Searchanddestroy-1 and Aylmer and Theo Robertson and OzMovieWatcher, you are completely wrong because you don't know anything at all, firstly, the detachments in the film is good for its time and despite problems with sound during gun recoil and plywood of some tanks, the film is very the battle scenes are well staged, the sound, editing and decoration, the fact that the film shows heroically detachments, there is nothing wrong with that, they often participated in battles and showed themselves worthy there, although the film embellishes them from a pro-Soviet position, but evenly also, some enemy at the gate, on the contrary, falsely demonizes them, presenting an anti-Soviet position, and although the film really has little dramaturgy compared to other Soviet films, it is still present, although the film itself probably was not intended so, it is also incorrect to compare it with the film Stalingrad, it came out in 93 after the collapse of the USSR, and even after that you can remember some kind of enemy at the gates of 2002 and how Soviet soldiers are falsely shown there, and Frank Wisbar's HUNDE, WOLT IHR EWIG LEBEN, of course, is not so anti-Soviet like a doctor from Stalingrad in 1958, but in general, in terms of showing the enemy, he is no different from a Goryachiy sneg and finally, empathy is possible and necessary, since they did not have any superiority, both qualitative and quantitative, and there was no actual small saturn operation at the beginning of the German counteroffensive , the action of which takes place in the film, initially at the beginning of 1943 a large-scale operation Saturn was planned, but due to the start of the German counteroffensive it had to be canceled and then it was redone into Operation Small Saturn and was started after the events of the film and in general the story should not be based on films study.