Z odzysku (2006) Poster

(2006)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Retrieval: Slawomir Fabicki and the morality of choice
matt-szy2 January 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Slawomir Fabicki graduated from the National Polish film school in Lodz. He makes films in the vein of serious Polish Cinema, by way of drama, a Polish genre of choice. And he does drama well. His diploma film, Meska Sprawa (A Man Thing) was nominated for an academy award for best foreign film. His next film and first feature, Z Odzysku (Retrieval), has been gaining similar attention and may have similar results. Fabicki might just be one of Poland's next great filmmakers.

Go as far as to say Fabicki is the next Kieslowski, albeit modern. The issues are the same. Human loss. Waning morality. The grey between good and bad. Fabicki approaches these matters without an upper handed morality or pretense. He balances things out. He shows how good can come from a bad choice and bad can come from a good one. He shows realistic characters living in realistic environments, who make epic decisions. And he does this convincingly, as Kieslowski did. Fabicki is modern though, because he shows these issues in today's world using today's filmic conventions, respectively, unemployment, immigration and drugs, with long documentary hand-held shots, hard cutting and parallel scenes and then some.

Retrieval is about a young man, Wojtek, who wants to provide his Ukrainian girlfriend and her kid with a financially comfortable life. But he reaches these ends by means that result in him loosing everything. His morality sways in his attempts to make real the ideals which he envisions. They diminish in the name of materialism. He wants to give her simple things. A house. Money. But she wants to reach this level of comfort by way of hard and honest work. Though, she does works in a strip club. But she is only a janitor there. And yet in order to avoid such dishonest circumstances which Wojtek has gotten everyone in she is willing to give her body to the hustler. No one is perfect.

We can also look at Retrieval like this: The hustler is the realist. He finds financial security and safety for his family by manipulating others to do his dirty work while he reaps the material rewards. Unlike Wojtek he is willing to get what he wants at all costs, with no doubts or restraints. The hustler has no limits to his immorality – he is the modern man. Fabicki professes that the moral man will have it harder, will have to teeter between the means to a comfortable life and what is moral. He may fail at first, as does Wojtek, by loosing everything, but he will continue because he knows what he wants, it is just a matter of finding the means to get there. Being good is not easy. Being good and living comfortably is even harder. We see Fabicki doing what Kieslowski did. And like Kieslowski, Fabicki, despite the trouble his characters face, the seemingly never ending trouble, at the end we see hope. Woytek, beaten and battered by circumstance, he struggles to move forward, repent, and try again.

In a catholic country where religious tradition has been tied to daily life and consequently politics, issues of morality become prominent in art. (Uhem, not just Poland. But so much it is visible, especially in the national cinema.) Considering the recent history of Poland – the rocky transition to capitalism and entrance into the EU, corruption and unemployment, and before that it was communism, and before that WW2 – Fabicki has successfully tapped into a cultural soft spot of pain and projected it via film. And however common it is for filmmakers in Poland to focus on similar subject matter tied to the pains of the ingrained culture and history of Poland Fabicki does it successfully with honesty and, simply, taste.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Film about Polish Life in the 2000s!
Sylviastel11 February 2020
The cast and crew did a fine job in displaying Polish life. Wojtek is a young Polish man who falls in love with a Ukrainian young mother. Fabicki, the film's director, was a promising start. He depicted Polish life as it is in the post Communist world where Poland is trying to rebuild itself as a capitalistic society. Wojtek would learn that money and materialism isn't everything. While Poland has come a long way since Communism, some things still stay the same.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A stunning portrayal of morality
Gordon-115 April 2007
This film is about a man's struggle between the strive for a better life and morality.

The film does not have beautiful sets or costumes. Instead, it uses the detailed description of the psychological conflict to draw the viewers. Wojtek starts off as a hard working person, in order to provide for his girlfriend and her son. After getting the first taste of big bucks, he spirals into the underworld. Initially, he refuses to cooperate with the gangsters, but he succumbs to lucrative financial rewards.

The portrayal of Wojtek's inner struggle is amazing. I could feel his pain and confusion. The transition from a caring Wojtek to a ruthless Wojtek is remarkable and thoughtfully shown. Katia stands for a high moral value, and the conflict between the couple is palpable.

The only disappointment I find with the film is that the ending is too abrupt.
12 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Weak and shallow plot and result is a dismal movie
sclerozo19 December 2008
I was unlucky to see this movie at the Toronto International Film Festival and now by chance I came across it on IDMB. I was hoping it might have been a movie I missed and after realizing what it is I decided to post my comment.

I can't believe how this pathetic movie garnered some awards as it appears to have. The plot is banal and approaches stupid as the unconvincing downfall of this man is portrayed. Somehow the director tries to portray that hard work will get you nowhere in post-communist Poland and the attachment with a gang lifestyle also leads to a calamity. The ending is so abrupt and unexpected that it leaves the audience wondering whether the film reel missed a splicing.

I would like to watch a Polish movie worthy of the time to see it and this one falls so far behind that and I truly regret the wasted time.
2 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed