Update - I initially thought they had changed the format of the show, but now the original series is back I realise this was a separate show.
It's similar (with the shorter defined time period) to other shows out there with the credibility of the original series.
It's a great watch with how they dissect the animal and survive with no tools. You don't get the involvement with the participants as they will change each week, so again comparing it to Alone, not as much fulfilment from watching. Compared to other shows of the same ilk, it's great.
I'm only 2 episodes in....but the format?!
Alone was the only real proper survival show. No help, no timeframe, totally 'alone' where the mind is as much of an enemy as anything else.
I will still watch this as I trust the people to do it properly, but it's practically turned into naked and afraid. That show has its place but, for me, Alone sat on a lofty position above all other survival shows. They used to build cabins, traps and the shared joy when they found or caught food was immense, the sorrow when a fish fell back in to the water equally so.
This specific comment will get dated but particularly now during a covid19 lockdown period, seeing people survive on only what they can find to survive, is inspirational. I found it so in prior seasons regardless.
There is a camera crew there which goes against the whole essence of original Alone, never mind the actual name of the show. I loved the original format of last man/woman/person standing, like other reviews here you get emotionally attached to contestants. Instances when they got sent home for medical reasons hurt, there was a measure of shared devastation.
I'd need to check, but this may be my first review I've ever made on IMDb, that's how strongly I feel! Which then begs the question whether this is right forum for my vociferous albeit sanguine anger/disappointment at the change in format.
I like these kind of shows so will still watch, but what seemed like the only proper orginal survival format out there has been changed detrimentally to be similar to others.
It's similar (with the shorter defined time period) to other shows out there with the credibility of the original series.
It's a great watch with how they dissect the animal and survive with no tools. You don't get the involvement with the participants as they will change each week, so again comparing it to Alone, not as much fulfilment from watching. Compared to other shows of the same ilk, it's great.
I'm only 2 episodes in....but the format?!
Alone was the only real proper survival show. No help, no timeframe, totally 'alone' where the mind is as much of an enemy as anything else.
I will still watch this as I trust the people to do it properly, but it's practically turned into naked and afraid. That show has its place but, for me, Alone sat on a lofty position above all other survival shows. They used to build cabins, traps and the shared joy when they found or caught food was immense, the sorrow when a fish fell back in to the water equally so.
This specific comment will get dated but particularly now during a covid19 lockdown period, seeing people survive on only what they can find to survive, is inspirational. I found it so in prior seasons regardless.
There is a camera crew there which goes against the whole essence of original Alone, never mind the actual name of the show. I loved the original format of last man/woman/person standing, like other reviews here you get emotionally attached to contestants. Instances when they got sent home for medical reasons hurt, there was a measure of shared devastation.
I'd need to check, but this may be my first review I've ever made on IMDb, that's how strongly I feel! Which then begs the question whether this is right forum for my vociferous albeit sanguine anger/disappointment at the change in format.
I like these kind of shows so will still watch, but what seemed like the only proper orginal survival format out there has been changed detrimentally to be similar to others.