All the stories were decent but had weird over the top supernatural endings. The 2nd story was obviously the best followed by the 1st, 4th, wrap around, then 3rd. I will say the thing thats missing from the TFTH sequels, is that the moral of the stories are too conventional and simple, not like the 1st movie where you could play it in any urban school, detention/community center etc and it was powerful enough to scare at least a couple people straight