"Gilligan's Island" Man with a Net (TV Episode 1966) Poster

(TV Series)

(1966)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Gilligan chases after a butterfly and some laughs.
Ralphkram16 July 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This is another episode which falls firmly in the middle of the pack. The ingredients are there for a comic romp a la Voodoo: a solid guest star; a ridiculous plot to hang gags on; and a group scavenger hunt. But it never really pops, mainly because it becomes redundant and pretty ordinary in the second act, and the ending is predictable and a bit of a letdown.

Gilligan's head gets caught in the open by a Briton with a large net. As usual, the Skipper doesn't believe his story until he sees the Briton for himself. He is noted butterfly collector Lord Beasley Waterford, hot on the trail of the pussycat swallowtail, the rarest specimen in the world. They find out Lord Beasley has a boat and a flare gun, and he'll let them and the other castaways return to civilization with him. All they have to do is help him catch the swallowtail. In fact, he nearly nets it, until our lead yelps for joy over his news and causes his first miss.

Lord Beasley is initially a fun and interesting character. He is so singularly focused on catching the butterfly that he is oblivious to both his surroundings and the desperation of the castaways to leave the island. All the early scenes are solid. While on safari with the Howells, he nearly sinks in quicksand; the girls watch him do some accidental cliff diving. The best scene, though, is when the Professor, in a bid to connect with Lord Beasley, tries to show off his butterfly knowledge and gets caught using crib notes.

To show his level of absurd dedication, he even walks by the group in a diving suit.

He becomes less fun and interesting as a martinet leading his castaway regiment. His followers soon spend the rest of the entry trying to go AWOL. Their plots against him aren't any more fun than his militarism and are ineffective.

There are the usual formulaic attempts at bribery and seduction. Lord Beasley gives little attention to Mr. Howell's bribe, and Ginger's pillow talk ends with a stinging rejection.

Frustrated, the castaways conspire to get Lord Beasley drunk on a concoction made from fermented berries. Their plan to drink him under the table works as effectively here as it did with the Russian cosmonauts. The scene has its moments, but has a very anticlimactic finish. Once again, the castaways outsmart themselves (if that's possible), and Lord Beasley gets his man.

COCONOTES:

Veteran character actor John McGiver does a commendable job as the stuffy Lord Beasley. His dry wit and understated style works very well in places. He is known for his work in such films as Breakfast at Tiffany's, The Manchurian Candidate, and The Glass Bottom Boat.

Given how rare the Pussycat Swallowtail is supposed to be, we see two of them--one yellow, one orange-- within moments of each other.

Now the island has a mountain. It's pretty obvious that's a rear projection shot as Lord Beasley climbs its side.

The girls continue to somehow build their wardrobe. Mary Ann sports three different outfits in the span of a day we haven't seen before.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
GET THE PUSSYCAT SWALLOWTAIL, PLEASE!
tcchelsey8 May 2022
Enter John McGiver, one of the BEST character actors in the biz. You can find him just about anywhere and in some truly classic movies. He was a diamond in the rough. Here he plays the rather stuffy (as usual) Lord Beasley, a renown collector of butterflies who, of course, steps out of nowhere to visit the island.

Beasley's focus is the rare Pussycat Swallowtail which has everybody running around with nets! This is goofy stuff that all us kids grew up on back in the day and McGiver is the whole show. This guy is over the top! Interestingly, Mr. Howell (Jim Backus) has a funny closing line, not Lord Beasley. Now that's a switch.

Another episode that keeps you wondering; how and why do all these kooks show up on the island --and yet the castaways are never rescued??? The ending is most always the same with the guest of honor talking about his or her exploits on the famous white radio, but totally forgetting everybody else! Poetic license 101.

Note the change and style in directors here. Veteran Leslie Goodwins headed this episode, who began his career in the 1930s with comedy shorts. Among his other tv shows was MY FAVORITE MARTIAN. Goodwins just let the camera roll and let the cast do their schtick, particularly McGiver, who I am sure did not require a second take! This guy WAS the eccentric butterfly catcher. The "one take" style was quite the norm with many directors, especially those who worked on low, low budget productions in their career where every dollar counted. If you truly had a talented cast (naturals), it made good sense, and the results were even better than expected. It shows.

The color in this episode is beautiful, and note Ginger and Maryann's wardrobe changes. Where they came from, we don't know! SEASON 3 EPISODE 7 1966 restored dvd box set. Get this.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
John McGiver as Lord Beasley
kevinolzak19 June 2016
"Man with a Net" guest stars John McGiver in the title role of Lord Beasley Waterford, world famous butterfly collector, on the trail of the pussycat swallowtail, the rarest species in the entire world. He arrived by boat, with a flare pistol to signal when he's ready to leave, eccentric to the point of sinking in quicksand or falling from cliffs in his single minded search. Lord Beasley's insufferable attitude has all seven castaways carrying nets around the island, unsure if they can even identify a pussycat swallowtail. The Professor tries to impress him through crib notes, while the Skipper fails to convince by painting a butterfly. John McGiver was a fine comic actor but this just isn't one of the funnier episodes.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed