Beau Is Afraid (2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
456 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Think of it as a long nightmare
zack_gideon14 June 2023
If you think of this movie as a nightmare it makes more sense. When you dream, your brain processes deep emotions and fears. Things like guilt, shame, childhood fears (spiders, strangers, water, the woods, etc.) and a lot of times the narrative is confusing and all over the place. This basically sums of the movie.

It's hard to review or summarize, but essentially it's a journey into Beau's subconscious. Fear of sex, mommy issues, shut down emotions, and unresolved trauma.

I sometimes gauge a movie based on how many times I think about it after I've seen it. For this one, I've been thinking about it all day. There are some really creative, artistic scenes and shots also that keep the viewer interested. Overall it's disjointed and way too long, and definitely not for everyone. 6/10.
134 out of 150 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An Incredible Experience I Will Always Struggle to Recommend
kjproulx25 April 2023
I truly don't know where to start with this one. I've become a fan of director Ari Aster. Hereditary and Midsommar are both great movies in my opinion, even though they're not for everyone. He has shown that his style is very much out there and he just does whatever he wants. I admire that in a filmmaker, so I was eagerly awaiting his next outing, Beau is Afraid. Well, it's now playing in theatres and I think it's Aster's best and worst work to date. There's no denying this film is brilliantly well-made, but the actual presentation (story wise) downright baffled me, in good and bad ways. Here's why I really enjoyed watching it, even though it will never be a film I recommend.

Joaquin Phoenix plays Beau, a man with an insane amount of anxiety. On the anniversary of his father's death, he has a plane ticket back home to visit his mother. Things prevent him from making his flight, which in turn leads to him slowly finding his way home anyways. That's the premise in a nutshell, but many other storylines are present as well. From confronting his demons through stage plays, crazy visuals, flashbacks, and some very creative practical effect work, Beau is Afraid is definitely one of the most unique films I've seen in a while. I loved watching this film, but didn't love it as a film overall.

The best way I can explain how much I actually liked it is to say that I think it's a 5-star film on a filmmaking level, but about a 2-star film when it comes down to how effective the story is. I was eating up everything this film was giving me. My jaw was on the floor from how they pulled off certain sequences. I just wish the story became more clear by the end. I was very engaged, but even when the film felt like it was delivering answers, they also felt far too vague. The film plays as if it's giving you all the answers, but I was well aware it wasn't. I never felt frustrated while watching it, because I was loving the journey, but afterwards, I really had to think about whether or not the experience was enough for me. It was, but I have to admit it's not a great movie as a whole.

Beau is Afriad isn't afraid to go all out in every scene. The studio that made this film (A24) also funded it as one of their most expensive films to date. The budget is used to its fullest potential here and the effort leaps off the screen. It's weird, visually stunning, and Phoenix's lead performance is stellar. Other than those aspects though, I was underwhelmed by the story. Still, if you're a film buff who likes to watch all movies, I recommend it, but to any casual viewer, I would say stay far, far away, it's probably not for you. It's a fantastic film to look at and follow along with, but it's simply not great otherwise in my opinion.
376 out of 440 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
You Must Conform to Beau's Norm
aweynand961 May 2023
I remember seeing a headline a few weeks ago in which it was claimed that Ari Aster dropped some LSD before a premiere. I don't know if that's true or not, or whether he takes psychedelics at all, but the man walks around with an imagination that is perpetually, creatively tripping. Like a colorful virus, he infects audiences with "Beau is Afraid" - a mind-bending journey of a film which I wish many people would see, but could only realistically recommend to a short list of open-minded friends.

This behemoth is a lot to digest in one sitting. It's not carried by its characters so much as it is by hypnagogic artillery fire of imaginative sets and set-pieces, most of which have rhyme and reason for existing but some, probably none. The actual plot consists of a paranoid man's surreal, Kafkaesque odyssey to appease his domineering mother. Beau (Joaquin Phoenix) lives in a world where his every decision is governed by assertive women, and every woman leads back to his mother. He's emasculated, directionless, and, as he points out himself, personality-less. The environments around him are nonsense to us. Strangers form theater troupes in the woods, seedy cities are filled with caricatures of real people; anyone's sentence can become a jarring non sequitur at any moment, and no event is guaranteed to be permanent. These depictions are of course exaggerated - but it's hard to separate what is and is not Beau's reality. It's like a strange dream, and the best comparisons I can make are to David Lynch's "Mulholland Drive" or Stanley Kubrick's "Eyes Wide Shut."

But I've only described what this movie is like, and not WHY it is like. Plenty is up for interpretation. At the bottom line, however, is a creative director exploring themes of perceived guilt in awesome, if not totally bonkers ways. Anybody with a narcissistic parent will relate to parts of the film, as well as anyone who is unsure of themselves, or frets over every action (and inaction) they take. I think of Tyrion Lannister's line in "Game of Thrones," defending himself in front of a father who hates him: "I've been on trial my WHOLE LIFE." Beau is literally put on trial for his whole life. There are people who feel this way about an extreme mother. I've got to believe Ari's speaking some personal truths here.

People who saw it before me had mixed reactions - giddy, disturbed, exhausted, confused. I can empathize with all of these. Though Beau held my attention for the entire 3-hour runtime, his performance is draining. And it should be no surprise that the man behind "Midsommar," "Hereditary" and "The Strange Thing about the Johnsons" locks this in with a good deal of shock value. His brand includes bringing out emotion through whatever means necessary, and it will turn some people off. My best advice is to give yourself completely to the experience. Don't try to follow the discombobulated world of Beau too closely, or you'll fall off a cliff every time. Sit back, enjoy yourself, and laugh where you can; there's maybe never been a more twisted humorist at work here.

7.5/10 for reminding me of the time my dad showed me "Mulholland Drive" and I spent a week trying to decipher it.
125 out of 161 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I'm still so confused
gabilumenati20 April 2023
After being so mesmerised by hereditary and midsommar I was really looking forward to seeing this. The acting was really good. Joaquin Phoenix never disappoints with his acting Patti LuPone was phenomenal in her scenes. Even Amy, Ryan and Nathan lane had some great moments, but the first hour of the movie, I was really confused the second hour of the movie, I thought okay maybe they will start to explain a little of what is going on the third hour when it all came together I was even more confused. I left the cinema in total confusion. I really want to like this movie. I neither hate it nor love it.
78 out of 112 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Beau is having nightmares
edwin-wks22 March 2024
I think the best way to approach Beau Is Afraid is to consider it as a series of Inception-styled existentialist nightmares that the real-life Beau is experiencing as he is safely ensconced in his comfy apartment in an upscale part of town. Everything that happens in the movie is then figurative, merely how Beau's mind is trying to process and resolve the difficult aspects of his life that may be hidden from his consciousness. The story consists of three nightmares or acts, each with its distinctive theme.

In Act 1, Beau lives in his dull but orderly apartment, surrounded by the chaos that happens in his building and the lawlessness in the streets. The theme here is that the world is a dangerous place; Beau feels vulnerable, believes that bad things will happen to him, and his apartment represents his safe inner space, which is fragile as danger is always lurking beyond its four walls.

In Act 2, Beau finds himself convalescing in the home of Roger, Grace and their volatile teenage daughter, after an accident. The couple seem inordinately concerned with the welfare of a stranger, yet has placed an ankle bracelet on him. Later, they set their other deranged ward, a combat veteran with PTSD named Jeeves, after him following an incident with their daughter. The theme here is that no one can be trusted. Fleeing from Jeeves, Beau runs into a theatre troupe. During their performance, like a nightmare within a nightmare, we see a story of Beau having a family and subsequently losing them in a natural disaster, only to reunite years later and discover they were never real to begin with. This family represents the life Beau could have had if it were not for his mother's influence on him.

In Act 3, Beau finally arrives at his mother's lavish residence but is too late to the funeral. Mona reveals that she is not actually dead and the body in the coffin is that of the housekeeper, whose death she had bought. When Beau tries to stand up to Mona after years of her tyranny, he is banished to the attic where he finds his emaciated opinionated twin and a representation of his late father's genitals. Jeeves bursts in and starts attacking the father, because if the father is rendered impotent, Beau would not have been born. Jeeves is probably a manifestation of Beau's self-destructive tendencies. In the final scene, Beau stands trial accused of being ungrateful to his mother and is executed as she watches. We see him accept his fate and her shedding tears of self-pity when he disappears into the water. The theme here is subjugation; Mona had always put her needs before her son's, and made him neurotic and dependent so that she had control over him. She did not want her child to differentiate from her and become his own person. Beau Is Afraid is the tale of a narcissistic mother who enmeshed her son, hence Beau's demeanour throughout the movie is that of his young and terrified self.

It is a big ask for people to sit through three hours of this. I watched it in two halves; I was thoroughly derisive in the first half but I appreciated the overall experience and meaning of the story as the second half progressed. Hence I empathise with the detractors and those who applauded this movie alike. As much as Aster might have been self-indulgent in creating this bloated excursion possibly based on a personal experience, I hope that he found catharsis in doing so. Still, I wouldn't recommend the movie without some forewarning and clues.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I feel like I just got punched in the face
FeastMode19 April 2023
What do I even say? I don't know. This movie broke my brain. I'm seriously stuck. It's been two hours and my mind is still racing.

Like the headline, much of what I say may sound negative, but I mean it in the best possible way. This movie is indescribably weird, outlandish, absurd and insane. So many times I thought to myself, "What am I watching?"

This is dark comedy at it's finest. It's so messed up. And I was cracking up. Like everything else in this movie, it takes it to the extreme.

The directing, cinematography and music work together to fully hypnotize me. It's so creative and imaginative with so many things I've never seen or could possibly imagine.

Beau Is Afraid feels like four movies combined into one. That seems like a terrible idea. But each one is amazing. And they all work together. I don't understand how he did it. Ari Aster is clearly way smarter than me.

There are long scenes of dialogue but I was fully glued. And there is usually other stuff going on during those scenes, like something funny in the background or interesting details in the set design. It made me even more engaged as I tried to catch everything.

In an age where so many movies fail to stand out in any way, Beau Is Afraid stands out in every way. It's not for the faint of heart. I think some people will hate it. But if you've seen Hereditary or Midsommar, you know what you're in for. It's very different from them. But just like those movies, it'll remind you how much a great movie can affect you.

(2 viewings, early screening IMAX 4/18/2023, IMAX 4/26/2023)
428 out of 536 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Beau is weird.
Alwayssomething24 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This film is weird. You will not have a good time watching this If you don't enjoy weird films. You also might not have a good time watching this if you do enjoy weird films. If something strange or jarring can happen, it will happen. With that being said, there are certain aspects of this film that are undeniably great whether you like the overall narrative. This film has genuinely funny moments. The scene in the connivence store made me laugh out loud. This film also has many shots and sequences that are just downright beautiful. The animated sequence that goes through the different play sets and the imaginary life of Beau was mesmerizing. The sequence of Beau traveling on the motor boat in the pitch black was amazing. My main issue with this film aside from the 3 hour runtime was that I think it did too many things that were weird for the sake of being weird instead of for the sake of advancing the plot.
45 out of 68 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
It's True What They Say, You Can't Go Home Again, Beau Is Afraid, and He Should Be
RightOnDaddio20 April 2023
This is Ari Aster's worst film. That's not to say it's bad, but it's his worst.

The beginning of the movie starts off with this incredible burst of energy.

Beau is this lonely guy talking his problems with a therapist and living in this dumpy apartment in some unnamed large city.

But it's also a commentary on societal downfall and policymakers stupidity.

It is absolute chaos in the streets. Broad daylight mayhem.

It's like Idiocracy with extreme violence.

And to be honest, it's entertaining as all get out.

The first brilliant half hour to hour of this three hour monstrosity's runtime is when it's running at its full-tilt best.

The apartment. The mayhem. The message on where society is heading and but fast.

All of this is well received.

Is this the Best Movie of 2023?

Am I witnessing the Greatest Movie of the 2020's?

In the first hour or so, you'll be out of your seat and thinking of spots to get this tattooed on your body.

Then we enter the second hour or chapter as it may be.

This is where Nathan Lane and Amy Ryan are introduced, and I love them.

Absolutely love them. By themselves in other projects, and here together even.

Love.

But this is where the film slows considerably and gets weird, and not in your typical Aster good weird, but here just plain sad, depressing, nonsensical weird.

And once Lane and Ryan have played their parts to the fullest in the middle of the film, audience members may start wishing there was a good editor making the hard choices in the house at A24.

In the third and final hour, Parker Posey emerges, in what is no less her most stunningly amazing performance of this century.

She is as gorgeous and incredible as she ever has been, though her scenes are short in this literal journey of a tale.

Patti LuPone truly takes over from where Posey leaves off and devours the remaining scenery in what is definitely her finest performance ever on celluloid.

But the story by now has devolved and is way too prolonged having lost its promise from the first hour so seemingly long ago.

The ending in the most kindest of terms is a monumental disappointment.

All the great filmmakers in history make a bad film sooner or later.

Let's hope this will be Ari's one and only.

Beau Is Afraid. But his movie is too often boring, overly long and unnecessarily grotesque.
86 out of 148 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ari at his best and worst
nesmkz19 April 2023
Beau is Afraid is going to be hit or miss for a lot of people. It's the type of movie that many will praise and criticize for the exact same reasons. Some will find Ari Aster's visceral, nonstop, in-your-face shock and awe absolutely brilliant. Some will find it grotesque, some hilarious, and some will probably just find it plain monotonous. Regardless of where you land personally, I think fans and haters alike will admit it's easy to understand all of those opinions (and more) on the fever-dream, bad-trip, crisis-coaster that is Beau is Afraid.

There are some ideas in this movie that absolutely hit home. The central character, Beau's, downright Fredian psyche is thought provoking and forceful, if not overstated. The movie looks wonderful throughout and showcases phenomenal cinematography. There is also a fantastic black comedy element that I wasn't expecting - both the wry smile kind and laugh out loud type. Beau is Afraid is packed with amusing subtleties that make me want to rewatch the movie just to see what details I missed. On the surface level, this movie considerably richer than Aster's previous two; it feels as though there is so much more to explore here.

What falls short for me isn't any one glaring detail, it's the sum of all the film's parts. It's a rambling, full speed ahead journey it that lasts an excruciatingly long three hours (two hours and fifty-nine minutes, to be exact). This ride doesn't feel like a edge of your seat thriller, it feels like a highlight reel of nightmares loosely strung together. Frustrating, inarticulate, and logic resistant. At points it feels like Aster is openly testing the audience's limits and patience, fully leaning into the fact that many won't hang on until the end.

Kafka-esque is spot on. Beau is Afraid is largely without a plot; the viewer is forced to most of the legwork if they want to reconcile any sort of direction. This could have worked in a smaller dose, but after the two hour mark you start to wonder why there is still so much movie left. Aster's audience engagement leans heavily on visuals and surprises, and somewhere along the three hour journey you start to wonder if that's quite enough.

You don't know what's coming in Beau is Afraid, but as the formula reveals itself you do know that entire movie is about to be turned on its head. Again. And again. And again. Watching the story bounce from one introspective non-sequitur to the next is a rather unrewarding experience. Even though a resounding lack of closure is surely supposed to be a deliberate point of the film, I had to question if I was enjoying it.

There's a very good movie in buried somewhere in Beau is Afraid, but it's layered under a heavy, heavy dose of self indulgence. It doesn't need to be so long, or so frenzied, or so indirect. Aster's core message simply isn't as profound as he makes it out to be. But it's a new side of Ari that we've never seen before and, for many, that alone will make it worthwhile experience. And the movie isn't without a good deal of genuinely redeeming qualities that fans of the genre (if you can narrow it down to just one) will surely enjoy. It's a thought provoking, visually stimulating trip that you should really just experience for yourself. Though perhaps on-demand with the fast forward button within reach, just in case.
289 out of 341 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
You Met Me at a Very Strange Time in My Life.
FelixisaJerk19 April 2023
Beau is Afraid demands us to see it again. It basically screams to be rewatched, paused, rewound, dissected, and examined. The brilliance of writer and director Ari Aster is that these repeat viewings will never ever help you get this movie. It's never going to click and magically make sense - going back to the well will only deepen your appreciation for the craft of the film.

Beau is a marvel of modern cinema not just for its striking visuals, alarming contemporary setting, and technical merit but for the fact that by all means it shouldn't even exist. No superheroes, not a sequel, not pushing a trending agenda or remade from a novel. How can anyone profit from such a film?!

I sound bitter or jaded. I'm not, I just want to express how deeply satisfying it is to see something so original and unique and beautiful and upsetting. Movies like this make me want to get off my ass and get on my ass. I mean to write. Like writing a movie.

Joaquin Phoenix is Beau, who may be one of the least reliable narrators I've seen in a film for a long time. The movie follows him on what should be a simple trip to visit his mother, but from what I can gather, nothing is ever simple with Beau. Beau's journey takes us through at least six vastly different settings but they feel like alien dimensions that effectively skew reality but also mash genre, medium, and technique. I think I'd like to leave the synopsis at that, the premise is set up in the opening scene and what unfolds becomes an odyssey unlike anything I've ever seen. To attempt an explanation or listing every character and actor seems like it would be a disservice.

It's gross, it's vulgar, it's profound, it's gorgeous - there is no shortage of adjectives to use here. Most importantly, it is worth your time. Beau is Afraid is a story that can only exist as a film and that's a true mark of greatness.
239 out of 337 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Loops
HumbleMensa28 December 2023
Oh my gosh it's brilliant, to a point.

Watching this can only be equated to what I believe 500 cups of coffee, no sleep, and functioning mental illness combined would be like. Several times I actually stopped to rewind (or, whatever it's called now, I backed up a few frames) to rewatch what I just watched, shouting "WTF just happened"...it's an adventure in madness, like a song with lyrics that take you from midnight through to 5pm the next day and you're still at the bar playing random jukebox tunes while everyone else has gone home. This movie, seriously the director or producer or maybe all of them...just said action and told the actors to just do or say whatever the heck they wanted to say or do. Joaquin does a great job being the guy he's supposed to be and if you know, you know. Unfortunately, amongst the madness some of the story really never gets there and it's one heck of a LONG movie to not quite get there. Hence, I have to stop at a 7. I wish future watchers luck...it's one heck of a ride.
16 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not a story. A string of pathological metaphors.
CSHaviland23 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Artistic styles come in two basic forms. You have your more lifelike art, which is meant to capture a moment in time through the imagination of the artist. The other is abstract art, wherein an artist has no intention of spoon-fooding you what to think, but is hoping to manipulate your feelings.

And it's not binary. Most art falls into a spectrum somewhere in between those two extremes.

If you've ever seen a David Lynch production like Eraserhead you'll recognize the abstract side of that spectrum, because you'll realize the futility of sorting out an actual plot. David Lynch, like sometimes directors David Cronenberg (Videodrome, eXistenZ, etc) and Terry Gilliam (Brazil, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen, etc) or writers like Charlie Kaufman (Being John Malkovich, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, etc), confuses reality on purpose and likes characters who roll with it, so that you have no choice but to roll with them. They have no intention of making sense. Their movies are often an attempt to throw off your sense of reality and ask you to simply except what you're seeing instead of try to understand it.

Beau Is Afraid falls into that category, but nonetheless, I'm going to try to understand it anyway.

This movie spends its entire time inside the mind of a man who clearly suffers from extreme anxiety, but it's hard to pin down what exactly it is that he's afraid of. And unlike movies like David Cronenberg's Naked Lunch, we're offered no obvious reason why Beau is seeing some of the weird things he sees. Is he schizophrenic? Maybe. Ari Aster does not want to answer that question, he wants you to ponder on multiple possibilities. And like most art that leans on the abstract side of the spectrum, each viewer is likely to reflect differently on it, and come up with their own answers (if any at all).

From what I could tell, there were many clues in the movie that seem to imply that his anxiety disorder is caused by something sexual. A sexual trauma, perhaps. From graphic graffiti at in the earlier sequences, scenes where he is attracted to a girl his age but believes he will die if he has sex with her, and a creature his mother calls "his father" locked in an attic that is basically a monster made out of male genitalia, the movie is riddled with disturbing sexual references. (Not unlike something Cronenberg would do.)

And his mother seems to be at the center of this problem. He behaves in a way that is constantly befuddled, and apparently victimized by every possible circumstance he stumbles into, but it all seems to have something to do with the way his mother treats him. Each sequence of the movie is another angle at the same problem, but in very different ways, and with perhaps red herrings to throw you off the scent.

In one very key shot, apparently a flashback, there was a POV scene of him in a bathtub and the young girl he has a crush on is sitting at the side of the tub, she gets up and exits the frame, but the camera pans over to see his mother entering the frame from the same direction - and approaching his young self. (He is effectively outside of himself observing his relationship with his mother.) His mother tries to remove his clothes for bath time and he resists, asking for his father. (It's not clear why he wants his father. Certainly not to undress him. My feeling is it was for protection. Why would a boy his age need to be undressed by his mother?)

The reason I think this is important is because I think the director is signaling to us that his mother might have sexually abused him through much of his childhood, and lied to him about his father and about his own sexual health in order to keep him tethered.

But yet there was an earlier scene wherein he was imagining himself in a play where he actually found a wife and had kids with her, and occasionally this wife looked like a man. (This man, we learn later, is identified as Beau's father.) Beau spends an entire lifetime in this staged story looking for his lost wife and kids (who had disappeared after a terrible flood) and finally he meets up with his sons all grown up. That this was framed as a stage play is no accident. It was an imagined reality.

Something about all that makes me think he had an intuition of being lied to all his life, and that his father represented the truth: that he could have a family all along. But we don't know what really happened to his father, and whether the man he met at the traveling theater was even real. Either way, his mother was very mean and impatient with him, and manipulative. She did not seem to approve of his natural interest in girls, and even seemed to enjoy watching him flirt with the idea of being with girls to see how it would play out.

It was she who frightened him into a life-long resistance to find love in the arms of another woman. When he finally broke down and at least believed he had intercourse with that childhood crush, now grown up and played by Parker Posy, and did not die, we learn that his mother apparently observed (and probably set up) the entire thing. When the girl died (at least figuratively), his problem shifted from having fears of himself dying to a feeling of terrible guilt for "killing" the woman he loves - a role which I think his mother insists on filling.

The final sequence was his trial, but unfortunately there was no redemption to be found here. Disappointingly, it appears he symbolically lost his battle with anxiety, false-guilt and low self esteem, and his mother won. No payoff to be found for the poor audience, who has sat through 3 full hours of this!

All in all, I would have rated it higher if the film was about 1 hour shorter and his long, painful journey of self discovery and failure to stop the pattern of "self incrimination" and "guilt" due to probably sexual abuse was rewarded at the end with something happier, something psychologically triumphant. But it wasn't. It was like watching someone die of cancer and then die without fixing anything in his life. So why was I taken on this ride into hopelessness? It's not like Phoenix's Joker character which was a portrayal of a man who chose evil due as a response to his unfortunate medical condition and the cruelty of life. The character of Beau went absolutely nowhere and changed nothing. He just learned the truth about himself, and his mind judged him guilty despite all that.

The movie is labeled a comedy and a horror, which is not quite accurate. It was satirical in many places, perhaps intending sarcasm about the violent world we live in. But it was neither that funny nor that scary. I'd have simply called it a psychological drama and satire.

Phoenix is an absolutely amazing actor, but I would have advised him to take another look at the third act and insist on a stronger payoff.
306 out of 370 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
More than enough
Groverdox7 September 2023
"Beau is Afraid" starts brilliantly, proceeds intriguingly, and finally gets so weird it becomes annoying and overstays its welcome.

They say you only know how much is enough when you know how much is more than enough. I remember with Aster's previous movie "Midsommar", I actually considered turning it off early on, because it seemed massively overlong and moved very slowly. It seemed it might become boring. I persevered, though, and realised Aster knew exactly what he was doing with the length and slow pace, lulling us into a false sense of security, making us empathise with the characters and feel the complex emotions they'd be feeling.

A director hadn't held the audience in the palm of his hand since Kubrick.

With "Beau is Afraid", it feels like Aster loosens his grasp on us toward the end. The movie just gets so unaccountably bizarre that I lost interest a little bit. You know it's not going to answer its questions, and then it asks so many, you lose track of them and stop paying attention.

The end still has flashes of brilliance, mostly Kubrickian and Lynchian touches, like startling still shots, and a meeting with a strange man who knows more about the protagonist than he should, a la the indelible, nightmarish scene with Robert Blake in "Lost Highway".

Joaquin Phoenix also gives a great turn, similar to his triumph in "Joker". His work here is Oscar-worthy, but we know it won't get any attention from the Academy, because the movie's just too weird, as with Aubrey Plaza's brilliant work in the similarly inscrutable "Black Bear".

Aster looked on track to become one of the all time great directors. His first movie was very good, and his second was great. Kubrick, Scorsese and Spielberg all took longer than that to make their first great movie. "Beau is Afraid" is a small misstep. I'm hoping that now Aster knows where the limits lie, he'll continue to go up to them, but won't need to go over them again.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A reminder of the stranger by Albert Camus
mhajibandeloo14 September 2023
A fascinating movie with an exceptional ending, can't tell how much I enjoyed the movie and the ending reminded me of another masterpiece the stranger by Albert Camus... Only this time the mother herself is the judge.

The thing that makes this movie precious is that we don't see young directors delivering these kinds of movies specially at this quality. Anyway I'm not a professional when it comes to movies and I'm not sure what to call the genre of Bea is afraid but for sure it's my favorite. The only bothering point is the length of the movie which makes it hard to be watched several times and at the same time it requires you to do so.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Feeling sad about going home, Beau?
beatrice_gangi30 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Beau is Afraid is easily the most experimental movie yet directed by the talented filmmaker Ari Aster, as well as another A24 production bet. The film is enjoyable both as surreal, grotesque and unpredictable odyssey and as a true interpretive challenge, in which the viewer is required to make an active effort in understanding the meaning behind the picture.

Interesting interpretative key, is that of a journey, not physical but mental, that Beau undertakes in an attempt to emancipate himself from the toxic relationship he has with his mother, in which what we see on the screen is a combination of a psychological journey and the representation of reality as perceived by Beau.

To simplify the discussion, one can divide the film into four main sections.

In the first, Beau's "starting" psyche, as the beginning of his mental journey, is depicted. The grotesque, cruel, and menacing characters who inhabit Beau's neighborhood are the various representations of his paranoia, fears, and shame, but also of his mind's feeble attempts to "make him wake up" (represented by the notes passed under the doorway of his apartment). It is particularly interesting how, in order to enter his home, these characters wait for Beau to leave the glass door open, which they instead break through to exit the building. This shows how, intrusive thoughts completely dismantle the mind's defenses after managing to penetrate even once, leaving them destroyed to break in again and again, but more and more easily.

The second and third parts, that is, the momentary settling of the protagonist first in a new home, and later in a "home that is not a home" (the forest), represent the slow process by which Beau realizes how, building his own satisfying life, his own family, and his own path, implies the need to free himself from the conditioning of his mother, as much as of his cowardice and passivity.

The fourth and final part, the confrontation with his mother, leads to Beau's "killing of his mother," but also to his final and total undoing in his eventual inability to defend himself from her "immortal" judgment.

For those who are no strangers to mental health issues, the incredible work of writing and staging, and of portraying a fractured psyche, is evident.

While the movie does have flaws, including its somewhat exaggerated length, Beau is Afraid is a film that unabashedly discusses and addresses many of the most intrinsic fears of the human soul, exploring yes a sick and co-dependent relationship between mother and son, but also the human terrors that nurtured and engendered it.

Even in one of the most grotesque scenes, that of the identification of Beau's "monster in the attic" in the form of a giant, monstrous penis, while delirious, is but a nightmarish image of many sad truths inside Beau's heart: his fear of the other is in there, his lack of a father figure is in there, his inability to grow up, his having been emasculated when he was just a child, his mother's obsession with the risk of "being replaced by another woman", his fear of not being allowed to create his own family, his anger, shame, disgust, and guilt, are all represented in that one almost ridiculous and senseless figure.

Although it may be a difficult film, and not a particularly commercial one, Ari Aster has managed to create a truly profound, absurd, complex, and unique product, memorable and powerful, and it is fortunate that there are production companies like A24 ready to believe and invest in such projects.
120 out of 166 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Great ideas in a too histrionic film
david_castillo711 March 2024
I loved what I have watched from Ari Aster...until this one movie. It is not that I dislike it. In fact, I think it has some brilliant moments that stole a laugh from me. The acting is superb. The cinematography is beautiful to my taste and suits well with the story. But...yesss, but it is way too histrionic at times and too long as a whole. As a plain viewer and nothing else, some scenes are way too long (like the very last one), where the point is made within the first minute or two and there is no need to keep it 20 minutes long. And that gets me out of the story. It might be the pace, the editing or even that I am not getting something I should.

I don't like or dislike the movie. I do know that if it was about one hour shorter, I would have been more compelled. And that is what I believe this art of cinema was invented for.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Ouch
sktraut24 April 2023
This whole movie is an exercise in anxiety. It's pretty much "Anxiety the Movie." Not horrific, just claustrophobic to the point of suffocation. There is a lot to unpack and multiple viewings will help with this one. Guilt is another big theme, guilt thrust upon a child from their parent. Nearly every scenario Beau is in involves animosity toward him. He is never safe from danger on some level. He can't leave or enter his apartment walking: he has to sprint away from people -- everyone really -- looking to hurt him or harass him on some level. He has been taught to be afraid from everyone and himself.

But even if you don't get it, and I don't think I got even 30% of what Ari Aster is going for, the movie is hilarious, if you have a twisted sense of humor. I almost peed my pants laughing at the first of many scenes involving a bathtub (you'll know what I mean when you see it). It's hilarious and that's really why I loved it so much.
117 out of 179 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
perfect
Kirpianuscus29 August 2023
A perfect film.

I admitt, my definition for Beau Is Afraid is a profound subjective one and, I suppose, after its end, each impression, verdict, opinion about this fim can not be other than subjective at whole.

Because it offers , in my case, a significant dose of memories about different experiences.

Because Joaquin Phoenix is, again, just great.

Because the dominant mother and the anxiety of adult son , helpless, scared, victim of creepy events, unsecure, vulnerable moment by moment is mixed with familiar slices of fairy tales .

Because al is realistic, from the family looking for a surogate son to the sadistic teen feeling ignored, from the sex in mother bed to the fight against venerable lady and so Kafkaiesque trial of the last scenes..

The essential piece of story is represented by Phoenix eyes.

In short, perfect. Sure, for fundamental subjective reasons.
8 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Do NOT watch if you're struggling with anxiety disorder
pateerick24 April 2023
Ari Aster's superfan here. I LOVED Hereditary and I still believe it's one of the greatest horror movies in history. Midsommer was a bit of a pastiche of Hereditary, but enjoyed it nonetheless. But I'm at loss of words with Beau. I don't even know what rating I should give.

So yeah, as you already know, this movie is nuts. I kinda knew it was but I wasn't prepared to experience what I sat through. The very same morning I went to the theater, I had talked with my therapist about the possibility of me having anxiety disorder. I've been on medication before and stopped, but I think I really need to go back, because I've started to experience panic attacks again. Being a fan of Aster I knew what I was putting myself through, and I thought, what the hell, let's watch this friggin film.

A panic attack feels exactly how this movie portrays it. And I had a full blown panic attack in the theater but I couldn't leave since I had brought some cousins with me. The first hour was enough to make me feel that way. And so I sat through this thing waiting for it to end.

So, this movie is brilliant because it manages to represent how mental illness FEELS, and for a movie to be able to do that is fascinating. But while I think is brilliant and shows the general audience how such states of mind play out for people with this disorder, I also feel like its a disservice to represent this condition in such a pessimistic, misanthropic and plainly cruel light.

While I know that this is a very subjective experience, I just needed to throw this out there: if you're struggling with anxiety, obsessions and phobias, stay away from this film until you're ready to take it; or just read the trigger warnings and come prepared.

There's a chance yo might feel represented, but there's also a chance you feel triggered and upset. Still, I plan to watch it and come up with a more objective rating once I work through my stuff (no mommy issues btw, just generalized anxiety! Lol). Cuz for a film to be able to do that, I must concede, it should be a masterpiece.
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Disappointing
parksiet27 April 2023
Couple things:

1. I don't like being negative about movies.

2. I love when filmmakers and creators take big risks and make original, creative movies that we haven't seen anything like before. Watching directors take huge swings, even when they miss, is infinitely more compelling than safe mediocrity.

That being said... I thought Beau is Afraid was terrible. I might even say... unwatchable.

And that really disappoints me. I love seeing big risks pay off and love to champion those films, and I really hate having to say I didn't like a movie. I'd usually give a wildly original film like this the benefit of the doubt for taking a big swing even if it doesn't fully pan out... but to me, Ari Aster missed the mark in every possible way with this film. The film felt like it was someone telling you all the unnecessary details of a nightmare they had as you slowly lose interest. The story had no rhyme or reason, and stuff just kept happening that never made sense to me. I really admire the originality and the skill behind the camera - it is still a technically well-made movie, and Joaquin Phoenix really commits to the role. The movie does do a good job of immersing you in the psyche of its protagonist. But overall, it just did not work.

This is a perfect example of when art-house cinema becomes too much - the movie is inaccessible. If I as a cinephile struggles to get through the third hour of the movie, I can't imagine what it must be like for a member of the general moviegoing public. Like, the first 45 minutes were promising, but everything after was almost unbearable. Nothing worked for me, and I even questioned whether I could sit through the rest of it. The movie is far too long and is a slog to get through. It is also so obnoxiously self-indulgent. I do need time to digest it and think about it, but overall my gut feeling is that this movie really did not work for me. To me, it was terrible, which is such a surprise since I thought Aster's previous films, Hereditary and Midsommar, were quite excellent (albeit disturbing).

I see why this film is so divisive, and I am very upset to say that I ended up on the negative side on this one. It's 100% an original and unique movie - I've never seen anything quite like it...

...but maybe that was a good thing.
341 out of 479 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Truly an Unforgettable Experience
wshqbms21 April 2023
It takes a bit to let this movie truly sink in. It is one of the craziest fever-dream odyssey style movies I've ever seen. Ari Aster absolutely broke out of the style of Hereditary and midsommar. This was its own monster. It had parts that were extremely anxiety provoking, or were hilarious, boring or extremely intriguing. It was almost painful to watch, but afterwards i can't stop thinking about it (in a good way). I am very impressed.

I think most people will be turned off/ not get the movie, but for some it will totally click. It's peak absurdism, and probably the most fascinating depiction of anxiety I've seen in film.

One of the only flaws I have with this movie is the sheer run time. It is extremely long, and will test your patience in parts. There are parts that could've been cut out, sure, but nothing that truly took away from the film.

Would I recommend watching it to most? No. But you should still see it regardless. It will more than likely impress you.
68 out of 103 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting Mess
sps-7065920 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Thought I had a free ticket for this one, would never intentionally have paid as much as $10, I know Aster's form.

It improves, from a blurry opening sequence, but never really finds its way, and overdoes the gross-outs. It won't make Joaquin's Highlights Reel, when he finally retires from the biz.

In the middle, there is a lengthy cartoon or fairy-story digression that could almost be excised entirely, and the movie wouldn't be any better or worse.

Sometimes, a messy movie can fall over the line, by really nailing the ending. This one does the reverse.

After 2 1/2 hours of bloated mommy-guilt and family psychosis, we could do with a little finesse, or a neat sidestep.

Instead, Aster amps it up even more, and plays the guilt all over again. Literally inside a stadium. Literally with an announcer.
22 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Interminably Long for What it Delivers, Which is Very Little...
Xstal20 May 2023
If you lived in Beau's world you'd have nightmares all the time, as the characters and encounters round the bend they would entwine, there's confusion and blind panic, just about everyone is manic, and if they're not, they may have tendencies, that would leave you disinclined; as we journey through a life, or are we really on a trip, all heading to a funeral, or are we heading to some ship, where an emperor of metaphor, is exposed, disrobed and stripped, and you may feel, after three hours, you've been part of some grand trick.

Bored to tears for the most part, although the performances are great, as you'd expect, but the relevance to me was close to zero and as such, it drowned in its own effluent.
168 out of 231 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Beau is Afraid
Jeremy_Urquhart28 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Beau is afraid, and the movie he stars in is three hours long Beau is living in a collapsed society, or an alternate reality, or a dystopian future Beau is going to a therapist Beau is someone with mommy issues Beau is hated by his neighbours Beau is constantly in danger of being murdered Beau is locked out of his apartment Beau is stabbed Beau is hit by a vehicle Beau is awoken in a strange house Beau is a bed thief Beau is taking drugs he doesn't want to Beau is trying to avoid drinking paint Beau is unable to prevent hitting his head on a log Beau is aware an audience is watching him Beau is unaware an audience is watching him Beau is unsure what stage of life he's progressing through Beau is late for a funeral Beau is even more afraid Beau is surprised by news about a family member Beau is judged and put on trial Beau is... ?

Beau is not in a movie that can be easily rated, but for now, I think it might be a 7/10 Beau is Afraid caused five people to leave my theatre, and there were no more than 20 people in attendance.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
7/10. An incredible experience but not an incredible movie
athanasiosze25 July 2023
1) This is a movie that you've got to watch it at least twice, in order to understand it better. Simultaneously, this is a movie that most of the viewers will be able to watch it only once.

2) Ari Aster fell victim to his own brilliance. Brilliance is one thing. Taming our own brilliance is another. If you don't know how to handle/deal with your ideas, instead of owning them, they are the ones that own you. There is a masterpiece beneath this pile of weirdness. There is a story of a broken man that got paralysed by his environment. This could be a magnificent allegory about every struggling, depressed person. Instead, the viewer watched these terrible last 30 minutes, minutes that changed the nature of this movie. Ridiculous "monsters" in the attic and an overused Oedipus complex.

3) The "forest scene", i mean what happened in the forest play, is one of the greatest scenes of this millennium. Seriously, had it ended there, this would be a masterpiece. It could also ended in the scene with Phoenix and Rosey (you can understand what scene i mean) and this would still be a great movie. But, no, we had to watch the gibberish of the last 30-ish minutes.

4) In conclusion, i definitely recommend for any art lover to watch this movie. Congratulations to A24 who funded this artistic creation. Please, don't be discouraged. This is an overambitious artistic creation that failed. But i prefer a thousand times something like this, instead of all these dumb/repetitive movies which literally have nothing to offer to a demanding moviegoer.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed