1/10
Very generic and clean Narnia/Wheel of time kind of show
3 September 2022
I was so excited for last 3 years to dive into Middle Earth one more time. Deeply hurt and disappointed, can not connect visually or emotionally with the show. Watched both episodes twice in English as well as in my native language just so I can force myself to love this show. Not even close, did not like it.

Elves look like men, lack that ethereal glow and demeanor. PJ captured it perfectly, every movement, every word they said had a impact that we are looking at a superior creation of Iluvatar.

Even after 4 hours (2X) of this show, I still do not feel connected to these stories or their fate. As a LOTR fan I will watch every episode in hope to feel connected.

You can see that village of men was created a few months ago. It does not give a feeling of middle earth. It was exactly like Wheel of Time show. Amazon you messed it up real bad.

Dwarves are the best till now, love Durin and Disa. Acting is on point, feels great. Harfoots are good to have in this show, a nice unexpected addition.
23 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed