This us a tough one to rate because I'm aware it is a very intelligent, well made, and intentionally challenging film. The performances are outstanding, and the issues tackled of huge importance. It has a lot to say and it warrants many watches so it can be explored and discussed. It provokes, certainly. I cannot criticise it for what it is. I admire it and am intimidated by it.
However, in terms of enjoyment, or not even enjoyment, but the emotional journey it took me on I would rate it low. I'm sure it is more revealing of what a philistine I am than any fault of the film itself, when I say it left me somewhat frustrated, confused and dissatisfied. For those wanting entertainment or a clear narrative arc this is one to avoid. I'm definitely not a 'mainstream ' film lover.... I like plenty of indie, world cinema and films that challenge and try new things. I want a film that makes me think and feel and learn sometimes. Occasionally I like a lightweight easy watch like Barbie or The Duke. But this was too obscure for me at the time I watched it. I'm glad a saw it as it was talked about a lot and my curiosity hs been satiated. BUT, i need to ask so many questions and am left pretty uncertain about it. The ending annoyed me. Maybe I need too much spoon feeding? Whatever. Some will love it. Others may recognise it is 'excellent ', but not for them. And, of course, there are those who will hate it and just switch it off after 15mins, or dodge it altogether.....
My enjoyment/satisfaction: 4* Quality/style/performances/intelligence: 8*(?)
However, in terms of enjoyment, or not even enjoyment, but the emotional journey it took me on I would rate it low. I'm sure it is more revealing of what a philistine I am than any fault of the film itself, when I say it left me somewhat frustrated, confused and dissatisfied. For those wanting entertainment or a clear narrative arc this is one to avoid. I'm definitely not a 'mainstream ' film lover.... I like plenty of indie, world cinema and films that challenge and try new things. I want a film that makes me think and feel and learn sometimes. Occasionally I like a lightweight easy watch like Barbie or The Duke. But this was too obscure for me at the time I watched it. I'm glad a saw it as it was talked about a lot and my curiosity hs been satiated. BUT, i need to ask so many questions and am left pretty uncertain about it. The ending annoyed me. Maybe I need too much spoon feeding? Whatever. Some will love it. Others may recognise it is 'excellent ', but not for them. And, of course, there are those who will hate it and just switch it off after 15mins, or dodge it altogether.....
My enjoyment/satisfaction: 4* Quality/style/performances/intelligence: 8*(?)