Here's another very brief (4 min.) movie from the stage conjurer Georges Méliès, not as elaborate as his famous Trip to the Moon, but sweet and funny. The Magic Lantern features Punch and Pierrot, two painted Commedia Dell'arte clowns, cavorting in a child's bedroom with over-sized props. The clowns assemble an enormous magic lantern, place a candle inside it, and project moving images onto the wall. After viewing a selection of brief film clips, including a kissing couple, the clowns collapse the sides of the lantern to reveal a surprising number of dancing girls inside. (After all, if it's a Méliès film there must be chorus girls!) A vigorous dance is performed, and one spectacularly athletic brunette dancer seizes the moment and steals the show. At that point, a fight breaks out between Punch and Pierrot over the girl's affections. The other girls flee, and gendarmes arrive. I won't spoil the ending, but it's safe to say the cops soon regret their attempt to intervene.
9 Reviews
The Magic Lantern is enjoyable Georges Melies short
tavm27 August 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Georges Melies really outdoes himself in The Magic Lantern. We see two clown-like men assembling a giant projector lantern where we see film of some couples talking. Then it opens to reveal some dancing girls followed by one particularly athletic one. Then they close and open the lantern to reveal some more girls, this time some slow ballet dancers. Then the police come as the clowns close the box lantern again. When it opens again, we see a jack-in-the-box-like creature moving his neck up and down constantly. At this, the police run away as all the dancing girls come back as we fade out. While enjoyable, I wish the version I saw had some music scoring instead of complete silence. Well worth a look for Melies fans.
More Melies Magic
JoeytheBrit6 December 2008
This might be a film from the early days of cinema but Melies was already a seasoned practitioner of the infant art back in 1903 and it shows in this relatively sophisticated special effects short. The premise is simply - as all films were back then: two clown dolls create a magic lantern in a child's bedroom and project moving images onto a bedroom wall before revealing a small army of dancing girls concealed in the lantern. The film begins to resemble a variety show at this point before culminating in a fairly surreal sequence featuring an abnormally tall figure taunting the police who arrived to break up the clowns who began fighting over the affections of one of the dancing girls. The film is quite amusing, but even at less than five minutes it seems a little overlong.
Méliès's Self-Reflexive Film
Cineanalyst2 February 2008
After Robert W. Paul's "The Countryman and the Cinematograph" (1901), as well as the Edison Company's remake of Paul's film, "Uncle Josh at the Moving Picture Show" (1902), Georges Méliès's "The Magic Lantern" is the earliest film that I know of that self-reflexively has as its subject a cinema screening. Self-reflexive films have been of exceptional interest to me and that this one is very early makes it even more precious. Aside from the self-reflexive element, this is a typical trick film by Méliès. He had previously used the tricks he employs here, including the multiple-exposure technique used for the projected film-within-a-film. Paul also used the same technique in his film. Moreover, both self-reflexive films were, as would often be the case, comedic.
Yet, there are notable differences between this film and Paul's film. First, Méliès's film doesn't take place in a theatre, but rather is supposedly set in a nursery, and the characters we see are toys that have come alive. Second, the projector of the motion pictures is a magic lantern with circular vignettes projected upon a black wall. The circular framing was typical of magic lantern slides, but what is projected are certainly not slides, but are motion pictures. It's a curious choice that Méliès would pretend the magic lantern capable of projecting motion pictures, although magic lantern shows were commonly used between films in exhibitor's programs back then (including in Méliès's shows at his Robert-Houdin Theatre), and the magic lantern was a notable precursor of cinema in respect to the projection of images.
The third and more important distinction between Paul's film and Méliès's is in their insight into the medium. "The Countryman and the Cinematograph" was ingenious for its time in this respect, as it explored film's doppelgänger role and its deceptive nature. "The Magic Lantern" also takes up the doppelgänger theme: the film-within-the-film begins with a bewigged eighteenth century man and woman kissing (in a medium close-up shot reminiscent of the Edison Company's "The Kiss" (1896), which must have set the standard, as cinema's first kissing scene, for such framing) and then dissolves to images of our two toy characters. As was the case in Paul's film, the characters are astonished to find themselves watching their doubles. Although Méliès had discovered many cinematic tricks in the nearly eight years since he attended the Lumière brothers' first commercial screening on 28 December 1895, he still revealed cinema's greatest trick to be its nature of reflection.
To top it off and depart from ground already touched upon in Paul's film, the magic lantern is taken apart to introduce six dancing girls. Another dancing girl (Zizi Papillion) comes from out of frame to perform some can-can kicks and other acrobatics. They leave, but then even more dancing girls turn out from the magic lantern, with Papillion returning for more can-can kicks, at which point the two toys fight for her affections. Toy soldiers come to break this up, but soon we're back to more dancing girls. It's not a very sophisticated conclusion, but it's light entertainment typical of Méliès's trick films, and, besides, Zizi Papillion had quite a kick.
Yet, there are notable differences between this film and Paul's film. First, Méliès's film doesn't take place in a theatre, but rather is supposedly set in a nursery, and the characters we see are toys that have come alive. Second, the projector of the motion pictures is a magic lantern with circular vignettes projected upon a black wall. The circular framing was typical of magic lantern slides, but what is projected are certainly not slides, but are motion pictures. It's a curious choice that Méliès would pretend the magic lantern capable of projecting motion pictures, although magic lantern shows were commonly used between films in exhibitor's programs back then (including in Méliès's shows at his Robert-Houdin Theatre), and the magic lantern was a notable precursor of cinema in respect to the projection of images.
The third and more important distinction between Paul's film and Méliès's is in their insight into the medium. "The Countryman and the Cinematograph" was ingenious for its time in this respect, as it explored film's doppelgänger role and its deceptive nature. "The Magic Lantern" also takes up the doppelgänger theme: the film-within-the-film begins with a bewigged eighteenth century man and woman kissing (in a medium close-up shot reminiscent of the Edison Company's "The Kiss" (1896), which must have set the standard, as cinema's first kissing scene, for such framing) and then dissolves to images of our two toy characters. As was the case in Paul's film, the characters are astonished to find themselves watching their doubles. Although Méliès had discovered many cinematic tricks in the nearly eight years since he attended the Lumière brothers' first commercial screening on 28 December 1895, he still revealed cinema's greatest trick to be its nature of reflection.
To top it off and depart from ground already touched upon in Paul's film, the magic lantern is taken apart to introduce six dancing girls. Another dancing girl (Zizi Papillion) comes from out of frame to perform some can-can kicks and other acrobatics. They leave, but then even more dancing girls turn out from the magic lantern, with Papillion returning for more can-can kicks, at which point the two toys fight for her affections. Toy soldiers come to break this up, but soon we're back to more dancing girls. It's not a very sophisticated conclusion, but it's light entertainment typical of Méliès's trick films, and, besides, Zizi Papillion had quite a kick.
Try to Project
Hitchcoc14 November 2017
Two men in classic French clown dress build a giant movie camera. After many trials they finally are able to project a scene on the wall. It is a couple of lovers trying to smooch. After being bored, they take the sides off the projector and inside are a group of female dancers. One particular is more talented than the others and proceeds to outshine them. This ends and is repeated with ballerinas this time and that same woman. The dancing is shaky at best, but it is visually OK.
Weird - Truly Weird
Rainey-Dawn12 July 2019
What can I say about this film short? The dancing is okay - not the greatest dancers was used in this bizarre work. The main dancer to me was the worst of all yet she was the star.
The film is under 5 minutes long - it's worth watching if you want to see a very different silent film short.
6/10
The film is under 5 minutes long - it's worth watching if you want to see a very different silent film short.
6/10
Apparating women apparently love to dance!
planktonrules6 September 2020
I am an odd person in that I've seen at least a couple hundred of Georges Méliès silent films. So because of this, I noticed a lot of familiar stuff in :La Lanterne Magique". Had I not seen all these other films, I probably would be more favorable about this film.
Two characters from the Italian Commedia Dell'Arte plays of the Rennaissance...Pierrot and Harlequin, two clowns. The pair make a HUGE magic lantern (like an early slide projector powered by a lamp). Soon, the magic lantern bursts open and woman come out of it. And, like I've seen in so many of Georges Méliès' films, they begin inexplicably dancing! In fact, every time that women show up in this movie, they start dancing! Ultimately some soldiers arrive and the clowns disappear...leaving a bizarre creature in their place.
This is okay...nothing special here. As I said above, there's a lot of familiar content here. Well made but familiar.
Two characters from the Italian Commedia Dell'Arte plays of the Rennaissance...Pierrot and Harlequin, two clowns. The pair make a HUGE magic lantern (like an early slide projector powered by a lamp). Soon, the magic lantern bursts open and woman come out of it. And, like I've seen in so many of Georges Méliès' films, they begin inexplicably dancing! In fact, every time that women show up in this movie, they start dancing! Ultimately some soldiers arrive and the clowns disappear...leaving a bizarre creature in their place.
This is okay...nothing special here. As I said above, there's a lot of familiar content here. Well made but familiar.
Creative & Entertaining
Snow Leopard3 February 2005
This creative little feature is one of the more entertaining of Georges Méliès's many short visual effects movies. It has some witty ideas that are put onto film with good craftsmanship and plenty of energy, and it is not without some light but subtle commentary as well.
It starts with two clowns setting up a "Magic Lantern", and then they use it both as expected and in unexpected ways. There is quite a variety of visual effects, and almost all of them are executed carefully and nearly seamlessly. The tricks with the dancing girls might be particularly impressive, since it clearly took some doing to make them work.
The pace also builds nicely, from an easygoing start to increasingly manic activity. It works well, and makes for good entertainment.
It starts with two clowns setting up a "Magic Lantern", and then they use it both as expected and in unexpected ways. There is quite a variety of visual effects, and almost all of them are executed carefully and nearly seamlessly. The tricks with the dancing girls might be particularly impressive, since it clearly took some doing to make them work.
The pace also builds nicely, from an easygoing start to increasingly manic activity. It works well, and makes for good entertainment.
Nice
Michael_Elliott27 February 2008
Magic Lantern, The (1903)
** 1/2 (out of 4)
aka La Lanterne magique
Two clowns create a magic lantern (more like a projector), which allows them to see what they're doing on the outside world. When the open the lantern seven women jump and and the film turns to song and dance. The most interesting aspect of this film is the early use of projecting one image onto the same scene in a movie. This wasn't the first time this trick had been done but it looks very good here. The film runs just under five minutes, which is actually too long because the second half of the film, dealing with the dancing, is all rather boring. For those new to the director this is probably one you should keep for later.
** 1/2 (out of 4)
aka La Lanterne magique
Two clowns create a magic lantern (more like a projector), which allows them to see what they're doing on the outside world. When the open the lantern seven women jump and and the film turns to song and dance. The most interesting aspect of this film is the early use of projecting one image onto the same scene in a movie. This wasn't the first time this trick had been done but it looks very good here. The film runs just under five minutes, which is actually too long because the second half of the film, dealing with the dancing, is all rather boring. For those new to the director this is probably one you should keep for later.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
