7/10
More drama than comedy
1 January 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This film, which mostly tells a dramatic story about a mother who gives away her 15-month son Niki to a stranger on a train, and then tries to get it back, is only in some parts (especially those with Paul Hörbiger) a comedy, but mostly a sentimental drama. Tissues recommended.

Yet, I found it a worthwhile watch, if only to get some feeling for 1950s Germany, as reflected in movies. Hörbiger plays his part, from denial to helplessness to sympathy to "ownership" of the baby, very nicely. The change in character of Hardy Krüger's young husband, from selfish bastard to engaged stepfather, is not so well motivated, I find.

All in all, a nicely done piece with some interesting scenes (the church sequence in particular, or the orphanry kids). 7/10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed