4/10
Only a wizard could answer this one....
22 November 2009
Some users have blamed David Yates for this bad movie. As the movie is part American I would say the one responsible for all the nonsense (apart from the producers of course) is the screenplay writer :Steve Kloves. This being said, this film seems to miss all the essential notions from the book. Although adapting a book is never easy, this film shows no effort at all has been made to bring the real story to the audience. If you do not know the story from the book, you may even sit there wondering what it's all about because there's hardly anything that's explained properly at all... The only true nice scene is the one from the quidditch game... well choreographed. The rest is a total waste. How are they going to explain away all the inconsistencies they've created when the next film comes, this is truly a question only a wizard could answer !
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed