Half Broken Things (TV Movie 2007) Poster

(2007 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Where deficiencies within the human psyche lead to the abyss.
RJBurke194210 December 2011
This is billed as a drama and thriller. It should, more correctly, be labeled as horror – and quite a suspenseful one at that.

The story concerns a fifty-nine-year-old woman (Penelope Wilton) who house-sits through an agency. She's been doing it for decades but, as we soon learn, this is her last job: when she turns sixty she'll be discharged with no prospects for further work. That type of future, of course, is a recipe for depression – and other things.

Coincidentally, we are introduced to a young con man (Daniel Mays) – but a likable one, sort of – who works the rural and suburban areas for objets d'art that he can steal and sell-on to shady dealers. He's currently on the run from one of his escapades that went wrong. And, while still running, so to speak, he comes across a battered woman (Sinead Mathews) at a petrol station who pleads with the young fellow to take her away – quickly, please quickly – from her abusive and violent partner. Being the good Samaritan, he impulsively does the right thing. Or, so he thinks.

Realizing that he needs more money now – with a woman on board and a pregnant one, at that – he sets out to find another easy mark somewhere. Ultimately, he decides to pull into the large mansion where the good house-sitter is ensconced, in the hope of perpetrating another con. Making that decision, however, seals the fate of all three - as well others...

There are three elements that help to keep this narrative flowing logically: first, the consistent adherence to cause and effect that determines plot; second, the psychology of the three main characters, each of whom needs psychological help like an alcoholic needs the next drink; and finally, a believable script that is thoughtfully presented and well acted out by the three protagonists/antagonists. It's almost unnecessary to say that the direction and editing are flawless.

Life is all about cause and effect, obviously. Everyday life is also about co-incidences, many of which are strange, even weird. Hence, the use of co-incidence as a plot device in this story is well within reasonable limits, I think. Some viewers might disagree, however.

The most unsettling aspect for me, and other perhaps, is that the whole story shows the extent to which seemingly average – whatever average means to you – people will go to protect their interests and well-being, including performing horrific acts when it appears no other option is available.

Who has never said "I'll kill you for thatÂ…"? Who has never had the darkest thoughts about how to handle a perceived enemy? Oh, I'm not excusing the horror of this story. I'm simply pointing out it's a very human story about many so-called average people; and three who throw caution to the winds and who make self-serving choices when escape seems impossible.

It's a story for adults, of course; I'd suggest that most teenagers would be bored, however.

Highly recommended.

December 11, 2011
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The madness of three
bexandbarn17 April 2009
There is something so utterly implausible about this story but it is done so well that you can't help being sucked in and believing it. For the film makers to depict three varying dysfunctional and desperate characters whose behaviour is so morally inexcusable yet still manage to generate empathy in the viewer shows a great deal of skill and professionalism. Penelope Wilton is excellent in her understated portrayal of Jean, a pathetic and lonely old woman who slowly descends into madness. The actors who play Steph and Michael are brilliant, too. This is down to a credible script and great directing, as well as heaps of skill by both of the performers.

Make no mistake, this film is tragic and so will not appeal to a lot. There is a desperation and darkness throughout which is tangible and reminiscent of the atmosphere created in 'The Visitor', although this story's protagonists are unhinged and not just desperate and lonely.

British film making at its most intense and best.
23 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Evil appears as Virtue
Leon-553 June 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Three people (Jean, Michael and Steph) from very different backgrounds, land up together and spend time in an almost idyllic setting.

Jean, a matriarchal figure, desperately tries to create the life she could never enjoy before. She had to look after her mother and from this and other statements she makes, one can conclude that she had difficulty in finding and or maintaining meaningful relationships.

Michael and Steph's conduct perfectly illustrates how seductive one's own desires can be. The "I deserve this" attitude blinds them to the reality of what they are actually doing. Because they have challenging lives, lies and deceit, theft and common criminality becomes acceptable and is almost glamorized in the movie. The viewer is made to sympathize with their self-centered delusions. Vulgar crime is portrayed through a soft lens of acceptability; crime is excused because of the "deserving" circumstances.

When Michael and Steph enter Jean's life, the scene is set for her to create her fantasy world. Jean seems fair and soft spoken, decent, moral, virtuous and respectable. But in fact Jean is manipulating others in order to satisfy her own needs - with deadly consequences. Jean looks pure but is in fact fatally tainted. Jean is the epitome of pure evil.

This movie makes for very good entertainment and is well worth a watch. It makes one realize that sometimes you have to take a step back and critically look at what you are doing. The "Me-Me-Me" attitude of so many people today, can in fact be very dangerous...
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I see nothing but trouble ahead for this family.
mark.waltz20 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
The universal interest in the BBC period drama "Downton Abbey" opened up much interest in the ensemble cast, many veterans of the British stage and screen, but their names outside of one grand dame unknown to us Yanks. For me, seeing their other work has become a hobby, and in the case of Penelope Wilton surprising that I had seen her in several films years before the series. This TV drama, just a few years before the series, shows her range, and she's fascinating.

As a lonely older unmarried woman who makes a living house sitting, Wilton gets what because of her age will be her last assignment, and ends up in a situation beyond her control, taking care of the abused single pregnant Sinead Matthews. She's run off from the abusive father and taken up with the kind hearted, concerned Daniel Mays, who happens to be a petty thief. Wilton allows them to stay at the country estate with her, becomes attached and helps them deal with a tragic turn of events. But the chances of them getting caught become greater and greater, especially when Mays starts to sell off the artwork.

A complicated situation, a serious bunch of deceptive lies and a limited period of time, this doesn't give the characters any chance of a happy ending, but getting to know these people does give them sympathy, even though Mays deals with the possibility of exposure rather violently. Not exactly the easiest of dramas to get into as the fraud gets more intense and threatening, but it's certainly a very unique situation that has very dark turns. Wilton is quite commanding, playing a very misguided woman whose years of social exclusion have manipulated the way she thinks. This is a very difficult one to pick up, but once you get hooked, you're not going to want to let go.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Superb and harrowing portrayal of desperate delusion
robert-temple-114 March 2008
Tim Fywell has been perhaps the best British television drama director for many years now, and it is a mystery why he has not been gobbled up by the big feature film producers yet. But here he is with his latest offering, and it is just as chilling and anxiety-producing as his eerie and unforgettable Barbara Vine dramas of the 1990s. This disturbing and nail-biting tale is based upon a novel by Morag Joss and is excellently scripted by Alan Whiting. What puts the whole project over the top into a realm of its own is the impeccable casting and the acting by the three principals. Penelope Wilton, Daniel Mays, and Sinead Matthews are so overwhelmingly convincing that one simply cannot imagine anybody else playing any of their roles. They absolutely became those people, to a terrifying degree. The intensity of this film is almost unbearable. The characters come together to live a dangerous joint fantasy life in somebody else's empty house. All of them are seriously damaged souls who have suffered terrible psychological deprivation or even physical abuse. In each other they finally find what they have always been looking for. But living a dream is dangerous, because there is something big and threatening called Reality which doesn't like people to do this and get away with it. What will happen? How bad can it get? The intensity rises, and rises, and rises. No pity is shown to the viewers who maybe can't stand all of this anxiety, want to turn it off, but can't. What solution can there possibly be? By now we are so enamoured of the three characters that we want them to win, they are all so endearing, so pathetic, so much at the very edge of human desperation and need. Why can't people who have been driven that far find some comfort and be entitled to it? And then the moral barriers begin to become permeable, and things begin to leak through, dripping, dripping, ominously. And the clock is ticking.
42 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An excellent, crazy drama.
Sleepin_Dragon21 January 2021
What happens when three lonely people, all of whom are looking for something, be it love, support or comfort, encounter one another, and begin living a lie, a sumptuous, comfortable, glorious lie?

What a wonderful ninety minute drama this is, it's so incredibly weird and wonderful, but engaging, funny, intriguing, and has a real shock moment.

It starts off In a somewhat serious tone, then becomes an almost whimsical drama of wonder and disbelief, until the traumatic act that totally transforms the story.

Stef had come from an awful home life, Jason truly was a monster, Michael started off as a petty thief, was Jean perhaps the most deluded and crazed of them all? Did she perhaps cause the events?

I wonder if like me, you kept on waiting for people to turn up?

It's crazy, it's brilliant. 9/10.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A very memorable TV DRAMA
rich-fletch23 October 2021
Once in a while, a tv drama grabs your attention and becomes memorable. This is a tale of desperate people flung together, making the best of their lives under a cloud of a big lie.

Great performances throughout.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This is one of the best black comedies ever written..
mrshagboozcash12 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This is my very 1st review of anything I've seen or heard...so il make it short but to the point..as for British humour goes this is 10.10..but my partner says I must be sick to have found it in anyway funny...all the characters gave 💯% performances. The irony in the corner shop had me in stitches..ha ha ha...it's a truly dark masterpiece of a flick..& no way could I have imagined it finishing in the way it did..!!!..a must watch
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Uncomfortable Viewing
crumpytv9 September 2021
I can't say I found this drama at all entertaining.

It started off ok with an interesting storyline but soon it degenerated to a level where it was impossible to have any sort of sympathy with the lead characters.

The inevitable ending was unfulfilling because there was no way that it could have ended positively.

Good performances, but flawed characters.

Downloaded from YouTube.
0 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed