This episode is at the very least deserving of a 9/10. It had every emotion you wanted in a supernatural episode and more! One of the best episodes of the season, easily...Great performances by Jensen and Jared! It almost had the feeling of a season finale. It had Big time story and character development. It will go down as one of the more underrated Supernatural episodes and really shows how much The Winchester's/Castiel care for Jack. I also loved Lily Sunder story. Great set up and payoff for only a character who was technically in two episodes. Great writing and exciting pace!