5/10
Pretentious and artificial
3 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Jane Campion wanted to revisit Brokeback Mountain but this time made by a woman. Beautiful postcard landscapes, smart camera (too smart), good actors . Yet the whole film looks fake. None of the characters are believable, the dialogs are artificial, the pace of the film is irregular with endless closeups full of supposed emotions. The music is a total disaster.. it just doesn't stop and the violins get on your nerves !

The dead calf is supposed to have died from anthrax or killed by a wolf as explained before.

It's totally unclear what Peter does with the dead calf. Isn't he dissecting As he did with the rabbit? No! It requires to read about the ending to understand what really happened. The story of the hides that Phil uses to make a gift to his new potential 'lover - friend ' is not believable. Phil has suddenly become a young girl in love, quite ridiculous!

Overall an awkward and failed movie that wants to be original but remain artificial and pretentious...
17 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed