The 5 Mrs. Buchanans (TV Series 1994–1995) Poster

(1994–1995)

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A light precursor to Desperate Housewives
VinnieRattolle18 January 2016
Four sisters-in-law with little in common share deep friendships, thanks in part to their dealings with Mother Buchanan, their cantankerous mother-in-law. Alex is a quick-witted, sharp-tongued Jew who is married to eldest son Roy, a school principal. The den-mother of the group, she delights in trading barbs with Mother Buchanan. Delilah is a ditsy, busty former stripper who fell in love with crusading preacher Charles. Status-conscious Vivian is continuously exasperated by her twin sons and is stuck in a passionless marriage to stuffy Ed. New to the group is Bree, a beautiful, self-involved, seemingly-airheaded former Disneyland employee, who's naive concerning her new marriage to Jesse, but seems to have more going on in her head than she's credited for. Mother Buchanan is a stoic, gravely-voiced passive-aggressive (sometimes without the passive part) nightmare of a woman who intentionally tries to make the people around her miserable, but she has occasional flashes of humanity.

Co-creator Marc Cherry worked on a handful of failed sitcoms before finding success with "Desperate Housewives," but this is probably the closest to his big hit in terms of tone and story. We have a group of vastly different women living in suburbia, dealing with various real-life issues, experiencing bizarre adventures and spouting off venomous insults. Aside from the murder-mystery angle, the biggest difference in the two shows is that the Buchanan husbands, who were often spoken of, were seldom seen. Not surprisingly, several cast members went on to appear on the later series. Everyone expected the Buchanan ladies to have a hit on their hands... except CBS, which buried the show on Saturday nights.

Interestingly, Eileen Heckart admitted she wanted the role of Mother Buchanan because it gave her the opportunity "to play the bitch," but the renowned stage actress had difficulty adjusting to the fast-paced world of sitcoms, where dialogue can be changed in an instant. You'd hardly know judging from her wonderfully campy performance, in which her every syllable seems deliberately and appropriately punched. She and the rest of the cast all had remarkable chemistry, and each of their characters were uniquely lovable.

Looking at the show more than 20 years later, it's a little dated. Life was simpler before everyone was digitally connected which, by today's standards, makes some of the gossipy situations and revelations seem unnaturally slow to pass. There's the occasional pop-culture reference or discussed incident (such as Alex's stint streaking) which date the show to another time, and it suffers from hideous mid-90s color schemes and fashions.

Those minor nitpicks aside, there's really sharp writing, incredible characterizations and a lot of heart. It's really quite a shame that CBS didn't have more faith in it because it certainly had the potential to have been a long-running hit.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Talented Cast of Strong Women!
Sylviastel2 September 2008
I don't know why some shows get canceled. This show related to one of my co-workers when I worked at the supermarket about an overbearing mother-in-law played by the Oscar winner Eileen Heckart. Her daughters-in-law were played by Broadway professional veterans like Judith Ivey and Harriet Sansom Harris as well as soap veteran actress Charlotte Ross and Beth Broderick. The husbands were rarely shown because it was really a show centered around the relationships between the sisters-in-laws and their mother-in-law. The newest in-law was played by Charlotte Ross. Beth Broderick played the more sensual wife while Judith Ivey's character was Jewish and the oldest of all the Buchanan wives. Harriet Sansom Harris was divine as the snobby wife who is always a show stopper in any performance. Of course there was Eileen Heckart who can make a great entrance and say more with a facial expression than a thousand words.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good
manitobaman815 September 2014
I miss this show! Set in fictional Mercy, Indiana, this comedy centers around four completely different women who have only two connections to each other: they each are married to a Buchanan boy, and they each cannot stand their mother-in-law. Alex, married to Roy, is a Jewish feminist from New York City. Vivian, married to Ed, is a frumpy Hoosier housewife with two children from hell, twins Lyndon and P.J. Delilah, married to preacher Charles, is a somewhat ditzy former stripper from Corpus Christi, Texas. Bree, newly married to Jesse, is a perky Californian who used to work with her mother. They constantly are trading barbs with the cruel but hilarious Mother Buchanan, who tries as hard as she can to make their lives a living hell through meddling and manipulating, her two specialties.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Well written and well acted
evergreen_1227 February 2003
This show was great, and I don't understand why they didn't give it a chance. Instead they decided to cancel it after only 17 episodes. The whole cast was terrific and Beth Broderick and Eileen Heckart played their roles especially well. The episodes were always well written and well acted and to sum up; This show was hilarious, and it shouldn't have been cancelled so fast.
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best sitcom ever written...!
dickprlx24 June 2011
This was definitely the best series I have ever seen. It related to so many people, having relatives with whom we have nothing in common except being part of the family, and a conniving mother-in-law who wants nothing more than happiness for her sons for whom no other woman could possibly be good enough. The mischievous reactions brought upon by the 3 daughters-in-law was also very hilarious.

Emma could make me burst in laugh with just a facial expression or her unforgettable "Hellooo!" when the front door opened. Never understood why it was eliminated. Maybe was it too witty for some people, I don't know.

If you haven't seen this series, it's a must. All 17 episodes can be found on YouTube, although each broken down in 3 parts. In the meantime we can only expect that some day, one of the TV channels playing oldies will bring it back for everyone who has never had the opportunity to see it.

Whenever I am feeling down, I watch one of the episodes, and it makes me feel great.

Enjoy !
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The show that should have really made it.
mark.waltz11 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Yes, this was one of those all-women cast sitcoms that came off the thrust of the smash hits of "Golden Girls" and "Designing Women", and as created by the now famous Marc Cherry, it is a show that really should have been given a chance by CBS to make it in one consecutive time slot rather than be moved all over the map. Oscar winner Eileen Heckart could eat a pickle and be funny, and even with her opening line, "Hello!", just wrecked the joint. Of course, her cue, "What could be so dangerous with a sweet old lady?" as the doorbell rang and she stood there. Ice water tosses off her veins as she speaks each line, and her reactions to the quips against her are just priceless.

"Aren't you just going to huff and puff and blow the house down?" daughter-in-law Judith Ivey asks, to which Mother Buchannan (Heckart) replies, "There's that lovely Semitic humor I just love", and only someone like Heckart could get away with spouting such a racist line and gathering laughs. She's a divorced mother of four sons, all now married to women she supposedly despises, but with the sons pretty much off screen in most of the episodes, she does show an affection for her four daughters-in-law: liberal Ivey, staunch Republican Harriet Harris (so delightfully prim and proper, a far cry from her many Broadway roles in which she playfully spoofs pickle-pussed society matrons), Beth Broderick (a former bar dancer who married Heckart's preacher son), and sweet, naive Charlotte Ross, who once worked as a dancer at Disneyland.

Every character has a developed past, whether it be Ivey being arrested at one point for streaking through Times Square; Harris, once accused in High School of being "easy" to which Ross responds, "You're the most difficult person I know!", Broderick, whose past is called into question when as Minister's wife, she is next in line to become President of the Women's Auxiliary, and Ross, who in the very first episode, gains the respect of the women by standing up to Heckart by not wearing her wedding dress. "Please be our leader!", Harris pleads. The acidic dialog has references to Walt Disney thawing out, Heckart not getting a Christmas present from Ivey because she didn't utilize the cemetery plot that she got from the previous year, and Heckart's delicious response to all the church ladies who are against Broderick becoming ladies auxiliary present. "Isn't it wonderful that they can make computer screens from all your empty vodka bottles?", Heckart tells the snooty Gretchen Wyler, proving that underneath her alleged dislike for these women, she actually adores them.

There's also a very funny episode where Heckart demands that the women escort her to an old friend's funeral, and finds out that she's being buried in a casket the size of a piano box. At first, the women snicker behind Heckart's back, but when she joins in and begins the sarcastic comments with them, it really is the key to the mother/daughter relationship they have. Like "Golden Girls", "Designing Women" and "Murphy Brown", "The 5 Mrs. Buchannans" took on some tough issues, including surrogate motherhood, child abuse and feminism, showing both sides of the issues with humor, class and often truth-telling laughs that society often tries to sweep under the p.c. rug. In particular, Harris being arrested for spanking her bratty twins in public, stands out, while Ivey's feminist past making her realizing how being a wife and mother while running a small business has been overlooked because of traditional women's roles in small communities.

Heckart, who had started off on Broadway in the mid 1940's and became a popular film and TV character actress, would continue to work on T.V. and in films and on stage, ending her career with a heart-wrenching performance in "The Waverly Gallery". Her life on and off stage has been captured in a wonderful book by her son, Luke Yankee, while the rest of the cast has gone onto some other great projects. Harris and Ivey, in fact, are two of the busiest actresses on the Broadway stage, and I'm sure they picked up a thing or two about stealing scenes from the magnificent Eileen.

As Emma Buchannan said here, "So much wit. So little inheritance!"
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Must See - Outstanding
scruff2815 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I only recently found this series through Youtube (being only 2 years old when it started) and I'm just so disappointed that there are only 17 episodes, this series should never have been cancelled.

It is very rare to have a comedy that is actually laugh out loud, but this is one of those few, I just can't help bursting into laughter at various points during most episodes - even though it's 90s, the humour is still hilariously funny. The writing is great.

And the cast are outstanding, you could not ask for a better line up of funny, strong and individual actresses. Each character is completely different, and you relate to each one instantly in a different way and for different reasons. I love the entire cast but the two stand-outs are Eileen Heckart (I don't know if it's just me, but she reminds me of Carol Burnett) and, especially, Beth Broderick who both totally embody their roles and prove themselves to be fantastic actresses with the sincerity they bring to an entire range of emotions and situations. Broderick plays the role of Delilah perfectly, coming across as hilarious, charming, sweet, sensual, ditzy, intelligent and so caring all in one! Also love the accent, it's so cute!

The story lines keep the audience thoroughly entertained and one of the best things about this show is the way that they tackle serious issues, such as not being able to have a child, with such sensitivity whilst infusing it humour at the same time (as is often the case in real life) so not to be depressing.

I just can't get enough of The 5 Mrs Buchanans, I've watched each episode several times and they still make me laugh every time. This series is a must see!
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
My Favorite Show
MsMacMouse-16 December 2008
This show should NEVER have been canceled. I've been trying to find a DVD of the season to no avail. The casting was superb. The only thing that could have been any better would have been to cast Olympia DuCaucas (sp?)as the mother-in-law and Cameron Diaz as the bride, but I loved the actors that were cast in both of those parts. How I wish someone could see its potential and make the series into a movie. I am generally quite critical of sit-coms, but I actually waited each week to see this one. For someone who seldom laughs out loud, I did quite a bit of it during the show. I can't recommend it enough and will wait patiently to see if someone has the good sense to revive it despite it's brief appearance. And I'll be its biggest fan!
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Lost Modern Classic
ksdilauri5 July 2020
More than one quality series was cancelled in its first season by the network (here, CBS) because some idiot decided to bury it in a lousy time slot. So it was with 'The Five Mrs. Buchanans', and no one has even had the decency to release the existing episodes as a collectors' DVD. Wonderful writing, and the cast is flawless. It deserves a Collectors' edition.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Slightly odd series.
wkozak22124 December 2020
I remember this series to a certain extent. It was ok. The 2 things I remember? You hardly ever saw the husbands. Also, when they made an episode around the dradel. They even sang a song about it.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Another That Should Be Brought Out From the Vaults!
TelevisionJunkie5 February 2001
I can't believe CBS killed "The 5 Mrs. Buchanans!" The cast was superb and the dialogue was hysterical. The situations could be corny at times, but nearly every sitcom drastically improves if given enough time. The sad thing is that this show didn't need much improvement. From the start it had a clever sharp-tongued wit about it that you rarely find in new sitcoms -- very close to the early seasons of "Designing Women." Unfortunately, CBS decided to bury this on Saturday nights with minuscule ratings. I thought perhaps Lifetime Network might end up with it, but alas, 7 years later it's still in the vaults. Quite a shame since it really had all the makings of a hit show!
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of best sit coms I have ever seen, if not the best
kimberlyannesmith-843733 December 2020
I remember waiting each week to watch this show. And over the years I have talked about it many times. It was funny, witty, beautifully done, it was written well and the characters where played by perfect people. I have always hoped they would bring it back. I think they could bring this out or one exactly like it, and it would do well today. The issues with mother in laws is timeless. And the old episodes of this show is as funny now as it was all those years ago. I hope and pray they can find a way to bring back this show, even if we have to get new actors, as we could all use a little humor today. This humor was just plain fun. No one will play these characters better than the ones in the original series, but something like this would be great. So much story line here.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed