"If This Be Sin" (1949) stars Myrna Loy in a rôle definitely far removed from her image as the "half-caste" she played so often at the beginning of her career or the deliciously witty comedic wife of William Powell in the wonderful series of films, "The Thin Man" detective features. Here, along with Roger Livesey as her husband, Peggy Cummins as her step-daughter, and Richard Greene as her secret love (and lover), she plays a wife whose barrister husband lives for his work, at which he is a master, while she is relegated to the woman in his life, a showpiece, but not much else, though he doesn't even realize the fact. The entire plot is the sort of melodrama that could indeed play out in real life - - - until Greene actually falls for Loy's much younger step-daughter - - - who's already been infatuated with Greene... The ending comes out of nineteenth century novels and is ridiculous... HOWEVER, Loy and the rest of the crew are such professionals that it was a good watch. Can't say I'd recommend this necessarily, but it wasn't a chore. The rest of us can all suspend credulity every once in a while.
What's interesting about this film to me is that it was made up entirely of a British cast except Loy. Even Elizabeth Allan and Wilfrid Hyde-White show up. Directed, however, by Gregory Ratoff, interestingly enough. This was certainly a diversion for Loy. It gave her some meat in a rôle. Only the year before she'd been seen in "Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House" and just prior to that "The Senator Was Indiscreet", but her parts were secondary to the male leads. Here she had a chance to mope and tear up and chew and, and, and... Good performance, but the script is - well, it's just...
What's interesting about this film to me is that it was made up entirely of a British cast except Loy. Even Elizabeth Allan and Wilfrid Hyde-White show up. Directed, however, by Gregory Ratoff, interestingly enough. This was certainly a diversion for Loy. It gave her some meat in a rôle. Only the year before she'd been seen in "Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House" and just prior to that "The Senator Was Indiscreet", but her parts were secondary to the male leads. Here she had a chance to mope and tear up and chew and, and, and... Good performance, but the script is - well, it's just...