This musical romance has a light, melancholy tone and features charming performances by Davies and Powell, as well as great support from Charles Ruggles, Rains, and a host of excellent character actors. The cinematography by the great George Folsey is lush and dreamlike, as one would expect in a romance directed by Frank Borzage, who never made a bad film. Some of said Davies was too old for the role, but I disagree. She was radiant, youthful, and charming in every scene. I also disagree with the reviews that cited her as better in comedies. This film is light in tone, and has many comedic sequences. Davies seems right at home in these early American settings and Orry Kelly's beautiful period costumes.
Review of Hearts Divided
