"Doctor Who" The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Five (TV Episode 1986) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"You can trust me, I am a Doctor." The start of a new Trial story.
poolandrews19 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Five starts as the Valeyard (Michael Jayston) continues the case for the prosecution & directs the court's attention to the Matrix & the events about to unfold on it. The TARDIS arrives on Thoros-Beta during the year 2379 where the Doctor (Colin Baker) & his companion Peri (Nicola Bryant) explore a cave where they are attacked by a mutant fish creature called the Raak which was placed there to operate complex machinery that extracts energy from the sea, the Doctor & Peri are found by humanoid guards & taken to the laboratory of Crozier (Patrick Ryecart) to be interrogated. However the Doctor & Peri manage to escape & find a half man half wolf type creature, part of Crozier's unsuccessful genetic experiments & they also come face to face with an old enemy the evil power hungry slimy slug like creature Sil (Nabil Shaban) & other's of his race...

Episode 5 from season 23 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during October 1986 & was the second four part story segment from the Trial of a Time Lord season, originally called The Planet of Sil which was changed to Mindwarp when it was made this sees the return of Sil last seen in Vengeance on Varos (1985) the previous season. Directed by Ron Jones this is an OK opening episode but it hasn't grabbed me as being anything more than that, the script by Philip Martin forms the present section of the trial after The Mysterious Planet was the past & happens directly before the Doctor is taken out of time to stand trial. I look at The Trial of a Time Lord season as four separate stories as opposed to one long one with three of the four segments written & directed by different people who worked independently of each other with the trial scenes inter-cut to give the season a running continuity, it's an idea I quite liked during The Mysterious Planet but it's starting to become tiring here as the thing keeps cutting back & forth between the main story & the court room scenes. I wouldn't say there's anything really wrong with Mindwarp so far except that it's the usual Doctor lands on a alien planet & quickly finds himself in trouble type scenario with nothing to make it stand out above any other similar story except that it marked the final adventure for well liked (by me anyway) companion Peri.

This time around Sil looks far more green that the brown bronze colour he was during Vengeance on Varos otherwise he's still the same memorable slimy slug like creature we remember even if one got the feeling he has been reduced to nothing more than comic relief, I mean there's no real reason for him to be here at all otherwise. The planet's leader Kiv is also seen & the make-up & monster suits are actually very impressive & look quite gross on occasion. There's also a huge long toothed fish creature thing that gets killed off pretty early that we never get a good look at, if that wasn't enough there's also a Werewolf creature that too looks surprisingly good. When the Doctor & Peri arrive on Thoros-Beta (in reality a pebble beach somewhere in Brighton!) there's some neat video effects as the sea, the beach, the cliffs & sky are all changed into startling bright colours which works well although it does look very odd after a while.

The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Five, or Mindwarp Part One, at only 25 minutes in length is a decent opener which entertains & maintains one interest without ever being outstanding. I liked it, I didn't love it but I did like it.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Mindwarp
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic20 September 2019
Review of Parts 5 to 8 of The Trial of a Timelord.

The season long overarching story The Trial of a Timelord continues with this second segment spanning parts 5 to 8 which is known as Mindwarp.

While the previous story The Mysterious Planet had the huge plus of finally portraying the 6th Doctor in a warm, heroic and likable way the main negative aspect of this story is that it sadly deviates back to an unpleasant characterisation of The Doctor. It is unclear within the story whether the Doctor's behaviour is deliberate or the effects of undergoing a 'mindwarp' after an experiment. Either way the outcome is Colin Baker is back to portraying The Doctor as an unlikable, uncaring, selfish narcissist who acts in quite a villainous way in the middle part of the story. It is really disappointing. Thank goodness the trial scenes, the first episode and the final episode of this story has a far more positively portrayed Doctor continuing some of the work done in the earlier story. It seems though that writer Phillip Martin and others behind the scenes such as Eric Saward and John Nathan-Turner had an obsession with trying to make the Doctor 'dark' and unstable which they impose in the middle 2 episodes. It is a very bad idea in my opinion and nearly ruins the story. Flashing back and fore to the trial scenes is a big plus in this story as it shows The Doctor is horrified and disowns his bad behaviour.

The story we are shown as trial evidence depicts The Doctor and Peri on Thoros-Beta where they encounter scientific experiments for mind transfer as well as slimy villain Sil who they have met before in Vengeance on Varos. They also meet King Yrcanos and a number of other characters who are all engaged in fighting one another. It is a mess of a story with too many ideas, too many characters and too many silly events. Writer Martin fails to imbue the script with enough subtlety or intelligence to make this a really good serial but there is plenty of fun and lots of little things which make this not a bad adventure at all overall.

The plus points are: The first episode which is interesting and entertaining. The fun effect that makes the alien world look different. The wise re-use of the fantastic model shot to show the vessel where the trial is taking place. The make-up and performance of the 'dog-man'. The return of the repulsive Sil, his make-up/costume and his fine performance (by Nabil Shaban). The initial scenes with Colin Baker and Nicola Bryant before they take 6 in a strange, unpleasant direction for the middle episodes. The dark idea of experimenting on beings and transferring minds. The ehuberant Brian Blessed as Yrcanos. Lynda Bellingham and Michael Jayston as The Inquisitor and The Valyard.

The direction and writing leaves a lot to be desired but the beginning especially and end as well as the trial parts are decent so it ends up a below par but not bad 4 part adventure.

My ratings: Part 1 - 7.5/10, Parts 2 & 3 - 6.5/10, Part 4 - 7/10. Overall - 6.88/10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I don't really understand...
Wisewoman6226 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This entire season is titled "Trial of a Timelord". We are watching episodes we haven't seen before interspersed with trial scenes with the Valeyard accusing The Doctor with the crime of interference. He seems to have a real hatred for The Doctor and keeps insisting that when all his evidence is presented, the Council will want to execute The Doctor. Yet, way back in Arc of Infinity (Peter Davison)we learn that the execution of a Time Lord is a very rare thing indeed. I would think they'd sentence him to any number of their other "punishments" before executing him. There are quite a few episodes to go, so we'll see how it plays out, but I'm tired of the Valeyard constantly calling for the destruction of The Doctor.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Five
Prismark1012 June 2019
The second story on The Trial of a Time Lord saga is popularly known as Mindwarp.

You eyes will certainly warp with the garish neon opening scenes with pink seawater. It is something straight out of a David Bowie video of Ashes to Ashes from 1980.

The Doctor and Peri land in planet Thoros Beta. The Doctor knows that the predatory capitalists the Mentors are here. The story sees the return if the vile Sil who featured in Vengeance on Varos. The leader Mentor Kiv is ill and scientists have been engaged in body experiments to save Kiv.

It is a dark story from writer Philip Martin. In the first episode we encounter a wolf/man hybrid who begs the Doctor and Peri for help. Colin Baker is more restrained in his performance and has a genuine friendship with Peri while also leading her on to danger.

The good bit is Brian Blessed spent most of the episode comatose. You can tell the director is holding his booming voice and fruity performance back for later episodes.

The bad bit in the first episode are the cutaway to the dreary trial scenes. Even the The Inquisitor has had it with the brickyard jokes.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A terrific start to Mindwarp.
Sleepin_Dragon27 December 2019
The Doctor and Peri land on the vivid planet of Thoros Beta, the home world of Sil, and discover some disturbing experimentation occuring.

Part one of Mindwarp, it's a much, much better story than Mysterious Planet, definitely more interesting, this is a terrific start.

The opening is great, the planet looks wonderfully alien and colourful. The story is dark, and has the main thing needed that the previous series lacked, menace, and there are multiple sources, wonderful to see Sil return.

Baker and Bryant are a terrific duo, the pair have a great on screen rapport here, they seemed to soften the relationship for Colin's second season.

Excellent. 8/10
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed