Don's Plum (2001)
9/10
Perfect epilogue to a Gatsby marathon
24 May 2024
Imagine embarking on a cinematic journey through the roaring opulence and tragic romance of F. Scott Fitzgerald's *The Great Gatsby*, first through Robert Redford's refined portrayal in the 1974 adaptation, then plunging into the lavish, modernized 2013 Baz Luhrmann version with Leonardo DiCaprio and Tobey Maguire. Each film offers a distinct lens on the enigmatic Jay Gatsby and his pursuit of the American Dream. But how does one unwind from such an emotionally charged double feature? Enter *Don's Plum*, a 2001 indie film that serves as an unexpected yet oddly perfect epilogue to this marathon, providing a raw and contemporary counterpoint to Gatsby's world.

*Don's Plum*, directed by R. D. Robb, features Leonardo DiCaprio and Tobey Maguire, much like the 2013 *Gatsby*. However, the similarities between these films run deeper than just the shared cast. Where *The Great Gatsby* examines the decadence and disillusionment of the Jazz Age, *Don's Plum* strips away the glitz to reveal the disenchanted youth of the late 20th century, grappling with existential ennui in the aftermath of the American Dream.

After immersing yourself in the grandiose tragedy of Gatsby, transitioning to *Don's Plum* is like stepping into the raw, unfiltered reality behind the glamorous facade. Both films, in their own ways, explore themes of identity, ambition, and the relentless pursuit of an ideal. While Gatsby's tale is one of opulent parties and tragic love, *Don's Plum* presents a group of friends navigating the more mundane, yet equally poignant, struggles of everyday life in Los Angeles. This stark contrast underscores a continuous thread of searching for meaning and connection in an ever-evolving American landscape.

In *Don's Plum*, DiCaprio and Maguire portray characters vastly different from their Gatsby counterparts. DiCaprio's Derek is brash and confrontational, a far cry from the enigmatic and charming Jay Gatsby. Maguire's Ian is introspective and reserved, contrasting sharply with the observant yet naïve Nick Carraway. These performances showcase the actors' range and provide a refreshing, if jarring, shift from their roles in Gatsby. Watching them in these stripped-down, raw roles serves as a reminder of the multifaceted nature of human experience.

The setting of *Don's Plum* - a nondescript diner where friends gather to talk through their insecurities and frustrations - contrasts sharply with Gatsby's lavish parties and sprawling mansions. Yet, this simplicity allows for an intimate exploration of character and dialogue, highlighting the universal themes of disillusionment and the search for identity that permeate both Gatsby adaptations. The diner becomes a microcosm of a generation, much like Gatsby's mansion serves as a symbol of the Jazz Age's excesses.

After witnessing the rise and fall of Jay Gatsby's dream, *Don's Plum* brings viewers back to a grounded, relatable reality. The film's unscripted, improvisational style further enhances this sense of authenticity, offering a slice-of-life glimpse into the struggles of young adulthood. It's a stark reminder that beneath the surface of grand aspirations and glittering facades lies a deeper, often unspoken, human experience.

Moreover, the transition from the stylistic excess of Baz Luhrmann's *Gatsby* to the minimalist approach of *Don's Plum* mirrors the cultural shift from the aspirational to the introspective. It's a journey from the external to the internal, from the collective experience of a bygone era to the personal introspections of contemporary youth.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed