User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Fu Manchu and the perils of Anita.
ulicknormanowen26 September 2021
Charles Vanel is now world-wide famous for his fifties movies (Clouzot's "le salaire de la peur" "la vérité" and "les diaboliques" -his character in the latter spawned the Colombo figure-) but his career began in the silent era ,with notable works such as Jean Grémillon 's "Maldone" With the coming of the talkies,he went on to become one of the greatest French actors, whose career lasted till the late seventies.

He 's here cast in a dual role, an oriental thug a la Fu Manchu and an actor in love with his co-star Anita. It has not to be taken seriously :Fu -Manchu meets "the perils of Pauline" best describes it. Vanel,made up as anasiatic villain is guaranteed to net nothing but horse -laughs .

But interest lies elsewere : in the French early thirties, most of the movies were often adaptations of plays,static, talky and very dull. This one smartly blends fiction and unrealistic reality :for instance ,there's a successful unexpected twist which makes the scenes in King Fu's den a spoof on the would be yellow peril ;the rest of the movie follows suit: are the characters in a play or are they in jeopardy in the event? There's a good use of shadows and light, the German co-director Karl Grune being obviously from the expressionist school ;he was neither Lang ,nor Murnau ,but his movie was not derivative in the early thirties.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
At Best, A Curiosity.
lchadbou-326-2659222 September 2020
When the simultaneously filmed German version of this bizarre early talkie opened in Berlin, it was according to Variety booed so strenuously that the lead actress had to calm the audience down. The French version is probably not one of the parts that the late, great Charles Vanel would want to be remembered for: a dual role as King Fu a vaguely Asiatic criminal terrorizing a city,and a ham actor Scalpa who is his look alike. The Orientalism besides trafficking in such Yellow Peril Fu Manchu stereotyping also indulges in some second rate exotic dance sequences. The expressionist director Karl Gruene (most famous for The Street) does get to pull off some stylized art direction of urban thoroughfares by night and looming shadowplay but these strategies lack the serious import they would have had in the context of one of his German silents.It all seems rather silly and contrived and poorly thought out.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed