"Doctor Who" Enlightenment: Part One (TV Episode 1983) Poster

(TV Series)

(1983)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Satisfying Fantasy Adventure
Theo Robertson31 January 2014
Materalising aboard the hold of a sailing ship The Doctor and Turlough are brought up top see the ship's Captain . The sailors aboard the ship have trouble remembering details of how they got on board the ship and The Doctor soon realises things are not what they seem

Enlightenment isn't a classic of the Davison era but in the context of a very disappointing season it's the best story . It's full blown fantasy and normally it's not the sort of story that appeals to me but what makes it enjoyable is the design of the sets and the costumes . In many ways it's almost like a period drama and a lot of thought has gone in to these designs . It's somewhat stagey and this is in no way a criticism though it never reaches the acting tour de force we saw in the previous year with Kinda

There is a slight problem with the casting and that is well known comedy star Keith Barron is a distraction and Leee John from camp pop group Imagination is every bit as dreadful as expected . This is down to JNT insisting on casting well known faces regardless of how suitable they were and this casting was a major factor in the death of the show . One other contentious piece of casting is Lynda Baron as Wrack . Watching her scenes in general and the ones alongside Turlough in particular you do think perhaps there might be a strong sexual subtext going on but there's a lack of on screen sexual chemistry . If this was Nuwho the production team would no doubt ensure there's plenty of estrogen and testoseron being splashed around

Not a brilliant story down to the fact that the air of mystery only works once before the cat is let out of the bag Enlightenment is entertaining , contains good model work , incidental music and brings The Black Guardian trilogy to a satisfying close
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
For me far & away the best of the 'Guardian Trilogy'.
poolandrews13 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: Enlightenment: Part One starts aboard the TARDIS with Turlough (Mark Strickson) & Tegan (Janet Fielding) playing chess while the Doctor (Peter Davison) is busily trying to discover what is responsible for a power drain. Soon it turns out that the White Guardian (Cyril Luckham) has been using power from the TARDIS to project himself & send the Doctor a message, soon after the White Guardian fades away & disappears as the TARDIS materialises aboard what the Doctor first thinks is an Edwardian racing yacht. However while exploring with Turlough several things make no sense like the crew men who have no knowledge of boarding the ship & all the futuristic electronics in the wheel room...

Episode 17 from season 20 this originally aired here in the UK during March 1983 & is the start of the third & final part of the Guardian Trilogy following the equally terrible stories Mawdryn Undead (1983) & Terminus (1983), the fifth story from Peter Davison's second season playing the Doctor I have to say straight away that Part One of Enlightenment is a huge improvement on the previous stories from the Guardian Trilogy. The script by Barbara Clegg was originally called The Enlighteners before script editor Eric Saward decided to use it as the third & concluding part of the Guardian Trilogy & as such included the Back & White Guardians & completed the subplot with Turlough & as such retitled it to Enlightenment. I have to say I really rather enjoyed this one, I liked the traditional Edwardian ship setting which sets up an effective cliffhanger ending when all of the viewers expectations are turned on their head (you see not every cliffhanger needs to have the Doctor in mortal jeopardy although these do tend to be the more memorable ones...). The character's are alright if a little mysterious at the moment which is good since I am intrigued to watch Part Two & see where the story is going & at only twenty five minutes in length it doesn't outstay it's welcome.

This episode sees the return of the Black Guardian (he returns here in Enlightenment after his return in Terminus after his return in Mawdryn Undead after his initial appearance in The Armageddon Factor (1979) from season sixteen) & indeed the White Guardian after his last appearance in The Ribos Operation (1978) also from season sixteen & his first in the Guardian Trilogy. The one question that I keep asking myself is why do they both wear dead birds on their head?! Like most period BBC productions the wooden panelled Edwardian yacht interior looks very nice, there is some reasonable model work at the end of the episode but not much else in the way of special effects as the episode is fairly exposition heavy as it sets the scene & the story quite effectively in my opinion. This story is notorious for it's factual error when every time the ship rocks from side to side any liquid stays completely static & still which it obviously wouldn't. Here while the Doctor & Tegan enjoy some dinner the ship shakes violently yet the wine in their glasses remains perfectly still...

Enlightenment: Part One is a good start to the final story of the Guardian Trilogy, as far as I am concerned it's a huge improvement on the previous two stories which I consider amongst the worst during the Davison era.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
It's a surreal, curious, great start.
Sleepin_Dragon30 October 2019
The Doctor hears a muddled message from The White Guardian, he mustn't lose the race, then ends up in a space race.

A great script from Barbara Clegg, I have to say I've enjoyed each one of them, Enlightenment does however stand out. I've always loved a bit of intrigue and mystery in Doctor Who, and this has lots of it. So many strange events, strange characters and surreal events.

It's a gorgeous looking episode, the sets and costumes are very good. I was very glad to see the DVD release contain updated special effects, it does add an extra something to an already strong visual episode.

Great to see Cyril Luckham return as The White Guardian, albeit only fleetingly, a wonderful actor.

Science fantasy, it's not particularly a favourite of mine, but it has some great aspects.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Entertainment
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic24 November 2019
This is an entertaining adventure which is visually enjoyable, has fun characters, has an interesting concept and has some drama and excitement.

This is the concluding story of the Black Guardian trilogy and involves the White Guardian guiding the Doctor to arrive amidst an interplanetary race. The race is for the prize of 'enlightenment' and is between members of an alien race 'the eternals' who have spacecraft which look like sailing ships from Earth history and are using human crew they have taken from their time on Earth. It is a fun idea and provides a lot of enjoyable scenes as well as visually beautiful images. The Special Edition with CGI enhancements give additional lovely looking effects although the spacecraft themselves possibly look nicer in the original model shots. Overall it looks great anyway and the sets and costumes are good.

The dialogue, themes and storyline are strong and the acting is of good standard. Peter Davison is on form and it is nice to have a strong female villain with Lynda Baron as Wrack. Indeed this has a female writer Barbara Clegg and a female director Fiona Cumming who both did excellent jobs.

The arc about the Black Guardian and his influence on Turlough is concluded well and after the great first part of the trilogy Mawdryn Undead was followed by a disappointing middle part Terminus, this gets back to a high quality final chapter.

Is this perfect? No. Is this thoroughly pleasurable to watch? Yes!

My ratings: All 4 episodes - 9.5/10.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
...
wetmars12 March 2020
This was a okay episode, I guess and did you know that this is the only Doctor Who story to date to be be both written and directed by women. :0
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed