6/10
The Romy Schneider show
5 July 2010
Le Combat dans l'île is a political film (at least in its clothing) about a reactionary, the racist Clément (Jean-Louis Trintignant); his childhood friend Paul (Henri Serre), left-wing printer; and love interest Anne (Romy Schneider).

Clément and Anne are in a rut, she an ex-actress, now a kept woman, he a son of a wealthy industrialist, very serious and eager to kill lefty politicians. She likes to pass herself around, wedding ring or no, he treats her as if she were personal property, they are deserving of one another.

Anne's slatternly behaviour appears to be foreplay for unhealthy sex as Clément physically abuses her and she submits. Trintignant is not really up to the part, not in the mindset of the character, but Schneider really wows. The movie is imbued with an almost unhealthy enthusiasm for her beauty and energy, she pelts the camera with daisies, as it pursues her. That is the soul of the movie, images of Romy Schneider. For more after this fashion see her in L'enfer d'Henri-Georges Clouzot, a documentary containing footage from an extremely ambitious Clouzot production that collapsed as a result of obsession. L'enfer is the concept of fascination with Romy Schneider taken to ruinous extremes.

These early scenes are accompanied by an ominous and weary soundtrack, which was very noirish. I would have been perfectly content for the movie to continue in this manner and end fatalistically, but the film increasingly goes for a political angle. That is to say the movie becomes about Anne's growth and she redeems herself under the wing of Paul.

This second half of the movie is dissatisfying, firstly in that it is quite "on the nose" politically, Clément is shown as being part of a shady international network of fascists holding old grudges, whereas of course Paul lives the simple life. Clément's communist equivalents were just as militant and obscure, but the movie doesn't show this. The element of personal growth here is also not very satisfying, generally in the bildungsroman form you get personal growth being achieved only by painstaking efforts, Anne here is doing little more than changing bedfellows and having a nice stay in the country on Paul's tab.

The action sequence at the end of the film (which the title refers to) is handled with an absolute minimum of suspense and is bizarrely anticlimactic. My own view is that there were conflicting desires from producer and director, Malle wanted to make a political film (a shot across the bow to other directors who supported the French occupation of Algeria), Cavalier is interested in getting as much footage of Schneider as possible. Watch Cavalier's diary film Irène to see how extremely fascinated he is by womanly beauty: "Oh beautiful woman, intelligent and lively, who confirms the planet's faith in the quality of the human race." Filming beautiful and intelligent women like Romy Schneider can become the entire point of a movie and I think Le Combat dans l'île is an example of this. Purists such as myself resent the awkward trappings and pretence in the film that distract from its real nature.
17 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed