sort of Oscar-baity dramas, but without the baggage of being real Oscar-bait (thus transcending that pseudo-genre).
I was hesitant to like this movie at first, but Bill won me over. At first he just seemed too obtuse, but over time you learn that he just takes that role when he needs to maintain a relationship. In reality, he is a smart and affectionate young man, who might be somewhat too impulsive, when he sees opportunities, but on the other hand, he needs to make money somehow. He is no father of the year, but maybe if he could just find some calm in his life, he would be.
Matho is a simpler character. He is rebellious and while early on he isn't the leader of his little friend group, he raises to that position later. On the other hand, life keeps dealing him a bad hand over and over again even at his very young age.
For most of the film, their paths are separate and despite the relatively small community, they don't even know each other.
We see a lot of examples of the native American culture they come from. I can't really claim to understand all the metaphorical aspects of certain motifs in the movie, but at the same time the characters have also lost their connection to them, so they don't understand them either.
In many ways this feels more like coming from European tradition of film making than American, as the focus is on the characters, not the story, which is just a vehicle for us to get to know the people.
On the other hand, it's also about the wealth disparity these people experience and the repercussions of that. Crime is casual. Many of these people just do it. It's all around them. The few interactions they have with people outside of their culture are quite racist and there's a strong feeling of their people being used.
Overall, definitely worth a watch, if you are into sort of Oscar-baity dramas, but without the baggage of being real Oscar-bait (thus transcending that pseudo-genre).
Exceptionally done
twillmot-7903718 March 2024
There was a great deal to take in regarding this film. My favorite part, which so reminded me of the last scene of FRESH, was when Bill asks Matho if he likes coffee and his answer so expertly and tenderly reveals his inner self and the growth still destined to take place for the two main characters.
Throughout the film their two stories seem intertwined and similar yet as the film extends we see that their trajectories are almost opposite (trying to ascend and trying not to descend) and yet destined to collide, inescapably predictable and refreshingly vulnerable as if one of them may actually be able to overcome the circumstances of their situations only to see that neither can quite generate enough speed to actually take flight.
The film is unapologetic, accurate, true to life on the Rez, and creates many moments that are excruciating to watch. The slow burn fuse in the storytelling is appropriate and effective, could it have moved faster...perhaps, but it gave me a similar vibe to MANCHESTER BY THE SEA and how the film just didn't want to, didn't let you, look away. And it shouldn't. Many great moments, great performances, excellent symbolism, and a plain and raw quality that spoke volumes of truth about human nature, the abject poverty of what is easily considered third world conditions of the reservations in South Dakota, the desperation, the hustling, the utter lack of opportunities, the loss of culture and language, and the blurry delicate lines that must be negotiated for survival and to get one's self even a little bit ahead. I thoroughly enjoyed the film. Not at all uplifting, but definitely makes you think, feel, and need/want to talk to someone what about it. It's a good one!!
Throughout the film their two stories seem intertwined and similar yet as the film extends we see that their trajectories are almost opposite (trying to ascend and trying not to descend) and yet destined to collide, inescapably predictable and refreshingly vulnerable as if one of them may actually be able to overcome the circumstances of their situations only to see that neither can quite generate enough speed to actually take flight.
The film is unapologetic, accurate, true to life on the Rez, and creates many moments that are excruciating to watch. The slow burn fuse in the storytelling is appropriate and effective, could it have moved faster...perhaps, but it gave me a similar vibe to MANCHESTER BY THE SEA and how the film just didn't want to, didn't let you, look away. And it shouldn't. Many great moments, great performances, excellent symbolism, and a plain and raw quality that spoke volumes of truth about human nature, the abject poverty of what is easily considered third world conditions of the reservations in South Dakota, the desperation, the hustling, the utter lack of opportunities, the loss of culture and language, and the blurry delicate lines that must be negotiated for survival and to get one's self even a little bit ahead. I thoroughly enjoyed the film. Not at all uplifting, but definitely makes you think, feel, and need/want to talk to someone what about it. It's a good one!!
A beautiful masterpiece!
bellabmuah15 April 2024
Oh my! I don't get the harsh IMBD rating. This movie is beautiful. It shows love, struggle, pain, and the obstacles you can face when underprivileged. You see two different stories and it is so raw and uncut about live on the Rez. You can see the unfortunate life they have to toggle with, and having no guidance, but yet you see someone hustle their way to try to make a better life. This movie is one of the best movies I have seen! Never a dull moment, and intriguing at every turn. This film is very original, and will have your full attention I can sure. I must also add that this is the first review I have posted and I look tend not too focus on the ratings so much as I do the review. Everyone has a different taste therefore I like to look at comments on top before coming to a conclusion. The trailer grabbed me and I am happy I have it a watch. You will not be disappointed! 10/10.
Courage is found within
johnnykav-266326 February 2024
How much has really changed in our world, how much has really changed for the first people of North America, the ones who it was taken from 3 centuries ago.
2 Oglaka Lakota Indians, one a boy and the other a boy-man, struggle to find their way in a world of poverty and barely hidden oppression. They languidly dismiss what they see as their failed culture, and seek the easy path of the white man's criminal world, that hangs like a veil all around them. Events lift the veil and show them that their path, even in this world, is blocked and so they must return to their own culture for clarity & freedom.
2 Oglaka Lakota Indians, one a boy and the other a boy-man, struggle to find their way in a world of poverty and barely hidden oppression. They languidly dismiss what they see as their failed culture, and seek the easy path of the white man's criminal world, that hangs like a veil all around them. Events lift the veil and show them that their path, even in this world, is blocked and so they must return to their own culture for clarity & freedom.
Hit Piece with a Tattoo
mad-impulse5 April 2024
Feels like a mokumentary of Native American life. Did you notice the Illuminati tattoo front and center on the older kids chest that is never explained? They throw it in your face and expect you to chuckle and forget about it. TY Riley Keough, ex victoria's secret model, for your anglo saxon FreeMason hit piece on Native Americans, who are in actuality, some of the strongest people on this planet with histories that pre-date all white men. It is clear what club these directors are in, as are most directors in Hollywood. Watch people close to Gina Gammel start to expire if she becomes a bigger director. Cheers!
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
