Have a general preference for, as far as Popeye cartoons go, Fleischer Studios' output. A vast majority of them are better made, more inventive and funnier, they tended to be formulaic in terms of story but when they did their changes of pace (and they had a number of those) they were generally better than those of Famous Studios.
Not implying here that Famous Studios' output isn't good. Much of it is, the later years did see evidence of tight budgets and hasty deadlines which accounted for the inferior animation quality (a general issue with later Famous Studios actually), the stories being more formulaic and the humour not as plentiful or imaginative, also more amusing than hilarious. With that being said, most of them were among the studio's better efforts in an increasingly inconsistent output, better than the late Herman and Katnip and late Casper cartoons, being still funny and with great character interaction and even better music.
Although one of the better World War II Popeye cartoons, 'Spinach for Britain' is still not one of the best representations of Popeye. The best Popeye cartoons are great to classic, this fits under the good distinction.
'Spinach for Britain' is not perfect although there is not an awful lot wrong with it. It is occasionally a little on the heavy-handed side and It is not hard to figure out what happens next and how the cartoon is going to end.
Inevitably there are stereotypes, but luckily while unsubtle it is not in an offensive way.
The conflict is stronger here though than in the two previous world war cartoons with Popeye fighting the Japanese because the personalities are more interesting. Popeye is likeable and amusing as well as resourceful and brave, he seems comfortable and fits well here.
Writing-wise, there is very funny material in 'Spinach for Britain' and it does boast some inventive moments visually and in the well-timed gags. As said, the characterisation is strong, meaning that there is tense and humorous interaction.
On top of all this, the animation and music are without complaint. The animation is fluid and beautifully detailed, everything looks meticulous and like a lot of effort and care went into it clearly. The music is outstanding as always, lushly and cleverly orchestrated with lots of energy, it adds to the action and enhances it even. Jack Mercer does a great job as Popeye and makes the most out of his material.
Altogether, good. 7/10 Bethany Cox