The Rats (1955) Poster

(1955)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
After the fall and before the wall.
dbdumonteil14 November 2007
Immediate background: After "the crimson pirate" and a -failed-remake of Feyder's "Le Grand Jeu" in France,Robert Siodmak was back in Germany.He did not direct in his native land for more than twenty years,since "Brennendes Geheimnis" .In between,he made brilliant movies ,some of them are among the classics of film noir.

Siodmak finds back a humiliated country .He came in blaring in 1929 with "Menschen am Sonntag" and with "die Ratten" came back the same way.He was helped by two of the most talented German thespians of the era: Maria Schell and Cürd Jurgens plus a fine supporting cast including Gustav Knuth people outside Germany know essentially as Sissi's father in the famous Marischka saga.

The prologue sets the tone: a distraught frenzied Schell tries to get to Berlin West.When the soldiers stop her,they discover she's holding a rag doll.The film is a long flashback.

Siodmak depicts a murky atmosphere ,with mean characters ,the rats.The subject is that of the great melodramas of the forties ,but the director displays a gutsy realism which is more European.

Memorable scenes: The bric a brac in M.John's house where his brother-in-law is doing bad things behind his back and where Pauline gives birth to her child.

The baptism and the funeral of two children,two scenes which recall Abel Gance's "Venus Aveugle"(1942) The walk through the Christmas market(Siodmak often uses the pom-pom of the fairground music ,notably during the cast and credits) where Pauline buys a teddy bear.

The ball of the new year's eve when a Singerin is bawling out a horrible ditty about having fun.

Siodmak seems to remember his earlier films such as "Voruntersuchung" ( a contrast between the tragedy and the fair and the fireworks where people rejoice) and "Stürme der Leidenschaft" aka" Tumultes" (the knife).

Like this? try These....

"The old maid" Edmund Goulding 1939

"The great lie" EDmund Goulding 1941

"To each his own" Mitchell Leisen 1946

"La voleuse" Jean Chapot 1966 (starring Romy Schneider)
25 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
another good maria Schell classic
cynthiahost18 April 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This plot is almost an exploitation type story.The kind of films that were being made in the united states and even Germany.Maria Schell plays Pauline, who gets job at a storage company called Karl Johns, owner portrayed by Gustav Knuth.Heidimarie Hatheyer, who had starred in the anti disable propaganda film Ich Klage I in 1941,plays his wife Anna John.Kurd Jurgens portrayed her lazy brother who works for the company Bruno.What's the problem? Pauline has out of wedlock pregnancy,Abortion is unhealthy and was not safe at this time beside being illegal.Anne is also pregnant too.Anna makes a deal with her that she would raise the baby up as if it was hers.She agrees with it.but eventually starts to regret it ,which is perfectly natural for a mother.Anna gets her lazy no good Brother to throw her off.Now it seems she has two babies.But only one is taken out in public.Confusion happens When Pauline decides to see her baby ,she actually seeing Anna's and Her baby is being christen. She takes the baby she thinks is hers to the train station.It's sick and eventually dies.She takes off.On New years eve she and Kurd has a fight .I think he's trying to murder her.But she kill him first.Later on and tries to commit suicide cause she realizes she did wrong and let Pauline know that her baby is still alive and she can have him back.A heart warming ending.Robert Siodmack. directed this.A good example of post war German film classics
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Not one of Siodmak's finest
Horst_In_Translation4 April 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"Die Ratten" or "The Rats" is a German black-and-white sound film from over 60 years ago. The director is Robert Siodmak, already and Oscar nominee at this point and back from Hollywood. Here he works with a couple big names from German cinema. The ones I heard of are Maria Schell, Curd Jürgens and Ilse Steppat, the latter two played villains in Bond films later in their careers. The writer is Jochen Huth and he adapted Gerhart Hauptmann's play for the screen here. As a result, several of the actors were nominated for German Film Awards, even some I did not mention before. But the 1950s probably weren't the best decade for German cinema. And this film's success here is another example. It is really not a great watch. Schell plays her part really well, but I struggled with the script on several occasions. All the wishy washy and back and forth in terms of her wish to give up / keep her child made this one not too realistic and the mix-up at the end almost has a comedic touch. So much chaos, so much goes wrong in this film. I would have wished for more realism. Yes there are a couple good moments, but those weren't frequent enough for a film over 90 minutes and I can see why this film is almost unknown today, even here in Germany. It just isn't a great achievement and the big shock moment at the end really just makes my head shake. Looks like they wanted to go out the most memorable way, but to me it was just a desperate attempt to distract from the mediocrity in the 1.5 hours before that. I do not recommend "Die Ratten". Thumbs down.
2 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed