When I saw this in the theater, I don't think I got it fully. I thought it was funny and smart, but I wasn't sure it held up to all the raves. But I was compelled to rent it this weekend, and knowing the story already allowed for me to enjoy the visual subtleties and the warped dialogue. Oh, the warped dialogue is awesome! This is funny funny stuff. Slightly more realistic than "Rushmore", but every bit as good. The acting is excellent - Reese Witherspoon is the best young actress around today.