This is based on a historical novel , loosely based on actual events. What is true religion, Catholicism or Shamanism? What is the best religion for these northern natives.? They live in a very harsh environment ,surrounded by hostile enemy tribes. The religion of the white Christ is not really suited to that. French colonialism and religion bring dependence, disease, and alcohol. All deadly to their civilization. The Huron tribe that accepts Christianity is wiped out in the end after an epidemic weakens them.
The fathers faith is kind of half baked. It makes it look like the priesthood is full of semi dysfunctional beings, full of odd motivations. Bringing the true religion? Did they ask for it? No!
This story is very accurate in the historic sense. The scenery and cinematography are top notch. The acting is excellent and the Indian characters are individuals, not stereotypes. It is a fine movie. I just don't understand the mediocre reviews. .Maybe the subject matter,historic period , and general lack of understanding of the Canadian Catholic- French historic context ,for Americans, is why. Somebody mentions the French and Indian War? That happened about 125 years + or - after these events....Dances With Wolves compared to this ,is a simplistic American oriented cartoon, my opinion. I enjoyed BR very much.
Review of Black Robe
