Dutiful But Dumb (1941) User Reviews

Paparazzi - 1941 Version

[ccthemovieman-1 · 9/10 · 14 February 2008]

Here, the boys - "Click, Clack and Cluck" - pretend to be newspaper cameramen and are given the assignment of taking some pictures of a Hollywood celebrity couple

The boys were in prime condition in the early 1940s and they are fun to watch in here. It's just a little weird watching this in early '08 with all the Britney Spears-paparazzi nonsense. The Stooges look like such innocents compared to the modern-day piranhas.....but the mentality is the same. Invade someone's privacy? No problem. However, it's funny when you see things like Curly's head on a platter on top of a dinner table. Anything to get the picture!

By the way, Stanley Brown and Marjorie Deanne are great as "Percival DePuyster" and his gorgeous wife. Unfortunately, their scenes are completed after just two-and-a-half minutes.

Most of the movie takes place in "Vulgaria," a place our Dimwits are assigned after they mess up in the dark room. They are assigned to take some photos there because "No cameras are allowed, under penalty of death," the boss figures he has nothing to lose by sending these three idiots.

Most of this Three Stooges short are a bunch of continuous slapstick gags. Some are still funny to this day; some are stupid, but they come so frequently, you just go with the flow.

I did laugh out loud at a number of things Curly said and did. I think he was a comic genius, and I don't say that about many people. In one scene, the boys are lined up to be shot. "Hey, wait a minute," says Moe. "According to International Law, we are entitled to a last request."

"Yeah," says Curly, "this is Request Night!"

When the boys ask for "a last smoke," Curly pulls out a three-foot cigar!

Bud Jamison, a frequent contributor to the Stooges films, is a hoot with his fake Eastern European accent.

man v clam

[SnoopyStyle · 8/10 · 27 February 2020]

The boys are photographers Cluck, Clack, Click from Whack magazine. Their candid paparazzi attempt goes badly and they are sent to the country of Vulgaria. They don't realize that cameras are prohibited and photography is a death sentence. They unknowingly run into an execution and walk themselves into prison.

I generally love the Stooges with Curly. The Clam v Curly scene is the distillation of why I love Curly. It's such a simple and pure comedic premise. It highlights the comedic genius of Curly and the pure goodness of his persona. The overall premise is simple and everybody loves the name Vulgaria.

The Stooges As Paparazzi

[bkoganbing · 7/10 · 26 April 2010]

The team of Howard, Fine, and Howard are newspaper photographers assigned to come back with pictures of an eloping celebrity. Curly actually gets the picture, but the devil's in the developing and it almost gets them fired.

But the boss instead gives them an assignment to photograph the Balkan police state country of Vulgaria, reasoning that if he loses the Stooges it won't be much of a loss. It's actually against the law to even possess photographic equipment.

But our Three Stooges go in where folks are fleeing and wind up in all kinds of trouble. This must have been a very popular short back in the day, satirizing as it does police states that were all over Europe in that year.

Curly gets several minutes alone in this short to do the famous burlesque gag which Abbott&Costello did a variation on called Oysters in the Oyster Stew. Curly orders some clam chowder with some really fresh clams in it. His struggle and really violent reaction puts them all in harm's way.

Dutiful But Dumb is worth seeing for that alone.

Great Three Stooges short!

[Movie Nuttball · 10/10 · 13 July 2004]

The Three Stooges has always been some of the many actors that I have loved. I love just about every one of the shorts that they have made. I love all six of the Stooges (Curly, Shemp, Moe, Larry, Joe, and Curly Joe)! All of the shorts are hilarious and also star many other great actors and actresses which a lot of them was in many of the shorts! In My opinion The Three Stooges is some of the greatest actors ever and is the all time funniest comedy team!

This has always been one of My favorite Three Stooges shorts! The entire thing is extremely hilarious! The scene where Curly performs music in the radio and the restaurant scene is great and when the Stooges come out of the building dressed as high officers are so funny! Bud Jamison as usual puts on a great performance! This is a super funny Three Stooges short!

Pictures and Oysters

[Michael_Elliott · 10 August 2011]

Dutiful But Dumb (1941)

*** (out of 4)

Moe, Larry and Curly are working as photographers for Whack magazine when they're ordered to get a picture of a famous movie star on his wedding night. They get the picture just fine but Curly messes up on developing it. The boss is about to fire them but instead sends them to Vulgaria to get a picture of a new ray gun. What the boys don't know is that it's illegal to take pictures in Vulgaria and the penalty is death. I've read a few negative reviews of this film but I certainly don't understand them as this Stooges short contains some very big laughs from start to finish. The stuff dealing with trying to take a picture of the actor works well because of the rather hilarious ways the boys finally get the picture. The final sequence of the film has the now famous bit of Curly ordering some oyster soup and getting a lot more in it than he expected. The middle portions were the best in my opinion because there's a downright hilarious bit where a man is about to be shot for taking a picture when the boys walk up to him and the firing squad asking to take pictures. This entire sequence is beautifully directed and acted and it really shows how funny these guys could be.

Vintage Stooges

[tnothnagle · 8/10 · 20 February 2005]

Picking a favorite Stooges short, or even identifying one as good or bad, is a little like doing the same with a Simpsons episode -- or a Bob Dylan song. You know what you're going to get, and once you accept the premise of what they are all about, you simply enjoy the ride.

That being said, this short is from the Three Stooges' best era, in my estimation. They had been producing shorts for nearly a decade, and their comic genius was beginning to be recognized. More and more, the Stooges were allowed to be the fully realized characters that would make them memorable 70 years later.. instead of just sight gags and slapstick. Plots were a little bit better thought-out.. sometimes downright clever, as in "Dutiful but Dumb". 1939-1943 was the golden era. In the post-war era, the shorts became a bit over-wrought and over-thought, and lacked the timeless innocence of their predecessors.

I know I haven't really written anything about "Dutiful but Dumb".. but then again, no spoilers :) Look, as I said at the top, you either appreciate the stooges comedy or you don't. That about sums it up.

average

[courtad6 · 6/10 · 25 March 2000]

This is not one of the best Three Stooges shorts by any means. There are some rather dull moments, and scenes meant to be funny don't really generate many laughs. The premise is a good one: Sending three inept photographers to Vulgaria (a great name for a country) where cameras are forbidden. Unfortunately, they weren't able to pull off as many laughs as in some of their other work. For high quality Stooges shorts, check out "Three Little Beers" or "In the Sweet Pie and Pie."

"Your brains need developing!"

[slymusic · 1 September 2009]

In "Dutiful but Dumb", directed by Del Lord, the Three Stooges (Curly being the third Stooge) are employed as magazine photographers Click, Clack, and Cluck. Of course, they don't know what they're doing! After they fail to produce a photo of a movie star, their editor sends them off to the fictional town of Vulgaria, presumably to get them out of the way, where cameras are forbidden on the penalty of death.

Highlights: By far the best and most celebrated scene in "Dutiful but Dumb" is the ending, in which Curly becomes the hapless victim of a live oyster in a bowl of soup. Moe and Larry slam the windows down onto the heads of their pursuers, and Curly "plays" their heads with a pair of xylophone mallets. A man becomes frightened of a camera accordion on Larry's head. And listen to the Stooges' Vulgarian football chant!

In addition to the Stooges, "Dutiful but Dumb" boasts an excellent supporting cast that includes Vernon Dent, Bud Jamison, Fred Kelsey, Eddie Laughton, Chester Conklin, and Bruce Bennett.